3 ms·
> New? Like it or not, the position of the Catholic Church on abortion has been extraordinarily consistent through the centuries. That's not even remotely true
by light_hue_1 4y ago
> New? Like it or not, the position of the Catholic Church on abortion has been extraordinarily consistent through the centuries.
That's not even remotely true!
For the vast majority of the history of the Catholic Church early term abortion was acceptable. It was only the 1588 that it was outlawed, and that didn't last long, only a few years. Another ban was instituted in 1869.
At the timescale of the Catholic Church, the current extremist position on abortions is extremely recent. Far less established as precedent than say Roe was.
- fulvioterzapi 4y ago> Another ban was instituted in 1869. That's more than 150 years ago. Matches pretty much my definition of consistency. Even before, there might have been some doctrinal adjustments, but abortion was condemned by many Fathers of the Church, in the very early centuries.
- light_hue_1 4y ago> That's more than 150 years ago. Matches pretty much my definition of consistency. So out of a 2000 year history, "consistency" means something that was invented 150 years ago? That seems like an absurd definition of consistency.
- bettysdiagnose 4y ago150 years out of 2000 is not consistent. If you value consistency, then ignore the current ruling as its relatively fresh and just carry on with abortion.
- Clubber 4y ago>It was only the 1588 that it was outlawed, and that didn't last long, only a few years. I mean that was 500 years ago. It's hard to argue inconsistency when it's been the same for 500 years.
- bettysdiagnose 4y agoReread what you quoted.