5 ms·

So, I should be forced to give blood if someone’s life is at risk and they need my blood (or, kidney)? There is a 3rd party to consider here and they are alread

by sanp 4y ago

So, I should be forced to give blood if someone’s life is at risk and they need my blood (or, kidney)? There is a 3rd party to consider here and they are already living and breathing. So, blood or organ donations should be made mandatory. And if the argument is that the woman is responsible for getting pregnant then apply the above logic to a person you accidentally injured in a car accident. Now, anyone who causes a car accident should be forced to give blood (or any other part of their body) to ensure the victim is saved.

Banana699 4y ago
>anyone who causes a car accident should be forced to give blood (or any other part of their body) to ensure the victim is saved. Yes. >So, I should be forced to give blood if someone’s life is at risk and they need my blood (or, kidney)? If that someone being in risk was the inevitable biological result of your actions, then yes. You should be forced to save him/her. Because you put him/her there.
- jquery 4y ago
  So if you gave someone Covid and their lungs failed, they have a right to one of your lungs? Should men be required to donate organs to women they got pregnant, if indicated? This is obviously very silly and not thought out. Banning abortion is just as silly.
  - Banana699 4y ago
    >So if you gave someone Covid and their lungs failed, they have a right to one of your lungs Yes, if you can 1- Prove that I infected them And, 2- Prove that no other solution would save the infected person, and organ donation would >Should men be required to donate organs to women they got pregnant Not if the impregnation was consensual. The person infected with Covid or hit by a car didn't consent to those actions, but a pregnant woman consented to impregnation unless she's raped, therefore she should accept responsibility for the associated risks. Rape is one of the very few reasons where abortion should be allowed. But it's something like 0.1% or so of abortion reasons, the vast majority of abortions are morally indefensible.

by sanp 4y ago

Banana699 4y ago

>anyone who causes a car accident should be forced to give blood (or any other part of their body) to ensure the victim is saved. Yes. >So, I should be forced to give blood if someone’s life is at risk and they need my blood (or, kidney)? If that someone being in risk was the inevitable biological result of your actions, then yes. You should be forced to save him/her. Because you put him/her there.

jquery 4y ago
So if you gave someone Covid and their lungs failed, they have a right to one of your lungs? Should men be required to donate organs to women they got pregnant, if indicated? This is obviously very silly and not thought out. Banning abortion is just as silly.
- Banana699 4y ago
  >So if you gave someone Covid and their lungs failed, they have a right to one of your lungs Yes, if you can 1- Prove that I infected them And, 2- Prove that no other solution would save the infected person, and organ donation would >Should men be required to donate organs to women they got pregnant Not if the impregnation was consensual. The person infected with Covid or hit by a car didn't consent to those actions, but a pregnant woman consented to impregnation unless she's raped, therefore she should accept responsibility for the associated risks. Rape is one of the very few reasons where abortion should be allowed. But it's something like 0.1% or so of abortion reasons, the vast majority of abortions are morally indefensible.