6 ms·
If your website's full of assholes, it's your fault (2011)
- hnuaer 4y ago
- sam_lowry_ 4y agoIt's easy to shut off assholes if you are an even bigger asshole yourself. I shall not point fingers but the the demise of online forums and the meteoric rise of Facebook is a proof. There were certain values that websites in 00-ies had and that were eroded by the likes of Facebook, LinkedIn and yes, even Reddit. I am still operating an old-style online forum that shrank from tens of thousands of users to a dozen occasional visitors, and I attribute its decline to its core values: anonymity, absence of monetization, minimal moderation.
- seunosewa 4y agoSince you run it, why not change the core values?
- LocalH 4y agoThe core values would be the entire benefit to the form of communication. The massive decline in classic forums has been a net negative for the Internet. The 2000s forum culture was a lot different from the current state of things, and better in many ways. You didn't have the level of de facto censorship that you see now with the massive centralized communication platforms.
- krapp 4y ago>You didn't have the level of de facto censorship that you see now with the massive centralized communication platforms. I disagree. Not every forum was SA or 4chan, plenty were aggressively moderated. The primary difference between then and now that I see is that, back then, moderation wasn't always considered censorship.
- LocalH 4y agoI'm talking about the upper level of modern content moderation, imposed by the platforms themselves. It's the autonomy that is missing nowadays.
- sam_lowry_ 4y ago>primary difference between then and now is that there is little choice and even less variation
- asdfsafwea 4y agoIs "absence of monetization" a value? Do we expect this with any other business other than the ones on the internet - news papers, magazines, local community events etc. Absence of monetization, to me means its a hobby project funded by you and not a business, that also perhaps means it has not kept up with the competition - think servers, performance, websites, mobile apps etc. Maybe avoiding ad based monetization could be what you are talking about but then you still got to pay the bills some how, so unless you monetize, I don't know how a business would survive. Considering this, I don't think its a surprise that your users are on the decline. Besides, doesn't everyone like to complain about ads online but very few really want to pay for alternative paid services anyway e.g. email, navigation, private messaging etc
- rhn_mk1 4y agoIt is a value. It means that the incentives of the user and the producer are aligned: to enjoy the time in a community, rather than have one try to extract money. Aside from that, not everything needs to be a business, and even then, not everything needs to be profitable.
- caracustard 4y agoBy that logic lets stop paying street sweepers and sanitation workers. See, their incenitives are mutually aligned with the interests of those who walk the streets, so there is no reason to "extract money". Sure thing, but the article in question EXPLICITLY mentions "You should make a budget that supports having a good community, or you should find another line of work.", which means that one way or another funding is needed, unless you're comfortable with making someone read through kilobytes of drivel and spam in their free (or perhaps not so free) time.
- rhn_mk1 4y agoI'm sure if you stopped paying the street sweepers, you'd find out that a lot of them don't care about sanitation, and the rest can't pick up the burden. That's why they get paid. Even then, I'd rather have one of those motivated by cleanliness service my area. Just the same way, I'll choose a forum that's not monetized. I don't see how that sentence means that funding is needed. Plenty of forums exist with community moderation. Whether the person doing the work is compensated in respect and social connections, or money, doesn't really make a difference to me.
- Bluecobra 4y agoI always thought that Something Awful’s $10 paywall was pretty effective. If you’re an asshole and break the the rules, you’re out $10 and have to pay again. If you’re a big enough asshole, then you get permabanned. You’ll hear a lot of people complain about it and never register over the $10. I paid my $10 once almost 20 years ago and never got banned. That was the best $10 I have ever spent.
- mountainb 4y agoYou're deeply confused if you think SA is/was not essentially defined by some of the most capriciously cruel people online. The founder just shot himself after leaving behind a wrecked family with multiple ex-wives, abandoned children, and DV convictions. FYAD, Helldump, etc. really define the spirit of SA, and it's also a precise counterexample to your argument about paywalls being a good thing.
- jstarfish 4y agoMetafilter (used to?) charge $5 in the same vein. That Lowtax was a piece of shit says nothing about his effectiveness in separating assholes from their money. The system works.
- streamlining 4y ago
- tjr225 4y agoI look around at every. single. internet community on the planet and I struggle to find a single one that isn't full of assholes. Including the very space I am on right now. And yet - when I step outside and go talk to people and hang out with my friends they suddenly recede into the shadows. Sure, here and there somebody will be an asshole but for the most part everyone is nice, helpful, and (especially in my friends group), welcoming. This includes people I disagree with politically. I think we should able to turn the internet off for everyone for arbitrary amounts of time. Don't really know how to reconcile this for those who need it like the disabled, medical, etc... My point is, I fundamentally disagree with this article.
- bombcar 4y agoIt’s the distillation - you don’t know me at all, and even if you do it’s only though some vague recollections of previous posts. Friends are people who do and say things - and if they say something assholic once in awhile, it’s just something they said/did - but one asshole comment makes the poster an asshole forever, and people start treating them as such, which encourages it. Non-online communications have way more venues to interact with others.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- psyc 4y agoAKA Gabriel’s Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory. https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/19/green-blackboards-and-other-anomalies https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/19/green-blackboa...
