3 ms·
This is how we end up causing our institutions to crumble. Your average American has no idea what Roe means or doesn’t mean, or what it’s repeal means or doesn’
by rayiner 4y ago
This is how we end up causing our institutions to crumble. Your average American has no idea what Roe means or doesn’t mean, or what it’s repeal means or doesn’t mean. It’s incumbent upon elites to tell the truth. Instead, people are playing fast and loose with the truth for political gain. Erin Chemerinsky, for example, a prominent Constitutional law scholar, called overturning Roe a “pure exercise of Republican power.”
In reality, Roe was the left’s Lochner. A pure exercise of judicial law making that could not point to anything in the Constitutional text or history to support a sweeping rule. It’s a precedent that even folks in the left have taken to defending merely by virtue of its existence as such. It’s protection of second trimester abortions is out of step with public opinion, and out of step among the law in other civilized nations.
Not all liberal precedents are like that. In fact most aren’t. There’s a huge difference between Brown and Loving and Obergefell and Roe both legally and in how the relevant issues have played out in domestic and international politics. Nonetheless, it will make political hay to act like overturning Roe will unleash the floodgates of rolling back everything else. Never mind the fact that, even though Roe was so vulnerable from the very beginning, it took conservatives 50 years of single-minded effort to overturn it.
- a2tech 4y agoIf there is such a huge difference why did Thomas specifically call those other cases out in his support?
- rayiner 4y agoIf there isn’t a difference, why didn’t the other four Justices in the majority join in his concurrence? There’s a spectrum of opinions among legal conservatives on many decisions. Kennedy wrote Obergefell and Gorsuch wrote Bostock. But no legal conservative thinks that Roe was correctly decided and a fair number of legal liberals don’t either. (Alito quotes a liberal legal scholar in this opinion who said of Roe at the time that it wasn’t Constitutional law and didn’t even try to be.)
- monocasa 4y ago> If there isn’t a difference, why didn’t the other four Justices in the majority join in his concurrence? Because commenting on other cases is generally not something the supreme court finds acceptable, heavily preferring to only comment on the questions directly before them.
- drooby 4y agoHello sanity. The opinion explains this all in great detail. But few will read it - many will just get angry. Saying this as someone that would like abortion legal federally.
- Comevius 4y agoPeople get angry because millions of people are profoundly affected, while some here are pretending that nothing will happen, this is just a course correction. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/may/23/roe-v-wade-abortion-laurence-tribe https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/may/23/roe-v-...
- drooby 4y agoI don’t think people are pretending nothing will happen. Nor did I say people aren’t justified in being upset.
- rayiner 4y agoAs a foreigner, what I admire most about Americans is their ability to dispassionately accept the results of legal procedures. I truly think that’s what is responsible for the success of America and England before it. We have people who have high minded principles and notions of justice in Bangladesh. That’s not special. What we lack is a populace that will accept even monumental decisions contrary to what they wanted and move on. And that’s what I fear is being eroded. You don’t have to agree with overturning Roe, but that’s no excuse for third-world country style rhetoric. As a matter of legal process, overruling Roe is unremarkable and consistent with longstanding principles of the kinds of cases that can be overruled notwithstanding stare decisis.
- Comevius 4y agoI could use your argument in the other direction. What useful purpose it served to overturn it after 50 years ago, other than to kick political compromise to the curb and increase polarization and harm.
- Comevius 4y agoI doubt that this was a benevolent step ensuing that Roe is replaced by something more real. This is not the pattern we are seeing, or else explain the other religion-related decisions. More importantly Roe was universally accepted as real. That legal tidal wave could very well come. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/may/23/roe-v-wade-abortion-laurence-tribe https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/may/23/roe-v-...
- rayiner 4y ago> I doubt that this was a benevolent step ensuing that Roe is replaced by something more real. It has nothing to do with "benevolence," but Roe being uniquely vulnerable in that its shortcomings as a legal decision made it a target even for the quarter of the GOP that disagrees with the party line on abortion. > This is not the pattern we are seeing, or else explain the other religion-related decisions. The explanation is that the Establishment Clause precedent is the next weakest after Roe. The U.S. was founded on religious pluralism, not French-style secularism. The absence of religious belief is, from the Constitutional perspective is not "neutral" but instead just another belief system. Excluding religious organizations and schools from public funding is plainly unconstitutional. This is neither controversial in the US (a country where 2/3 of people disagree with the Supreme Court decision banning school prayer), or most other countries. Religious schools can get public funding in Sweden. Why not the US? > More importantly Roe was universally accepted as real. A real what?
- Comevius 4y agoBut isn't Roe weak because of the fundamental irresolvability of questions like when a fetus becomes a person, and thus Roe existed to leave room for political compromise. And even if it's a bad, constitutionally defective law, isn't overturning it 50 years later only causes harm and more polarization, kicking democracy further down the drain? Actively playing favorites with a religion is not religious pluralism. Besides reality-wise how would all the fundamentalist stance about what America founded on, and how this and that should be interpreted based on that is useful if the country can't serve it's people. Nobody back then really thought that the country should not adapt to thrive.
- happytoexplain 4y agoYes, there is a not-unreasonable purely legal argument for overturning. Yes, it would be to the benefit of all if this was better understood. But, patently, that does not obviate the practical consequences for individuals, which is much more obvious and just as true. Focusing on those consequences is not misleading. Americans reasonably feel extremely strongly about this. When a perceived right is forcefully taken away by one's state, the legal argument for or against the federal mechanism that was preventing that takes a back seat, to put it mildly.
- drooby 4y ago"forcefully" taken away? The legal argument never takes back seat. This is a nation ruled by law.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoNo nation is ruled by law, they're all ruled by people. Certain people on the supreme court decided to take a right away that's been in place for 50 years. Due to the current dynamics of the political system, they could have handed down the decision with just "because we say so" and it wouldn't have changed a thing. Legal argument was always a back seat to the end goal.
- drooby 4y agoRoe was essentially established in the first place because liberal justices said "because we say so". And now we have the current justices saying "no, that's not how this system works" (and I highly recommend reading their opinion, its not 'because we say so'). Even RBJ has agreed that Roe was a faulty decision. If you are against "If we say so" rule of government, you might like this supreme court opinion. There is plenty of precedent for overruling constitutional decisions. From a legal perspective this is not new, see Brown v Board overruling Plessy v Ferg.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoIn case it wasn't lost, this isn't a theoretical academic exercise. This effects real actual people. So no, I might not like this supreme court opinion.