4 ms·
That is one of the two concerns. The other concern, is that will be a paid product. It's users decide to pay or not, based on the quality of the code suggestio
by belter 4y ago
That is one of the two concerns.
The other concern, is that will be a paid product. It's users decide to pay or not, based on the quality of the code suggestions.
The quality of the code suggestions are tied to the quality of the training corpus. The manufacturer of the product needs to get permission, explicitly, or implicitly via a license associated with the code corpus, to use the training
set on the building of the commercial product.
Speaking exclusively for US jurisdictions, so far courts seem to have been accommodating to the so called discriminative algorithms, but the jury is still out, for the so called generative algorithms. [1]
Instead of examples like Copilot or Codewhisper producing code, let's think of examples like some of recent advances using Convolutional Neural Networks [2]
What will the Music Industry or Cinema Industry do, if a company uses the Corpus of Music or Movies without asking for further permission? For example, to produce a commercial product, that would allow a user, to create music on the style of Pat Metheny, AC/DC, Abba, or a Cinematic experience on the style of Lord of the Rings?
Surely both the user and the product vendor would be called upon it?
[1] "The Most Important Court Decision For Data Science and Machine Learning": https://towardsdatascience.com/the-most-important-supreme-court-decision-for-data-science-and-machine-learning-44cfc1c1bcaf https://towardsdatascience.com/the-most-important-supreme-co...
[2] https://arxiv.org/pdf/1508.06576v1.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1508.06576v1.pdf
- charcircuit 4y ago>What will the Music Industry or Cinema Industry do, if a company uses the Corpus of Music or Movies without asking for further permission? As a composer or cinematographer you don't have to ask for permission to learn from other people's work, so why should a computer? (rhetorical question)
- belter 4y agoBecause fair use does not mean any use. [1] "...You cannot sample music without permission, no matter how short or long the sample is. Copyright is copyright. And if the sample is recognizable (hell, even if it isn’t recognizable), you’re using another person’s intellectual property in order to construct or enhance your own. You control the copyright to songs you write – and you’d expect the same for your work..." [1] https://diymusician.cdbaby.com/music-rights/clear-samples-to-copyrighted-music/ https://diymusician.cdbaby.com/music-rights/clear-samples-to...