> The privacy aspect is simple. You have no right to know anything about my discussions with my doctor nor to dictate courses of action. This is a pretty weak

> The privacy aspect is simple. You have no right to know anything about my discussions with my doctor nor to dictate courses of action. This is a pretty weak argument which could be used to justify any number of things. Can you rape or murder behind closed doors, and invoke the right to privacy when the authorities try to stop you? Just because X happens in private doesn't make it legal and protected by privacy rights. There are plenty of illegal medical procedures. You can't have a doctor remove a kidney and help you sell it, for example.