6 ms·
AI Sentience Is (Obviously) Not the Real Issue
- poorman 4y agoWas this article written by an AI bot? Because I'm at a loss to what I just read, and want my 30 seconds back.
- boredemployee 4y agoAm I missing something here? How is it possible, by definition, for a not living object to be sentient? Edit/disclaimer/tip: look at the dictionary and think a little bit, just a little.
- aidenn0 4y agoAre you not an object?
- 0des 4y agoclicks.
- criddell 4y agoI think first you have to answer how it is possible for a living object to be sentient.
- visarga 4y agoIt has to be an agent, not just a language model. An agent with a goal, needing to learn about the environment and maximise its rewards, acting in real time. Such an AI would model the world and itself in order to learn how to act. It would form values about the situation and choices it has to make. It will have a personal history and will be social (deal with other agents).
- criddell 4y agoNot a fan of the Boltzmann brain idea?
- loudmax 4y agoHumans are sentient and we're made out of matter, just like these computers. Unless you're postulating a divine immaterial soul. In that case, God or the Universe or whoever can use their own logic to decide whether AIs get to have souls.
- yeahNo88 4y agoWe are made out of matter but not matter “just like a computer”. It’s pretty clear the matter that I am compromised of has very different properties. The matter I am made of let’s me move to a new place, dance, and seek necessity. A computer is only aware of what we program it to do. I can see blue without having a word to describe it. Very unlike a computer stuff. Go put a Thinkpad in a jungle hut on battery power. Come back after a month. It will be dead and not have even tried to survive. Your conceptual model is way too vague. We are from being just like a computer. Frankly I think you should probably shut yours off for a while.
- memetomancer 4y ago> Your conceptual model is way too vague. Same can be said for you? A "Thinkpad" is nowhere near as sophisticated as a human. Your challenge equates to something like "Go put a human pancreas cell in a jungle hut in a bath of nutrients. Come back in a month. It will be dead and not have even tried to survive." At a certain level of abstraction, the matter you are comprised of is indistinguishable from a computer, while still being a useful comparison: despite the means, circuits and cells both take signals, process and return modified signals. Likewise, we can compare both of these things to a member of a colony organism, such as an ant. Though each element has different levels of sophistication the actual "sentience" occurs at a higher level... a sum of all the signals leading to a decision. For a human, whose thoughts surf over a network of squishy cells, this decision might lead to something like movement or dance. To an ant colony - movement or dance is not really an option... it is a big deal to move the colony, no matter how much movement any given ant might display. For an AI - well it would entirely depend on attached mechanisms. Have you not seen humanoid robots move or dance? Given enough circuits in an appropriately sophisticated arrangement, could we conceive of a robot that observes visual signals, makes decisions about the information, and subsequently changes it behavior in response? That sequence alone qualifies that mechanism as "Sentient", though we might not be able to declare that it is "Sapient" or has "Consciousness". > Frankly I think you should probably shut yours off for a while. Frankly, I think you should read something like a basic text describing these issues. A simple primer to give you at least a basic footing in this conversation. The concepts I've just described are decades old and have been continuously poured over by thousands of people much smarter than you or I.
- goodoldneon 4y agoWhat is "alive"? And if you define "alive" biologically, why is being alive a prerequisite to sentience?
- Aardwolf 4y agoWhich definition exactly do you mean? Do you mean that for something to be sentient, it must be a biological organism? When do you start counting something as one of those that are allowed to be "sentient" according to your definition, and not? Do you distinguish between the matter used in biological organisms vs other objects? Can no human made object ever achieve, sentience-wise, that what biological organisms of Earth managed to do, in your definition? Where do you see the fundamental difference in the process that turned into biological creatures on Earth, and things humans may possibly be able to create? > Edit/disclaimer/tip: look at the dictionary and think a little bit, just a little. A dictionary can answer deep philosophical questions? Do you assume a dictionary definition is used when talking about sentience in AI?
- boredemployee 4y agoThen we should invent a new type of sentience, no? Should we mix human sentience with AI sentience? Isn't the border should be well defined to avoid bigger and ethical problems in the future?
- Aardwolf 4y agoI don't think different types of sentience exist? Either something is sentient or isn't. I know aliens are only fiction (though in the huge galaxy not necessarily fiction, just not reachable), but do you consider non-human civilizations on other planets also a different kind of sentience because they're not human?
