5 ms·
I dunno. All models are wrong, some are useful. This tells me that having debt and no way to reliably pay it off is a really bad situation to be in. Consider i
by roenxi 4y ago
I dunno. All models are wrong, some are useful.
This tells me that having debt and no way to reliably pay it off is a really bad situation to be in. Consider income vs. expenses. If the first is consistently higher, life is relaxed. If the second, life is very stressful. If they match then life seems OK then falls apart following some reasonably short-term time horizon. This model bakes that in to the assumptions and sends a lot of people broke, as we might predict.
The two interesting questions that follow from this seem to be:
1. How to convince people who are doing OK to consistently spend less than they earn?
2. How to deal with chronically indebted people who can't or won't save money?
- ginko 4y agoEven without debt (i.e. if a person has no money for a round it won't give a dollar to anyone) the result is more or less the same: https://www.masswerk.at/misc/wealth/ https://www.masswerk.at/misc/wealth/
- SMAAART 4y agoOf course! It's the Natural Distribution at work.
- Applejinx 4y agoDeath is natural too. As intelligent people, we're not only obliged but fascinated with the problem of overcoming harmful things in our environments. This distribution is without merit and counts as a harmful thing. I'm not sure why any intelligent person would be enthusiastic about it when by definition it represents nothing useful, and at worst damages potentially useful economic players for no benefit at all.
- roenxi 4y agoYeah, that model is assuming everyone consistently spends about what they earn without people having a saving/spending personal drift. Which is cool enough, models can assume what they like. But that certainly isn't how people should operate - if you spend what you earn, sooner or later a surprise will bankrupt you. Helpful tip: nobody should plan to get that outcome. It sucks. Save some money.
- SMAAART 4y ago> 1. How to convince people who are doing OK to consistently spend less than they earn? I don't believe we can. Not sure under what premises we should, in a way we (society) already do, personal finance training is only a quick google search away. Free will has its price. > 2. How to deal with chronically indebted people who can't or won't save money? We (society) can offer tools, but then it's up to the individuals to use them, or not: * Bankruptcy * Personal Finance training that's only a quick Google search away. In both cases we need to thread carefully, Free Will and Agency are things that we (society) don't want to mess with.
- iso1631 4y ago> 1. How to convince people who are doing OK to consistently spend less than they earn? Rental prices increase to capture any excess income, on average you can't save money because the rental prices will increase to capture it all. One way to avoid this would be to take 10% in taxes and not allow access for X years, thus forcing everyone to save 10%, and thus allowing less money to be spent on rent.
- Applejinx 4y agoCrime increases to capture any excess resources in the absence of functioning society, too. Generally, in a functioning society, price-fixing and collusion and extortion count as crime. I would say the distinction between this and collective rent fixing (coordinated, or as an epiphenomenon of the underlying system with self-interested rational actors) is pretty moot: society either decides to dictate the limits of this behavior, or it does not. The idea that exploding rent prices are inevitable and unquestionable is… well, it's an idea. One might contest the idea of building a functioning society on that assumption. Might consider that behavior being something in the way of criminal behavior, at least on the scale of petty larceny, if not something more serious.
- iso1631 4y agoNot really, when demand outstrips supply prices will rise, econ101
- jgalt212 4y ago> then falls apart following some reasonably short-term time horizon. Only if it's student debt you owe. It can still take years to foreclose on a house.
- t0bia_s 4y ago"2. How to deal with chronically indebted people who can't or won't save money?" Why save a money when they are worthless (inflation)?
