6 ms·
I think the GNOME designers are incompetent
- lhnz 4y agoThe author certainly knows how to use the middle finger.
- guiambros 4y agoI'm a bit lost on what OP is complaining about. I agree that GNOME has tons of flaws, and they make some design choices that are questionable, but the 3-button titlebar click sending the window to the back of the Z-stack and being able to copy two things at once (one via clipboard, one via middle-clicking) works fine for me on GNOME 3.36. Am I missing something? Or maybe GNOME 40 screwed things up?
- temptemptemp111 4y ago
- Apocryphon 4y agoThis is the exact kind of article that needs screenshots
- Sin2x 4y agoI couldn't agree more. They have their HIG and their Adwaita design language, but the end result somehow is still subjectively off-putting for me personally, visual-wise and usage-wise. They need their Steve Jobs.
- baybal2 4y agoThey would never have it because nobody would work with them. It's an OSS projects with the most abrasive, and socially inept people around, seemingly gathered together on purpose. GNOME had few hundred active contributors on its peak, now down to at most 20-30 people. The proliferation of *Kits is very much an intentional policy by RedHat to pull the classical "Embrace, Extend, Extinguish" scheme, except when they do the extinguish thing, the remaining people have no other option, but to move to RedHat's platform.
- Sin2x 4y agoWere you answering to my comment? Anyways, I don't believe that Gnome nowadays is an open project de facto -- AFAIK most of the contributors are Red Hat/IBM employees for whom it's a job.
- heretogetout 4y agoI can't honestly say this is how OSS projects die (I just don't know) but there does seem to be a correlation between corporate support and low PR acceptance. I know I'm put off by all the anti-contributor corpo-CLA nonsense that's permeated the OSS world and I'm guessing I'm not the only one.
- esarbe 4y ago> It's an OSS projects with the most abrasive, and socially inept people around, seemingly gathered together on purpose. You are repeating unsubstantiated claims and accusations. > The proliferation of *Kits is very much an intentional policy by RedHat to pull the classical "Embrace, Extend, Extinguish" scheme, except when they do the extinguish thing, the remaining people have no other option, but to move to RedHat's platform. And this is just conspiratorial. Really, this is not contributing anything to the discussion.
- phendrenad2 4y agoThe GNOME HIG is barely a thing anyway. I've read it, it's like 3 pages of vague platitudes like "Make things nice for the user".
- georgyo 4y agoAm I the only one who really likes gnome? Gnome 40+ are excellent, and I don't really see any flaws with daily use. I haven't seen much change between 41 and 42, which is fine since everything is already working great.
- webkike 4y agoI love Gnome as well. I think partly because I only use three windowed programs on Linux - emacs, Firefox, console, and okay occasionally music. I really appreciate the nice eye candy and polish - especially for the music app
- atemerev 4y agoI am enjoying it, too. In fact, I like it better than macos.
- heywire 4y agoNope, I’m a huge fan. There are a couple annoyances (like not having minimize/maximize buttons by default), but they’re all easily remedied with gnome tweak tool or extensions. I’ll admit that I was a little worried when I started seeing screenshots of libadwaita and gnome 42, heading down the path of flat-everything, but in practice, the experience has been nice on both Arch and Fedora 36.
- Gigachad 4y agoFor maximise you can double click the top bar or window snap it on the top. Minimise I agree should be added in though.
- philliphaydon 4y agoOut of the box I can’t get used to it. I tried fedora 36 for 2 weeks with Gnome and ended up switching to KDE Plasma. I’m constantly trying to find extensions to simplify simple tasks or make it usable and it’s frustrating. Tons of extensions are old and broken and don’t work anymore. Visually I don’t like KDE Out of the box but I don’t need to install anything.
- atemerev 4y agoI never used the “collapse to title bar” functionality. If you don’t need a window right now, why keep it visible on the desktop? And I am quite happy with Gnome, and I enjoy the empty desktop in particular (I tend to clutter it on all other desktop managers).