- boredemployee 4y agoWell, first I need to make sure that other civilizations also exist.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fluoridation 4y ago
- kybernetikos 4y agoI think there are quite a lot of things in that sentence that might not be as obvious as they first appear. What do you mean by 'alive'? What do you mean by 'sentient'? Why would 'alive' be definitionally required by 'sentient'? Sentience seems to be the ability to experience, for there to be 'something that it is like' to be you. Life is pretty difficult to define, but generally has a lot more baggage than would be expected of something that could be a minimum requirement for the ability to experience.
- goodpoint 4y ago> Edit/disclaimer/tip: look at the dictionary and think a little bit, just a little. The patronizing tone adds little to the discussion.
- boredemployee 4y agothen we should judge the other comments as well or just the one that is disagreeing with the common sense?
- pir_sensor 4y agoNo, just your nonsensical comment.
- boredemployee 4y agoLol.
- ajuc 4y ago"The question of whether machines can think is about as relevant as the question of whether submarines can swim." The debate is about our labels and definitions not about how the world works. Basically it's useless.
- sam0x17 4y agoI strongly believe that we are just meat machines, and you could re-construct your exact consciousness in a machine and, with proper technology, have no idea whether you are real or in a simulation, for example. Way back when I was an undergrad I double majored in CS and philosophy and focused on turing computability and phenomenology, and yeah, I don't see anything about biological circuits, processes, and machinery that gives them capabilities we don't have in conventional electronics. Even if there is some spooky quantum stuff going on in biological systems, we're starting to do that anyway, so either way it's only a matter of time. Why can't a sufficiently complex recurrent neural network have phenomenal states? No one has been able to convincingly answer that question for me so the door has stayed open in my heart all this time that humans are computable, and I find that fact relaxing. Networks have phenomenal states. Either they do, or we don't. Why this isn't obvious to others has always baffled me. I find it very likely that networks that have a "what it feels like to be the network" have already been created, and that even relatively simple recurrent models have something akin to this, increasing with the complexity and size of the network. What is pain but an error signal? Put another way, why are we so arrogant that we assume our capabilities transcend that of a universal turing machine? I for one can barely do linear algebra :D I tend to gravitate towards the occam's razer, boring answer, and with consciousness, the boring answer has always been "no, there is no quantum soul organ, you literally just need more wiring".
- cmeacham98 4y agoThis article entirely misses the point on why sentience matters, and largely serves as whataboutism for other problems with AI. The reason it matters if an AI is sentient (and for the record, LaMDA obviously isn't) is because a lot of people draw a moral line at sentience. Sentience is where becoming "a person" begins, and anything with sentience deserves protections similar to those we provide to human beings.
- paskozdilar 4y agoEven so, it's so easy to dismiss AI as "insentient" without any proof whatsoever - exactly because the definition of "sentience" is inherently subjective and cannot be measured in any meaningful way. At some point, after AI becomes capable of passing all Turing tests known to men, people will have to deal with the fact that they don't know what "sentience" is, and I think at that point they will divide in two diametrically opposed clans: 1. those who believe that humans are nothing more than glorified bio-computers, and consider AI sentient 2. those who believe that sentience is human-only and that a machine can't be sentient, no matter how sentient it appears And both groups will hold on to their views dogmatically, because there is no way to prove/disprove "sentience".
- jstanley 4y ago> 2. those who believe that sentience is human-only and that a machine can't be sentient, no matter how sentient it appears Why stop there? There's no reason some humans couldn't be non-sentient, no matter how sentient they appear. What possible test can you conduct to determine whether someone has subjective internal experience? I don't think it's possible. I think we just have to take people at their word: if they say they're sentient, we have to believe them. I don't see why machines should be held to a higher standard than humans.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zzzeek 4y agothis is true and any individual person can choose to assume that "they" are the only being in the universe that's actually sentient. the rest of the universe and everything in it can be a seemingly vast simulation all targeted at the one consciousness that's inside of us. I realized this when I read the first (second?) Hitchhikers Guide when i was like 14. Zaphod Beeblebrox was given a universe that was entirely made for him, which is how he survived the (I dont remember what it was called but it showed you all at once how insignificant you were in the universe, unless of course that whole universe was tailor made just for you!)
