6 ms·
Every time I read about this I'm struck by the number of people who see Assange's treatment as politically motivated and seem unable to accept the possibility t
by jgrahamc 15y ago
Every time I read about this I'm struck by the number of people who see Assange's treatment as politically motivated and seem unable to accept the possibility that he assaulted two women.
- zobzu 15y agoits hard to believe he assaulted the woman when you read what she says, did you read it? its like your gf complaining that you had sex last night and she didn't agree to it, cause she was asleep that time - oh wait - in fact she wasn't asleep.
- hitonagashi 15y agoThe judge isn't disputing that. He's saying that it is necessary to face a trial to determine it, and he isn't going to just brush the charges away and say they were definitely nothing. He's saying there's enough uncertainty that there should be a trial to answer it.
- jrockway 15y agoWhat's odd is that they only want to question him. Can't they question him, and if they don't like the answers, then extradite him? It all sounds a little odd to me. I would just say, "I'm not going to answer your questions, so save yourself the cost of the flight and arrest me when you get some evidence."
- gillianseed 15y agoThis is something which has been brought up here in Sweden by people with legal background: First the prosecutor at call (Marianne Ny) decided to arrest Julian Assange on the accusations from the two women. Meanwhile the news of his arrest has somehow been leaked to Expressen (a daily newspaper) the same evening. Next day the chief prosecutor dismisses the case, this should have been the end of it. However once Assange leaves the country, Marianne Ny (prosecutor on call) brings up the case again, and somehow manages to have Assange arrested on suspicion of rape, sexual assault, and has issued a european arrest order in order to question him. This makes no sense, Marianne Ny says that the purpose of the international arrest is to 'question him', why couldn't she do that while he was still in Sweden? Why turn down the offers to question him on video conference or at an embassy in England BEFORE extraditing him given that Marianne Ny herself says that she doesn't have enough evidence to prosecute Assange and only wants to hear him at this time? Also given the huge costs that an 'international arrest order' brings along, to do so for questioning a suspect in such a weak case as this is unprecedented. Yes, this is political.
- sukhbir 15y agoAny particular reason that you believe the alleged rape allegations more than the fact that they may _actually_ have been politically motivated? I mean, it's difficult to take sides without knowing what did transpire.
- jgrahamc 15y agoWhat I believe is what I see happening. Sweden has asked for him to be extradited to face charges for alleged crimes in their country. It doesn't seem unreasonable for them to ask for that, nor for Britain to comply. My point was that I am surprised by the people who do take sides. Surely, the right thing is for him to be tried in Sweden as that's what the rule of law would require and to see what the outcome is.
- mike-cardwell 15y agoAt the same time, it's good that we have judicial oversite on this and he wasn't just extradited by default. I don't want to live in a country where I can be forcibly deported at any time, just because some foreign country wants to question me.
- jodrellblank 15y ago"It's right because it's the law" wince
- jgrahamc 15y agoI didn't say that. I was referring to the 'rule of law' not the 'law' itself. For example, was it right that Turing was tried for his homosexuality? Yes, it was right. I believe that the law itself was despicable but it was right that he was tried as that was the law at the time of his 'offences'. I believe that same standard applies to Assange. He is alleged to have broken Swedish law, the British courts believe that under European law the right procedure has been undertaken for the extradition and so we see the process of law operating.
- 15y ago
- archangel_one 15y agoIt's quite possible that he did, but that's not proven yet. In the meantime, why should I not see it as politically motivated as well? It doesn't seem at all unbelievable to me that governments might stoop to some pretty dodgy behaviour to try to silence him.
- jgrahamc 15y agoI agree with that, but setting him up on some sexual assault charge that itself seems a bit flimsy doesn't seem like much of a government operation. Surely, if they wanted to frame him they could do better than that. How hard could it be to set him up on phony charges of being involved with child pornography? If you want to take the guy down then do that, or something that'll stick.
- mseebach 15y agoOr even a proper rape with strong, consistent stories.
- burpee 15y agoConsidering Assange has probably been pretty careful and paranoid, I wouldn't be surprised if this was the strongest thing "they" could find.
- jgrahamc 15y agoIt doesn't sound like he's been very careful. Between sleeping with random women who his supporters claim are CIA agents of some sort, and using the same password for different secret files... But truthfully how hard would it be to honeytrap this guy? Suppose you go with my child pornography scenario, your sexy blonde Swedish secret agent only has to get close enough to slip a USB key into Assange's luggage so that when he flies through LHR customs can stop him and discover it. And if he checked any luggage it would be even easier.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- nextparadigms 15y agoDid you follow the story? There are a lot of inconsistencies with what the women are saying. There is little doubt in my mind that they are lying.