- dgb23 4y agoIt is interesting that people spend their money more or less on the same things proportionally, regardless of their wealth and income. Two exceptions: Richer people spend more on education and long-term assets that generate further wealth. There is a threshold where you have enough so to speak and can start investing in the future. I would say this is typical for the middle class. There is potential to spend in a smarter way here. You get more opportunities, social currency etc. But being poor is expensive. You have to spend money on subpar quality products because you need them. You pay interest on different forms of debt, which keeps you down. You are constantly worried about the next large bill and are being pestered by bureaucracies and owners (banks, state, landlord etc.). So below the threshold you get pushed down, above the threshold you get lifted up. It takes incredible effort and discipline to pass the threshold from below. > 2. How to deal with chronically indebted people who can't or won't save money? 1) There's two aspects to this. One I described above and I'm pretty sure this represents the vast majority of cases. Cover the basics with free education, cheap housing and good infrastructure and allow debt forgiveness or just give them money or interest free loans. Basically make sure that the lowest points in the graph (OP) is livable and dignified. This way everyone gets more opportunities to do really good stuff and everyone benefits from that across all layers. Plain and simple. 2) There are also people who are just wired to fuck this up for whatever reason, they need more support and care than anyone else. If they are uncooperative you have to let bang their head into the wall and hope they learn from the pain. You can't help everyone though. It has to be a two way street.
- bko 4y ago> So below the threshold you get pushed down, above the threshold you get lifted up. It takes incredible effort and discipline to pass the threshold from below. At the very low end you could be pushed down. If you can only afford $5000 for a car, it'll be expensive in the long run. But its also true that on the high end you get pushed down as well. If you have a lot of money and feel the need to buy an expensive car that's no more reliable than a much cheaper car. Plus you have to pay more for insurance, maintenance, etc.
- Applejinx 4y ago
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y ago> How to convince people who are doing OK to consistently spend less than they earn? OR, rephrased How do you convince people who are doing OK to not increase prices so that other people's expenses won't exceed their incomes?
- bko 4y ago> This tells me that having debt and no way to reliably pay it off is a really bad situation to be in. How do you get that from this model? In this model it's equally as likely to go from -50 to 50 as it is to go from 100 to 150. What I get from this model is there may be natural discrepancies in wealth not necessarily attributable to a systematic bias. It's what Taleb likes to call Mediocristan vs Extremistan. The tallest person won't be 100 times taller than the median person, but the richest person may be well over 100 times richer than the median person. https://albertoguerrero.net/mediocristan-vs-extremistan/ https://albertoguerrero.net/mediocristan-vs-extremistan/
- roenxi 4y ago> In this model it's equally as likely to go from -50 to 50 as it is to go from 100 to 150. It isn't. You can see that the distribution isn't symmetric, that the individual bars aren't random walks and the equations used are explained down below the graphs.
- Applejinx 4y agoI think by definition it is, but people assume because it is, that means the distribution will be relatively sane. The whole problem is that it's just as likely to go from -50 to 50 as it is to go from 100 to 150, but this does NOT in any way change the fact that actors will exist within the system that end up at 1000 for no good reason, causing lots of other actors to be at -50 for no good reason. The fact that it's just as likely for one of 'em to randomly get lucky and start surging up to 1000, as it is for the actor at 1000 to go to 2000, is not the point. Point being, it's not about merit, it's about the automatic emergence of that distribution when it's not warranted and is in fact harmful. (assuming that the points being awarded in an economic model have anything to do with existence and the ability to function, create and innovate versus being stifled and unable to execute on ideas)
- caracustard 4y ago1. That's their personal choice. The only thing you could do is find them a financial advisor or tell them about investing. People change their financial attitudes when they understand that money can be used to make more money. 2. Analyze their spending and understand what skillset they have that would allow them to obtain either a higher paying job or become self-employed.
- masswerk 4y agoAuthor here (late to the show). I think, there are two things to be learned from this: a) Inequality is not just the fault of some actors, who are either ingenious/proficient/hard-working/greedy or incompetent/insufficient/lazy, but a natural byproduct of interaction. b) We should be careful when attributing economic success to merit, since this may be just a tautological assertion of inherent random processes, even in a model as simple as this. Now imagine, what will happen, if we add systematic biases of all kind, the costs (and profits) of debt being another of these factors. What this may mean in terms of politics and if there arises any kind of obligation for the society that enables and necessitates these interactions is left to the beholder.