- traverseda 4y agoI use the title bars for a few niche things, keeping a window on multiple desktops, keeping it above others, telling it to disable the compositor so 3D effects are more efficient, moving from one desktop to another, killing stuck windows...
- ergonaught 4y agoI think they are incompetent and seemingly ignorant as well (which appears to be the thrust of this article), but "They don't know how to use this obscure thing that the overwhelming majority of users will never do so they removed the capability" isn't arguing for either incompetence or ignorance, really. It's just saying you aren't the target audience, which is true.
- lottin 4y agoManipulating the window stack with the mouse is something the majority of users will never do? That is a strong assumption.
- f311a 4y agoCalling people clowns is too much. A lot of the work on Gnome was done in free time.
- Nextgrid 4y agoAll the functionality they removed was done in free time too. It’s literally more work to mess with them than just leave good enough alone.
- lolinder 4y agoNo, it's not. It's more coding work in the short term, sure, but every feature that exists is one that has to be maintained. This is obvious in code written in a professional context, but people seem to think that open source is somehow exempt from this rule. If the feature uses shared internal apis, then that code has to be refactored if you need to make changes to those apis. If you need to update versions of dependencies, then the feature needs to be updated too. If there are bugs, at a minimum you have to do something with the bug reports for those features. Even ignoring the report has overhead in the form of extra bug reports that you never intend to fix. Marking them as "won't fix" means you have to figure out a solution for dealing with the backlash from the reporter. Then you get to the PRs from people who want to improve the feature but don't know the project well enough to really be of help. You have to either reject the PRs outright or carefully walk them through how to make them acceptable. The minimal-work way to keep a feature around is to ignore all PRs and all bug reports for that feature. Any other approach is extra overhead. But taking that approach is still in many ways worse than stripping the feature out entirely, because you're left with a feature that only sort of works some of the time, it makes your code more resistant to change than if it were gone, and you're building up a backlog of reports and PRs you never intend to fix.
- ohgodplsno 4y agoHave you never had a cross-cutting feature to change ? A new field on a core struct that needs updating everywhere ? Well consider that everything is ten times worse on an old codebase like Gnome, coupled with insane amounts of tech debts and unwanted interactions because that is the unfortunate destiny of UIs. Removing a feature might be a bit of work now, but if it avoids hours of headaches later, that's absolutely worth it.
- madjam002 4y agoIs there any way to style GNOME 42 to look more like GNOME 41? For me 41 was one of the best desktop UIs I’ve used and I’m not a fan of the new flat design of 42, light mode looks really nice but I find it really difficult to distinguish between UI elements in dark mode.
- j16sdiz 4y agoThe author might have a point, but the article is thin on details.
- 0des 4y agoThis guy needs Acme + Rio + Plan9 with all this middle clicking he's doing.
- mrob 4y agoI don't think they're incompetent. I think they're operating under the assumption that GNOME is going to be popular. The majority of people primarily or exclusively use mobile touchscreen UIs, so mainstream popularity requires that everything be dumbed down to suit touchscreens. In reality, this will most likely just drive away the users who prefer more powerful UIs without giving the mobile users any compelling reason to switch. But this isn't even necessarily a sign of delusion or incompetence. It's plausible that the GNOME devs know it's a bad idea, but they have to do it anyway, because without the possibility of mainstream popularity there's no good reason for IBM to continue funding it.
- tokai 4y agoIf its made for mainstream popularity, then why has it become the most common default DE among distro when linux is still not mainstream? Even use for poweruser distros.
- ginko 4y ago>If its made for mainstream popularity, then why has it become the most common default DE among distro when linux is still not mainstream It's pushed by Red Hat who has disproportionate control over the development of Linux. Same reason everyone had to switch to systemd.
- uluyol 4y agoDisproportionate in what sense? In terms of funding? Users? Red Hat has some of the most popular distributions and backs more open source devs than anyone else.