- jgrahamc 15y agoThat's for a court to decide. And a Swedish one at that, since that's where the alleged offences occurred.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoI suggest you should read up on the case. There is a certain level of ridiculousness beyond which any thinking person can realize the charges are nonsensical. Here is Glenn Beck explaining the charges (cause he's funnier than a translation of swedish court documents): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sVt-WD-p950 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sVt-WD-p950 Sending him to Sweden only makes sense if he will get a fair trial there. Based on the fact that this case hasn't been dropped, and the trial will be held in secret, there is a good chance that he may not.
- wildster 15y agoIs Glen Beck really the best source of information on this? I prefer wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_Judicial_Authority_v_Julian_Assange http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_Judicial_Authority_v_Ju...
- eli 15y agoYou seem to be saying the Swedish laws and the Swedish court system are ridiculous. That's a fine opinion, but when you visit another country you have to obey by its laws regardless of your opinion on them.
- loup-vaillant 15y agoHe talked about the case, not about the whole system.
- kzrdude 15y agoI agree, yet this case is unproportional. It is not normal in sweden that crime victims are given this huge service when suspects escape abroad. There are long lists of worse cases that have simply been dropped because the suspect escaped sweden. In any case, Assange's done time at this point is more than he can expect to be sentenced to if that happens, and so if convicted he should be promptly released anyway.
- tjogin 15y agoThere are a lot of things wrong with this case, but this is not one of those things. First, normal suspects are harder to find. Assange is a semi-official person, not a lot of work went into tracking him down. Second, the case was already opened. Assange's location in the world did not affect it. It'd be different if Assange's identity was not known, and if, at the time of making the decision to investigate the case further, his whereabouts were unknown and him likely in another country.
- dagw 15y agoThis case looks politically motivated even if we assume he's 100% guilty of everything he's accused of. Sweden basically never spend this amount of efforts and resources to get 'normal' people extradited, even when they're accused of far worse things that Assange is accused of. Had he been just some tourist there is no way in hell they'd bother with any of this. That being said I don't think there is some big dark conspiracy with the CIA pulling the strings, but more a case of local prosecutors and politicians who saw a chance to make a name for themselves, and a tiny country with self-esteem issues desperately wanting to swing their dick with the big boys (and I say that last bit as a Swede).
- gillianseed 15y agoYes this is obviously politically motivated. Not only are the allegations insanely hard to believe, night after the 'alledged rape' the 'victim' went to a party with Assange and was seen enjoying herself in his company. Then later she and her best friend (who also had sex with Julian Assange during his visit in Sweden, go figure!) decided to go to the police and press charges. Then the case was dismissed by a chief prosecutor, brought up again by another prosecutor, dismissed and then brought up again, just as if there was some 'pressure' from somewhere to take this to court. After that, swedish high-profile lawyer Claes Borgström suddenly takes the case on behalf of the women. Non-political my ass. What Assange claims to fear, and with our spineless government here in Sweden I can't blame him, is that he will be extradited from Sweden to the US.
- eli 15y agoSweden basically never spend this amount of efforts and resources to get 'normal' people extradited I've heard this claim before, but is there any data to back it up. If Sweden believes a sex crime has been committed on its soil it has the right and the duty to seek to prosecute the perpetrator.
- dagw 15y agohttp://www.aftonbladet.se/nyheter/article12621641.ab http://www.aftonbladet.se/nyheter/article12621641.ab is the first example I can find (it's in Swedish). The crime in this case is violent assault. Basically the police caught the guys, who then confessed, but fled the country (back to Ireland) while out on bail. So they have the name and address of the people involved, but can't be bothered to try to get them extradited. The money quotes from the prosecutor is: "If we where to try to bring home everybody who commits a crime that isn't serious enough we'd never get anything done...It doesn't work like that, we only do that (attempt to extradite) for serious crimes, like murder".
- tjogin 15y agoI think neither. The treatment have most likely not been politically motivated, as Sweden's justice system doesn't work that way. Politicians can't really sway prosecutions. It's also likely that Assange is not guilty of rape (the allegations have a lot of holes and inconsistencies in them), though probably guilty of being an asshole. Alas, that's not a crime. Nevertheless, this is not a reason to drop the case without investigating it properly.
- octover 15y agoI always wondered why if the extradition is just to question him, it would be cheaper to just fly out a Swedish prosecutor/team and conduct the interview in the UK. Then they could determine if it should file charges and from what I understand the extradition for a trial is clearer and simpler to obtain. Swedish prosecutors might be immune from official or open political pressure, but I'm sure back channels exist. That said I don't think any are being used in this case. One thing I've seen a handful of times in Sweden, is a problem the US has too, prosecutors trying to make a name for themselves. I'd say that is what is overcoming the shaky facts of the case, a prosecutor who thinks it could pay off career wise.
