3 ms·
I find this interesting because it was suggested (not urgently) that I could be on the board of a local food bank. This article did not even mention D&O insuran
by AlbertCory 4y ago
I find this interesting because it was suggested (not urgently) that I could be on the board of a local food bank. This article did not even mention D&O insurance, but they said they would have it.
What scares the sh&t out of me is being financially responsible for anything any volunteer ever does (and possibly that not being covered by the insurance). None of the comments so far mention that either. Is that fear overblown?
>Board members who can't say much about where they expect to be highly engaged, vs. casually advisory ... don't seem like great bets to step up when they most need to (or stay out of the way when they should)
Indeed, I have no idea what I would do, so probably I should stay off.
- kevin_nisbet 4y ago> What scares the sh&t out of me is being financially responsible for anything any volunteer ever does (and possibly that not being covered by the insurance). None of the comments so far mention that either. Is that fear overblown? I don't think it's overblown, and should be something to research and understand. I'm on the board of my condominium corporation (same idea as an HOA), and there are specific laws outlined in the Condominium Act here in Ontario around directors, as well as the corporation declaration and bylaws. To try and briefly summarize, there are two things that largely protect directors in my case. First, the corporations insurance policy, includes directors liability insurance. So the corporation is purchasing insurance that covers all directors. It's actually in the law that the condo corporation shall purchase this insurance if reasonably available. The second, is so that people actually volunteer for these boards, the laws for the most part will hold harmless a Director that is acting in good faith. And there is context, that the board is expected to be made up of individuals with various background and no specific expertise or qualifications. There are carve outs for certain specific breaches. But it's mostly in the realm of your not covered if you breach your duty to act in honesty and good faith. In other contexts I don't know the laws, as I operate on a board specifically governed by the condo act in Ontario. But if you are considering boards in other jurisdictions, I do believe it's prudent to do some due diligence and understand potential liabilities. But in most jurisdictions I'd expect fairly strong protections for board members.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bell-cot 4y agoIANAL, but I was once advised on this by a friend who was. In short, the justice system is very biased in favor of non-profits such as food banks. Nobody needs to tell a jury "if you award $$$$$ to the guy who ate the bulging can of bad tuna, that'll mean a whole lot of needy people going hungry". A lawyer deciding to sue the Food Bank (or a Director of the Food Bank, or ...) knows that "Defend the Food Bank, for Free" is the sort of "+10 to your own Reputation" side quest that some real heavyweight law firm might find irresistible. Etc.
- AlbertCory 4y agoWell, you have a point. I thought of it as "suing me" but maybe "suing the food bank" is the right formulation. I hang out with one of the "gleaners" (the people who pick up the unused food from the supermarket), a former engineer, and he seems to be the business sense of this operation. They've been inspected by the big, successful food banks, so it's not some fly-by-night operation.
- bell-cot 4y agoAgain IANAL...but I'll speculate that the "sue you" risk is very context-dependent. If you're a local Big Shot, and wealthy enough to target individually, and so hands-off that a jury could be convinced that you're "kinda turning a blind eye to problems you shoulda known about and done something..." - maybe there's some risk. If you look more like a well-intentioned little guy, not savvy about legal & big-picture organizational problems, and are week-to-week involved enough to be aware of stuff like inspections or "systematic issues" - then I'd say you're at very little risk, even before the O&D insurance kicks in. (And in general - if you aren't a savvy big shot, then you want to be fairly involved with any organization that you're a Director of. If only so that you don't look stupid, if things don't go well.)