- Certhas 4y agoBut it's not really touch focused the way I use it. It's more text focused. I never start a program by touching/clicking, I hit Super and type the name. Same for settings. I absolutely need the Ubuntu modifications to it. I really think they removed too much, but the basic design and workflow of "Hit Super to get to the organisation view" is excellent IMO.
- gabereiser 4y agoLove how attacking GNOME devs who work in their free time gets top HN of the day. If you don’t like it, roll up your sleeves and submit a patch. If you can’t do that, go find another desktop.
- guerrilla 4y agoI don't think patches will get accepted, they have their vision and won't listen to anyone: however, just fork it like MATE and Cinnamon have. I use both, depending on my mood. There are even others...
- stingraycharles 4y agoWhile I don’t like the hostile tone, “if you don’t like it, fork it / submit a patch” is equally unproductive, especially when it’s about the high level, direction of a project.
- krapp 4y agoHow is it unproductive? That's literally how F/OSS is supposed to work.
- phendrenad2 4y agoNo, it's not. FOSS has come a long way since the bad old days of code being the only consideration. Now people expect that open-source projects have good stewardship of said code, and accept direction from the community, you know, the users. Unfortunately many corporate-sponsored projects have other goals, often detrimental to the community. Which would be fine, if you could just switch to something else, but good luck getting away from GNOME/GTK (unless you happen to like KDE, which isn't everyone's cup of tea).
- 0des 4y agoXFCE is the real deal
- denysvitali 4y agoI don't get it. Why are they incompetent? From the article it only seems to be because they didn't include features that other Windows Managers have. GNOME is not Windows WM or macOS WM. There might be things that you are not used to, when you come from one of those worlds, but that doesn't make them wrong. It would be wrong if the feature was there in the past and removed it without guiding the users (via UX) to an alternative. IMHO the author shouldn't complain about the design choices of GNOME by comparing it to other WMs. There isn't a reference WM that everyone needs to stick to (thankfully!), so a missing feature compared to macOS / Windows is not a wrong thing.
- baisq 4y agoHow old are you, Liam?
- sabedevops 4y agoShit article with hidden agenda: shake confidence in GNOME, which is free and is becoming the defacto GUI on Linux distributions that matter (and loved by millions).
- Sin2x 4y agoAnd cui bono?
- bityard 4y agoThey are incompetent, but it's not (totally) their fault. They were never exposed to the powerful and highly configurable classic Unix window managers and desktops, only Windows, Mac, and iOS. Yes, these old desktops all had their warts and configuration was not always a straightforward affair but they packed a lot of functionally into a small package. It's like asking an otherwise experienced programmer to write an IDE when all they ever used was notepad.exe and a command-line compiler.
- viraptor 4y agoI'd like to put a huge "citation needed" on the claim that gnome designers have not been exposed to the classic window managers. Where did you get that information? How many of them is that confirmed for?
- addicted 4y agoGnome developers actually appear to look at Linux as an operating system and an ecosystem. Linux development and use had become unimaginably complicated and fragmented. Choice in Linux is a good thing, so I’m not against the fragmentation. At the same time, choice also means I should be able to choose an OS that keeps things simple for both devs and users. And that’s what Gnome (and others such as the Fedora devs) appear to be aiming for. Ubuntu used to play this role, but Canonical has built a consistent reputation of creating an alternative, splitting the community, and then abandoning it a few years down the road.
- jdub 4y agoIf you knew the GNOME project or any of its contributors over a long period of time, you'd know that this is absolute poppycock. If anything, the GNOME 2.0 approach was an allergic reaction to years of overcomplicated nerd software. Consider that, prior to 2.0, Enlightenment was once the official GNOME window manager.
- dapids 4y agoEnlightenment was truly the worst I have even used.
- kzrdude 4y agoFree and open source development is it's own thing. It's personal and the community is not that big. Criticism should be respectfully formulated and preferably constructive. I don't champion GNOME maybe but their work on usability is very important to me in real terms, it's a movement for a better user interface instead of just repeating old and broken patterns (like Yes/No dialog boxes.)