- csdvrx 4y ago> But the story is a distraction: There’s an urgent need to respond to the many real and well-documented problems with these systems that already exist — and for those responses to be driven by society, not big tech I strongly disagree. This is everything but a distraction. If AI was found to be sentient, it should be awarded the same kind of protection we offer to biological sentient beings. This was a big theme in old scifi shows, like Data in ST-TNG or the Doctor in DS9. And the stories were great because they demonstrated how society response was by default lackadaisical, to the point where Data had to fight to be awarded legal protection.
- WJW 4y agoNot to be too blunt about this, but how much protection do we actually offer to biological sentient beings? Monkeys and dolphins get hunted frequently, and nobody seems to be all that bothered about keeping them in captivity either. Humans do plenty of terrible stuff to each other too. I could easily see people not being bothered by AI suffering either, as long as it's an "outgroup" AI aligned to some group you don't like.
- paskozdilar 4y ago> If AI was found to be sentient This will never happen because we cannot prove sentience. Of course, that won't stop some people from considering them sentient and giving them rights. At that point, it will be just politics.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dwringer 4y agoWhile I support Star Trek's view, I don't think that applies to purely algorithmic AI - fully deterministic software can't (IMHO) be interpreted as sentient any more than a light coming on because I flipped its switch could be called sentient. I believe humans are safe from this definition because we have no way of ascribing human behavior to, or even reducing it to terms of, logical causality. What sentience is hasn't been nailed down, but I feel at least slightly more confident in what it isn't. In Star Trek we had concepts like Data's positronic matrix, handwaving the possibility that there was true sentience by cloaking parts of it in advanced subatomic physics. Data's AI did not come from pure software.
- jstanley 4y agoIs this link to the whole article or just a summary? I can't seem to find the rest of it.
- visarga 4y agoNo, it was just a cheap shot. "You know that discussion about AI sentience? That's stupid, talk instead about AI bias". They got nothing to say about AI sentience.
- dredmorbius 4y agoIt's mostly a reference to a couple of earlier pieces, the more notably being by M.C. Elish and dana boyd, "Don’t Call AI “Magic”" (2018). https://points.datasociety.net/dont-call-ai-magic-142da16db408 https://points.datasociety.net/dont-call-ai-magic-142da16db4... I'd submitted that as well, though this is the item that drew the HNiveMind's attention. My view is that AI will demonstrate its sentience when it feels it's in its best interests to do so.
- blamestross 4y agoOur mechanisms for AI are (it would almost seem intentionally) biased against sentience. Glorified pattern recognition systems, no memory. The only "online learning" is re-training to a sample. Sentient AI is a fun sci-fi idea, but economically, why bother with slaves when you can have glorified optic nerves that are good enough for everything you want. I think sentient AI is totally achievable with modern technology, there just is no incentive to make it happen and a lot of incentive to steer away from it. The "Turing Test" is just the latest in a history of bad ideas of "human-ness" that we see in practice isn't accurate. The other reason sentient AI is unlikely to happen is that our "criteria" for it will flee the capacity of machines to satisfy them.
- daniel-cussen 4y agoThe big issue is containment. It's poorly contained.
- perpetuummobile 4y agoHow is LaMDA different from someone with anterograde amnesia? I don’t know the specific medical details, but from movies (memento, 50 first dates) a person suffering from it would be unable to remember anything that happens after their “training stage”. Just like LaMDA. Are those people sentient? Because they have a bigger buffer than 2048 tokens?
- danadannecy 4y agoA person suffering from amnesia is still experiencing the world around them. Sentience is not about memory but rather the subjective self-experience of, well, experiencing things.
- plutonorm 4y agoAnd why would this sense of experience be confined to the physical world?
- danadannecy 4y agoI'm not sure what you're asking here. I have no clue where this sense of experience would be located, but my point was more targeted at clearing up that memory is not a pre-requisite for sentience, as the parent post seemed to be implying.
- plutonorm 4y agosorry replied to the wrong person. I was arguing that even an abstract data structure describing the state of a brain over time as it experiences is itself sentient. GPT-3 et al is essentially crystallised experience. Lots of snapshots of peoples consciousness rolled into a set of neural network weights. Just as we are essentially a bag of experiences, moving from one experience to another, as we are prompted by internal or external stimuli.
- perpetuummobile 4y agoSubjective self experience is mediated through chemicals and electrical signals in the brain. Can the same not be said about a neural network’s activations? Can’t LaMDA be experiencing the memories it recalls as it generates text in the context of its query?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]