3 ms·
I couldn't get past: "One can make endless arguments as to why history texts are spectacularly bland." Of course, many history texts are bland - but so are bo
by arethuza 15y ago
I couldn't get past:
"One can make endless arguments as to why history texts are spectacularly bland."
Of course, many history texts are bland - but so are books on many subjects. And the best history texts I find some of the most fascinating things to read...
- Tyrannosaurs 15y agoSimilarly the idea that history is merely memorisation, as if we had access to perfect information about the past which we can completely understand despite our entirely different context.
- acqq 15y agoExactly. Typically, the curriculum for history is made to match some political agenda (even if you'd claim that it's not so, it is in fact always so with the history taught in schools). Making it adhering to the agenda necessary results in some awkward perspectives or unbalanced attention to really relevant or really interesting events. To quote Bertha von Suttner in "Lay Down Your Arms," 1889: "Speaking generally it is history which, as our youth are instructed, is the chief source of the admiration of war. From thence it is stamped on the childish mind that the Lord of armies is constantly decreeing battles, that these are, as it were, the vehicle upon which the destiny of nations is carried on through the ages ; that they are the fulfilment of an inevitable law of nature and must always occur from time to time like storms at sea or earthquakes ; that terror and woe are indeed connected with them ; but the latter is fully counterpoised, for the commonwealth by the importance of the results, for individuals by the blaze of glory which may be won in them, or even by the consciousness of the fulfilment of the most elevated duty. Can there be a more glorious death than that on the field of honour, a nobler immortality than that of the hero? All this comes out clear and unanimous in all school-books "readings for the use of schools," where, besides the formal history, which is only represented as a concatenation of military events, even the separate tales and poems always manage to tell only of heroic deeds of arms. This is a part of the patriotic system of education. Since out of every scholar a defender of his country has to be formed, therefore the enthusiasm even of the child must be aroused for this its first duty as a citizen; his spirit must be hardened against the natural horror which the terrors of war might awaken, by passing over as quickly as possible the story of the most fearful massacres and butcheries as of something quite common and necessary, and laying meanwhile all possible stress on the ideal side of this ancient national custom; and it is in this way they have succeeded in forming a race eager for battle and delighting in war."
- arethuza 15y agoLiving in a country that arguably defines itself in terms of a war fought and won 700 years ago I am, in my skeptical old age, rather appalled at the level of indoctrination we received under the cover of historical eduction. Not to mention the odd fact that my long-standing interest in history led to a much more recent fascination with geology...