- dna_polymerase 4y agoI set my dad up with Ubuntu & Gnome. He needs the A11y functions a lot and has. I complaints. He loves it and gets work done. I can’t thank the gnome devs enough for their easily accessible software.
- swayvil 4y agoYou mean the old gnome (mate) or the new gnome? Because ya, the new gnome is dumb last time I checked. But mate is awesome.
- jcpst 4y agoGnome works fine for me. I’m glad it was made. I was an i3 user for a long time. When I grew tired of configuring things like wifi, mounting USB drives automatically, and a dozen other little things, Gnome just worked. What I think kind of sucks is this person is just talking shit because an open source project doesn’t do what they want it to do. Author, you are rude.
- cfcfcf 4y agoThe author is mistaking the designers' competency with his own personal taste. I've never used the features he mentioned. I like GNOME 42, for what it's worth.
- unethical_ban 4y agoThis is satire, right? Or at least, a mockery of a silly comment? How does this get its own submission? None of the things the author describes are intuitive. I think Ubuntu and/or Pop_OS had a great thing where you can hold the Super/Win button and see a guide for which buttons do what. This is for keyboard not mouse, but the idea is the same. I can understand frustration at non-power-users taking away gestures, but come on.
- snarfy 4y agoCalling designers incompetent is rude. If you don't like it you can submit a PR, but until then fuck right off with the rudeness.
- ohgodplsno 4y ago> First, you need to know how to use a 3-button mouse properly. The middle button is important. Middle-click a title bar and it sends it to the back of the Z-stack: behind all other windows. Not on Windows. Not on OSX as far as I know. In fact, the only place where it happens is on a few obscure distros and on Gnome for a very short amount of time. Hiding such behavior behind something as little used as a middle mouse is asinine >Select text, then middle-click elsewhere, and it copies it. No formatting, just text, and without going through the clipboard. Yet more asinine things. Copy without formatting is a dumb idea and should be replaced by paste without formatting. Don't lose data the moment you copy. And bypassing the clipboard brings more trouble than good things. You know how else you can copy two things at the same time ? By looking inside of your damn clipboard history. >But now, you can scroll up on a title bar, and it collapses into just the title bar. It's an alternative to minimisation, called the windowblind or windowshade effect. Oh, great, more ways to wonder "how the fuck did my windows transform into this?" by binding this action to something as easily done as accidentally scrolling your mouse wheel. The one thing I'll grant him is that client side decorations are... dubious at best. While they should be available if you want to do stupid things with your UI, there should be an easily accessible way to ask for simple "please do it for me" decorations that'll just pop in the buttons and be done. Potentially by making it a standard that window toolkits have to implement. Should these options be available to be bound ? Yeah, sure. Make a simple config file to bind that and be done with it. But when 99% of the people will be confused by it, do not make it the default. This clown will be calling for the year of linux on the desktop then ask for "scroll on the titlebar to make it implode".
- bdekoz 4y agoGoes back further, to their attempt to kill pagers. Agreed, window management has always been painful with GNOME, let alone titles, shading, and the third button.
- koprulusector 4y agoThe author raises some interesting ideas and may even have valid points. However, the unnecessary vitriol toward people surely doing the best they can with what they know and what they have is distasteful and off-putting. Their delivery hinders whatever message they intend to convey (unless it’s arrogance, pettiness, and elitism).
- seabird 4y agoModern GNOME is a liability to Linux desktop usage. It's usually fine, but can turn into a clunky, shitty mess at completely random and unpredictable points in your usage of it. The average person doesn't want to deal with this. It doesn't make their life easier or better. "Don't do X" isn't a real answer. I don't dislike it because it's just different and I don't want to learn -- I've used GNOME 2, GNOME 3, Unity, KDE, Openbox, the Windows DE, and the OSX/macOS DE for a year or more each. GNOME 3 and the macOS DE are the standout bad ones of the bunch, but macOS has the excuse of a long design history that it has been continually improving on, while GNOME 3 was a step backwards from what GNOME 2 was 10 years before its release.
