3 ms·
> The problem with this legal OCD is that in the meantime, people suffer. I am willing to empathize with the denial of service but thats it. Congress was the
by yieldcrv 4y ago
> The problem with this legal OCD is that in the meantime, people suffer.
I am willing to empathize with the denial of service but thats it.
Congress was the more appropriate federal authority to be a legislature, and failed to do so. In the absence of a federal law passed by Congress, state ones are the only ones that matter.
The topic of how long the ruling lasted is a complete red herring, as this is not out of character for the court at all.
I don’t feel like the convenience of having the court being so hard to overrule is a good enough reason for it to act as a superlegislature when convenient.
I am the same way on this regarding all topics. On this specific topic, in the past I had tried to point out how odd Roe v Wade was with the court acting as a superlegislature but I quickly learned this was not a conversation people were willing to have as they couldnt separate the “camps” from the case(s) so I stopped bringing it up. I’m glad that this case forces the conversation.
- TameAntelope 4y agoSo it's more important to you that common law not exist than it is for the Supreme Court to make rulings based on religious ideology? Are you really going to pretend not to understand why this ruling came now, when the religious right just so happened to be in charge of the Supreme Court, and not at any other time in the past 50 years?
- yieldcrv 4y agoI don’t feel like the convenience of having the court being so hard to overrule is a good enough reason for it to act as a superlegislature when convenient. I completely understand that only one party is willing to make that interpretation on this topic. I think it is noteworthy that “the religious right” did not act as a superlegislature itself, given the opportunity, and simply removed it back to Congress or the states when in the absence of a law from Congress. I observe that there are or were other ways to reach the outcome that the other party wants, that party has bungled all of those ways, and will likely continue to do so.
- TameAntelope 4y agoYou "understand" and "think it is noteworthy" and "observe", but what do you "feel" about the people who've lost freedom today, because of the observable fact that this primarily happened due to the religious beliefs of the new members of the Supreme Court? Not caring about the people for whom the system is designed for is exactly what makes this such a monumental problem. If the system doesn't work for the people it's designed to work for, it the outcomes don't reflect their will, then it's a broken system. If this is the "correct" way, then the system might need to be torn down and rebuilt, possibly violently. Consider that as you avoid empathizing with those affected.
- yieldcrv 4y agoI empathize with people that expected the option of one set of services and won’t have that.
- TameAntelope 4y agoAnd I'm sure that empathy is comforting to those who will now die because their miscarriage can't be handled in a medically sound way. Possibly less so to their loved ones, some of whom may act violently in response to a system that killed a person they care about. I doubt they're going to care meaningfully about which legal mechanism it was that would have been most appropriate to use to allow their loved one to live.
- yieldcrv 4y agoThat is a consequence of Congress not doing its job on this topic for 50 consecutive years. Contact your state and Congressional representations and find legislative candidates that are as passionate on this topic as you are, if there arent other causes you are more passionate about that different candidates care about of course.
- TameAntelope 4y ago