3 ms·
Very different contexts. Before human heart transplantation was available, you could pick someone with severe heart disease but otherwise in good condition as
by ceejayoz 4y ago
Very different contexts.
Before human heart transplantation was available, you could pick someone with severe heart disease but otherwise in good condition as a test candidate. It was entirely ethical; they'd die without the transplant anyways.
Now that we have viable human heart transplantation, you have to pick sicker patients as candidates - people who wouldn't survive even if they got a human heart transplant. Giving someone who'd survive with a human heart an experimental pig heart isn't ethical.
It makes sense that the failure model would be different.
- mort96 4y agoIs there no shortage of human hearts to transplant? Don't you have people who would live with a human heart transplant, but where the risk of waiting a short period of time for a pig heart transplant is about the same as the risk of waiting a long period of time for a human heart transplant? I mean if we do have enough human hearts to transplant into anyone who needs it I suppose that's a good thing, but all I hear about transplants is how long the wait times usually are for human organs.
- Retric 4y agoThe shortage means the people likely to survive longest after transplant get preferential treatment. Which means if someone has stage 4 cancer etc they aren’t on the list.