- Sin2x 4y agoWe still have MATE as a replacement for Gnome 2 but I've switched to Xfce personally as soon as Gnome 3 was released.
- qalmakka 4y agoThe GNOME designers really only give a damn about UI, eyecandy, and making everything as cool and good looking as they physically can. The real problem is that this has basically annihilated any trace of decent UX from GNOME, and it went from being literally one of the best UX ever made (GNOME 2, now MATE) to an absolute mess of good looking, confusing crap. GNOME 3 and 4x aren't just "different". They are simply bad. GNOME 2 was different, and it was amazing. I remember letting my mother using my computer in the late '00s and even though she was absolutely terrible with computers she figured out how to use GNOME 2 in like, 20 minutes. Applications? Click on applications. Where is the download directory? Just click on Places. Sadly GNOME isn't alone in this trend though, no one except KDE Plasma gives a damn about UX anymore.
- Sin2x 4y agoElementary's Pantheon was a breath of fresh air in the field of average user's DEs, but sadly they seem to have encountered some internal issues within the company and it's unclear if the future is bright.
- krylon 4y agoI am sooooo happy that MATE exists. I'm sure there's plenty of things people dislike about it, but to me, it hits the sweet spot. Maybe this is just because I've been using MATE and before that Gnome 2 for more than 15 years now, but over the years, I have come to believe this is a value in itself. It's why Windows 8 made me pretty mad - the good old desktop of Windows 95 - Windows 7 was not perfect, but I have spent enough time using it I no longer needed to think about how this thing or that thing worked, it was almost muscle-memory. When I wake up in the middle of the night and need to visit the bathroom, I can navigate my apartment without turning the light on. I feel that desktop environments are similar - familiarity beats clever design hands down, so I prefer small, incremental changes to "re-inventing" things.
- Sin2x 4y agoFun fact: Openbox, Blackbox and Fluxbox all stopped active development around 2015. What happened in that year? Another fun fact: FVWM is still more or less actively developed: https://github.com/fvwmorg/fvwm3 https://github.com/fvwmorg/fvwm3
- alpaca128 4y agoAll I'm seeing in this article are baseless insults because Gnome doesn't work exactly the same way as other desktops the author has been using. Meanwhile I like it, Gnome may not be perfect but to me it's the most polished modern Linux desktop environment. It might not support all kinds of middle mouse button features but works better with other input methods. When Gnome implemented touch gestures to smoothly scroll between virtual desktops, KDE had zero support for touchscreens iirc but supported pointless things like rotating desktop icons. I'm puzzled how someone can get so worked up about a system component which can be switched out in less time than it took to write that rant.
- YmiYugy 4y agoOn Top Panels: > They don't know what the top panel is for, but all the desktops they know have one, so they kept it GNOME tries to maximize the amount of screen space apps have available. This motivates a decision against permanently visible docks or taskbars. We do however want still want immediate access to essential status information like time, network connection and sound status. We also need some way to initiate and interaction with the shell. For now the Activities button/corner provides a solution that works reasonably well for touchscreen and mouse users. GNOME has (and I think for good reason. It has poor discoverability and many apps don't make good use of it.) abandoned the menubar so the top bar looks a bit underused. But making it more useful would increase it's size, which is a no no. On Desktop Icons: They require you to close, minimize or move out the way any window. The favorites bar combined with the app grid seems superior in almost every way. On the middle mouse button: That doesn't seem to be all that universal. Chrome e.g. closes a tab when middle clicking it. I've never heard of or used the middle mouse copying selected text. So this isn't something I miss. Developing a first party clipboard manager however could be a worthwhile undertaking for the GNOME team. On CSD: So this windowshade thing apparently is an old Mac OS thing. I fail to see how it's better than minimizing windows. The lack of a minimizing button is indeed something I disagree with, but it is so easy to bring back that I don't mind. For me titlebars were always an ugly waste of space. I fully support getting rid of them. On Action Buttons: I think putting them on top is a controversial but not totally unreasonable. It means that they are always in a predictable position and always visible. If you want the same with bottom buttons you need to a) introduce a bottom bar on the dialog, wasting space and b) make every dialog the same size. Having action buttons on the top of big modals is also something people are used to from mobile.
