3 ms·
From 2008-2010, the Democratic party had the chance to enshrine abortion into the law of the land. They even had a perfect vehicle, the ACA, in which to do it,
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
From 2008-2010, the Democratic party had the chance to enshrine abortion into the law of the land. They even had a perfect vehicle, the ACA, in which to do it, since it already dealt with healthcare rules. They declined.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- delecti 4y agoBoth parties benefited from abortion being a wedge issue that wasn't under legislative control. The dems knew that if they enshrined it in law, then the GOP could campaign on undoing that legislative imposition. The GOP just plays politics better though, so now they're a dog who caught the car they were chasing. The dems have a chance to make that backfire on the GOP in the midterms, but they're awful at getting or wielding power, so I'm skeptical they will.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThis is honestly the reason why the DNC chose to gamble on Roe rather than seizing one of the opportunities they had in the last 50 years to write a law. It's a sleazy move, and I'm not sure why they think people don't see what they are doing.
- dane-pgp 4y agoDo you think the ACA would have been more or less likely to pass if it had mentioned a federal right to abortion (which would have benefited zero people for the next decade)?
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThe ACA would probably have had equal chances. It was passed on a party line vote anyway. Besides, nothing stopped them from passing a right to an abortion otherwise.
- Slow_Hand 4y agoThe ACA was already getting a lot of challenges and multiple attempts to repeal it from day one. I imagine that throwing abortion protections into the mix was deemed to be a poor tactical choice at that moment because it would enflame many of the ACA’s political opponents further and perhaps bring new adversaries into the fold.
- function_seven 4y agoThere is a 0% chance ACA would have gone anywhere if it included protections for abortion. 0%. Democrats did not in fact have a "perfect vehicle" nor did they have a chance to enshrine abortion into the law of the land.
- mburns 4y ago~25% of House Dems crossed the aisle to vote on a Republican amendment to the ACA to ban federal funding of abortion[1]. While that specific amendment failed in the Senate, it still forced a handshake deal that Obama would issue an EO to that effect. It seems very unlikely that the ACA could have been passed if it enshrined abortion rights. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stupak%E2%80%93Pitts_Amendment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stupak%E2%80%93Pitts_Amendment
- saxonww 4y agoThis came up in another discussion a month or so ago, and I did some checking: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31484169 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31484169 In short, this is not true. There was a brief window where they might have had 60 votes in the Senate to overcome a filibuster, but it's unlikely for a divisive partisan issue like this one. And they didn't have a 60% majority in the House anyway. To put it very bluntly, the lack of action we've seen from Democratic Party majorities in recent history is very likely because they knew they couldn't pass legislation over Republican opposition. Sure, you can frame it as 'they declined', but that's an uncharitable oversimplification.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> To put it very bluntly, the lack of action we've seen from Democratic Party majorities in recent history is very likely because they knew they couldn't pass legislation over Republican opposition. No, it’s because they couldn't pass it over Democratic opposition (whether it's actually one or two Senators, or whether those two are pretextual is a matter of debate.) Republican opposition isn't an excuse with a trifecta. (And, no, the filibuster doesn't change this, since it only takes a majority to change it.)
- Stevvo 4y agoOpposition in the Republican party was near 100%. Near 0% in the democrats. That's Republican opposition however you spin it.
- generj 4y agoBut removing the filibuster wasn’t even in the tables or discussed half-way seriously when those majorities had power. It used to be the filibuster was rarely used and the Senate actually compromised to create legislation. There is effectively no chance the filibuster would have been removed to pass an abortion bill. It would have been political suicide. Even if it had, a federal abortion ban would have been passed the next time the GOP held a trifecta. Not opening Pandora’s box was a smart move.
- 4y ago