- jakevoytko 4y agoGoogle's Real Names experiment helped simplify this equation. They proved that people don't even need anonymity to be fuckwads; all they need is an audience. I remember a lot of low-level bemusement and high-level consternation when the quality of discussion in YouTube comments didn't get any better after they tied everything to an identity.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoEh, gratuitously sweary and inflammatory. Sort of a hypocritical take -- I say this as someone prone to f-bombs myself, but this is a situation where modeling appropriate behavior would be an appropriate thing to do. You will find assholes everywhere. We all have that potential. Good rules etc can craft a reasonably civil environment anyway. It takes work to foster civility. This is always true. It's just not always obvious.
- loloquwowndueo 4y agoI did get the occasional asshole comment in my Wordpress blog. Much happier since I moved the thing to Hugo and disabled comments - not like I really care much about what others say, and my tiny blog was not a super popular gathering place anyway.
- cosmiccatnap 4y agoI think the fact this article exists proves otherwise
- nobleach 4y agoReal humans viewing comments is probably one of the most important things. HN has good moderation when things get personal. (I am admittedly the recipient of one of these moderations) HN tends to keep things professional - but can dip into the "you have no idea what you're talking about" territory at times. The problem is, we're all know-it-alls on the internet. We have a wealth of information at our fingertips. We often pretend like we were on the teams that made some sort of scientific discovery. What I see happening in other communities (I'll take Reddit and Townhall.com as examples) is that people get into like-minded echo chambers where they feel comfortable. Anyone appealing to reason in either of those communities is downvoted if they make a suggestion, ask a question, or simply refuse to tow the "party line". (I say that without politics in mind, but politics DEFINITELY factor into it) People as a general species, WANT to be liked. Because of this desire, we'll often adopt the viewpoints of our surrounding community. We'll pick on those who are different because we perceive that they're "morons" for not agreeing with the "party line". It's very hard for any sort of algorithm to solve that problem. The best we can hope for, is an even-handed moderator to say, "this person may not agree with my own personal feelings on a matter, but their voice is just as valuable to the conversation".
- gloryless 4y agoAnil dash is one of those tech bros that just says shit to create content and it has no basis in experience or research, just a weak amalgamation of thoughts. This article vaguely describes moderating. Thanks for your wisdom, Anil.
- james-redwood 4y agoThat’s quite a substantive claim with little to no evidence that adds little to productive discussion.
- savanaly 4y agoDid he shit in your corn flakes too?
- motohagiography 4y agoModerators who treat their forums as a privilege to be a part of, and who enforce a bar reward their users with that value every day I think. I've been a member of a variety of communities in my life, and to a single one what made them good was the sense of ownership and stewardship by a core member or senate of members. They were all minor personality cults around BDFLs. Whether it was bands, bars and restaurants, hackers, software projects, companies, sports teams, volunteer projects, or anything else, there was someone who could say, "this is my thing, the bar is here, be welcome or leave," and the main thing they did not tolerate was members usurping that authority with external criteria, criticism, or drama. The difference between an organic community and a "scene," I'd suspect is this ownership piece, where an organic community has a founder steward who is a hub or hierarch, whereas a scene is a kind of dynamic running opporunistic power struggle. While I thought there might be masculine and feminine aspects to that, I've known too many women who had that steward/hierarch role in different places to think it is an artifact of sex. I suspect you could replace most of the rules in the article with one rule, which is "respect the mods," and provided the moderators don't debase themselves or get trolled, that's pretty sustainable. The more rules you have, the more likely someone will leverage any possible inconsistency into creating chaos that puts them at the center of it. I would be interested in others' thoughts about why irc/silc, usenet, fidonet, early reddit, and even early twitter worked. Did they implement this articles recommendations, and which ones are sufficient or necessary? IRC was pretty anonymous for its time, especially with proxies and shells, and it persists today. IRC helped scale communities pretty fast, but being an entertaining participant vs. running a show are very different skills and desires. In each case, the rule was "respect the mods," and so long as they stayed aloof, appreciated what they had created, and acted minimally and according to principle, their communities sustained and thrived. I don't know whether these additional rules are that necessary if the recipe for a thriving community is just really a good BDFL.
- anotherevan 4y agoWild digression: Just reading the title, I thought this was going to be the story about someone who had a huge amount of server traffic for some innocuous image he was hosting. He eventually figured out some Wordpress theme publisher had used a link to it in a theme they wrote and sold. So all these web-sites that were using the theme were loading this image from his server - costing him traffic and money. So he changed the image to something disgusting along the lines of a goatse image (and this is where my brain went to, "If you website's full of assholes..."). The kicker was the theme writer actually contacted him and asked him to "fix" the image as it was upsetting their customers and effecting their sales. Apparently the theme publisher no longer had access to whoever they originally had write the theme, and lacked sufficient skills to publish an update with a link to a different image themself.
- warpspin 4y agoThis is easier said than done. The one thing all online communities suffer from is you cannot truly perma-ban people on the internet, making moderation a bottomless pit. Only chance you have is basically charging people to sign up, but then you will also drive away 99,99% of your target audience.