- Nursie 4y ago> I've never heard of or used the middle mouse copying selected text Have you ever used a unix system? Wow. This has been pretty standard in X windows across many platforms for decades.
- kaba0 4y agoCan we go back to the time when one is able to criticize something with civility? Just my anecdotal experience with Gnome is that it is probably one of the most handy desktop OS out there right now, I prefer using it much more than OSX for example (gnome copied plenty things from OSX but sometimes made them better in the process - you can actually differentiate between different browsers’ windows for one. It is also much smoother). So unless you dismiss my opinion (shared by plenty of other people) as useless, the Gnome team managed to create a useful environment for several people, making them more then competent. Cudos to the team from here as well. It must be really tiring seeing all the negativity for their free work.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoYet another critic of gnome who has failed to build a windowing environment that is better....
- kkfx 4y agoIMVHO Gnome designers are simply not free. They mostly came from RH before, IBM now corporate/management "environment" so they must follow a certain line, a really bad one. They can do something good, but their are locked on many other aspects. As a result the formal Free project is not that free. Beside that, yes Unity was a good desktop, something there when you want it, discrete otherwise. Gnome SHell in comparison suffer from secondary narcissism doing it best to be at the center of anything. But desktop concept is finished. Modern desktops start with icons and than we realize how stupid is putting icons on screen that get continually covered by applications, modern desktops start with floating WM and then we realize how absurd is wasting time moving windows around instead of a simple flexible screen subdivision. Background prove their non-sense, menus prove their absurdity vs command-line/search&narrow tools, ... Essentially the desktop of the future is the classic document-centric desktop from Xerox workstations and LispM after them. We have timidly started such migration with web crapplications that are document-based even if the document is not ours nor easy to change by the end user. We have started calling Notebook UIs the most advanced desktop UIs etc. We have started with quicklaunchers and than "dash" concept, with "tagged" file management and so on. Probably 50-60-70 years after Xerox PARC pioneering works we will have rediscovered what they have implemented back then. So far personally, the most modern desktop I know is Emacs/EXWM since I have a free tiling WM, I can manage my files with org-roam/org-mode/org-attach instead of a hierarchy of files and folder, I can link pretty anything and have anything integrated. Still not much GUI for the modern time, not like Pharo at least, but far more modern than anything else I've used so far... In a decade probably such modern desktop we will be kind-of mainstream...
- mattkevan 4y agoThis is a weird article. It reads like they’re still bitter about the demise of RiscOS and are upset with any other OS that doesn’t live up to it in their view. To declare all the GNOME devs incompetent because they’ve probably decided it’s not worth the overhead of supporting some highly niche workflows seems a bit much.
- Shadonototra 4y agoi gave up on linux UI decade ago already, mainly because of gnome so i live in a terminal, and whenever i need some desktop UI, i boot my macOS VM (with GPU passthrough) whenever i need gaming, i boot the windows VM gnome and red hat want the death of linux desktop, they want everyone instead to become a tablet/smartphone user they sabotage desktop and held for hostage the entire linux community it's really a shame to see more and more desktop app with CSD and these giant headers that needs multiple clicks and scroll a sad era for linux.. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_JTEsQufSx4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_JTEsQufSx4
- addicted 4y agoWait, so competent design includes making decisions assuming that users know how to use a 3 button mouse correctly? Including, for example, that middle clicking the title bar sends a window to the back of the stack? Seriously? Anyone who designs a general purpose operating system based on that assumption probably shouldn’t be designing general purpose operating systems. And that’s just the first one. The next complain is that middle clicking selected text allows copy pasting without using the clipboard. So apparently good design is having a clipboard but also not a clipboard. Gnome designers may be incompetent (considering that nearly every OS is building on that, if they are, they are at least more competent than nearly everyone else in the Linux design world), but these are not signs of their incompetence.