- beagle3 15y agoI have no specific knowledge of the Swedish justice system. But any system can be swayed, and from 3000 miles away, the Swedish system doesn't look really resilient: e.g. http://www.zeropaid.com/news/9622/swedish_prosecutor_wont_investigate_top_cops_mpaa_ties/ http://www.zeropaid.com/news/9622/swedish_prosecutor_wont_in... , and both the Pirate Bay trial and the Assange case look like a charade. If you believe that there's such a thing as an independent, only-cares-about-the-law-and-not-about-any-ties-and-pressure justice system out there, there's a bridge near my house that I can offer to sell you. Things aren't (much) different now than they have always been - there's law for the common people; there's law for the influential people; and when you upset the _really_ influential people, the law will be rewritten against you, retroactively.
- tjogin 15y ago> I have no specific knowledge of the Swedish justice system. But... Thanks for your input! > If you believe that there's... I don't. What I know is that sweden prides itself on having the strongest freedom of speech laws in the world (which is why Assange wanted to bring Wikileaks there in the first place), and that other disruptive forces like piratebay haven't felt any governmental pressure in the past. I've seen nothing that suggests that any government official have commited the serious crime of involving themselves in a particular prosecution case. It's extremely unusual for a politician to even offer their opinion about a particular case, as that is borderline illegal for them to do. Most likely, government officials weren't involved in this case. Most likely, it's just another overblown rape charge. Sweden has lots of those, as they're constantly redefining what constitutes rape. Slippery slope. But whatever you and I think, we'll find out for sure if/when Assange faces trial in Sweden. If he is found not guilty, clearly the government couldn't or didn't sway the prosecution. If he is convicted, then at least the possibility that some government official did intervene exists.
- tomlin 15y agoWell, it's not that simple. It may be true that he assaulted two woman - and that deserves attention and proper justice. The question is really - why does the media pay more attention to this than the landslide of evidence against our elected leaders? I try to keep a pretty sane, "normal", law-abiding lifestyle, but it would take a motivated official about 10 minutes to find dirt on me. And I'd imagine a lot of it isn't necessarily surprising nor as bad as it might sound. Not saying Assange doesn't deserve to be punished for his wrongdoing, just don't think it should be held as being more important than if someone like myself committed those offences. If I helped uncover several cables illustrating corruption among elected officials everywhere, I shouldn't be surprised to be on the news often for uncovering incredibly important, politically sensored information.
- revscat 15y agoContrariwise, I am struck by the number of people who do not believe this to be politically motivated. Assange greatly upset a number of powerful entities, from financial powerhouses to the US State Department. They each have the motivation and the ability to railroad those whom cause them problems. WikiLeaks became Enemy Number One after the State Department cables. I'm sorry, but if you think this is anything other than politically motivated persecution you are simply mistaken.
- ubernostrum 15y agoTo be honest, when even Naomi Wolf says something's not right about the prosecution of an alleged rape, it's probably worth stepping back and considering that there could be another dimension to it: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/naomi-wolf/jaccuse-sweden-britain-an_b_795899.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/naomi-wolf/jaccuse-sweden-brit... Choice quote: In other words: Never in twenty-three years of reporting on and supporting victims of sexual assault around the world have I ever heard of a case of a man sought by two nations, and held in solitary confinement without bail in advance of being questioned -- for any alleged rape, even the most brutal or easily proven. In terms of a case involving the kinds of ambiguities and complexities of the alleged victims' complaints -- sex that began consensually that allegedly became non-consensual when dispute arose around a condom -- please find me, anywhere in the world, another man in prison today without bail on charges of anything comparable.
- brudgers 15y agoThe political implications of Assange's extradition and exposure to prosecution are the big story regardless of his innocence or guilt. In addition, the degree to which spycraft entails placing people in compromising sexual situations, as well as, the explicit actions taken by the US and other wealthy governments in the interest of neutralizing and containing Wikileaks (e.g. trying to cut off funding), when combined with the vast resources available for a counter-espionage operation, certainly make a setup plausible even to people without tinfoil beanies. Heck, the honeypot meme was even proposed here on HN. That's not to say Assange didn't violate Swedish law. But as Stallman's rider might be said to illustrate, it can would pretty damn easy to place a couch sleeping nomad in a compromising position. And although I in no way condone or approve of sexual assault, from a utilitarian standpoint, the ability of Wikileaks to continue its mission is highly likely to curb much worse behavior on a much larger scale. In my opinion, the argument that it is more important to hold governments and corporations accountable for their actions than it is to hold Assange accountable for his deserves the same consideration as arguments regarding the justifications for the wartime actions Assange helped expose.