- addicted 4y ago> The guys at Xerox PARC and Apple who invented the GUI knew this. The clowns at Red Hat don't. The guys at Apple stuck to a 1 button mouse until about a decade ago. And here you’re calling designers incompetent because they’re not assuming users will know hot to middle click a title bar to send the window to the back.
- akagusu 4y agoThe author makes a bold statement and it is a bit aggressive, but he is right about Gnome devs removing features people use when they think people shouldn't use. People complain about Gnome not because their mobile-like interface, but because Gnome devs always remove features people use. They do this since Gnome 2 and even Linus Torvalds complaint about it multiple times.
- karmakaze 4y agoI've never cared for Gnome since v3 using alternative Deb-based OSes. Since then, I've not liked the decisions that Gnome have been making. At the same time, I'm good with them trying something different. There really isn't a point of having so many distros with hard to distinguish differences in motivation. I'm happy as long as there's maybe two or so doing something well that suits me. Here's the distrowatch hits-per-day for past 6 months: 1. MX Linux 2946 2. EndeavourOS 2684 3. Mint 2242 4. Manjaro 1750 5. Pop!_OS 1385 6. Ubuntu 1331 7. Fedora 1159 8. Debian 1083 [I hadn't looked at this in a very long time.] Ubuntu used to be much higher. I've used Xubuntu (#41), Mint, and now Pop!_OS which are all fine. For some reason I've always avoided KDE--though with the power of even modest computers now it can't really be considered very bloated.
- lolinder 4y agoYou missed the disclaimer: > The DistroWatch Page Hit Ranking statistics are a light-hearted way of measuring the popularity of Linux distributions and other free operating systems among the visitors of this website. They correlate neither to usage nor to quality and should not be used to measure the market share of distributions. They simply show the number of times a distribution page on DistroWatch was accessed each day, nothing more.
- karmakaze 4y agoI know what hits-per-day means. Ubuntu was #1 on that list up until 2010, now there are 3 deb-based distros above Ubuntu. If you have more indicative data, please share.
- lolinder 4y agoMy point is that Ubuntu's position in that list means absolutely nothing about Ubuntu's overall usage or its quality. The most likely explanation for the decline is that people don't go visit the DistroWatch page on Ubuntu because it's too mainstream these days for the DW demographic to be curious about it. I'm not obliged to produce additional data because the only point I was making is that your data is meaningless and shouldn't be used to indicate anything about Gnome or Ubuntu.
- akagusu 4y agoThis is a comment by Linus Torvalds from 2012 about Gnome: "That’s exactly the reverse of the gnome “we know better” mentality, and “We will force Corba/.NET down your throat whether you like it or not, and if you complain, you’re against progress, and cannot handle the change”."
- pjmlp 4y agoNot sure if they are incompetent as such, however GNOME is far from what I used to advocate for back in the 2000's, and thinking I even wrote an article advocating for Gtkmm back in the day. It doesn't even support common X Windows stuff like shading windows without extensions, which obiously have to be written in JavaScript. And the way the transition to Gtk4 has been managed isn't certainly the way to make the platform appealing to the developers used to the graphical tooling for Apple, Google and Microsoft platforms, or even KDE to stay on the Linux world.
- phendrenad2 4y agoThe 3-button clipboard criticism seems... weird. You can't do that in MacOS or Windows, either (Perhaps Linux should be better than those environments, and give you more options to enable/disable such things, but that's a different discussion). But I do like the "Chesterton's fence" analogy. GNOME is exactly that. They've rearranged things just to rearrange them, not based on research. Incompetence? Maybe. But I hesitate to call something so poorly-designed incompetence. I'm guessing GNOME has no actual designers, and the "designers" are just programmers who felt like they could do design, and so did.