15 ms·
The Modos Paper Monitor
- bowsamic 4y agoYou need a picture or render of it right at the top
- AlbertoGP 4y agoThey do have concept design renders in a follow-up blog post, “Designing the Modos Paper Monitor”: https://www.modos.tech/blog/designing-modos-paper-monitor https://www.modos.tech/blog/designing-modos-paper-monitor
- Toadtoad 4y agoDemo of the music video "Bad Apple" being played on this monitor (or at least an iteration of it): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XduK7wn9SE4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XduK7wn9SE4
- oops 4y agoI wonder what the display's lifetime is with this kind of usage? I see someone asked in the YT comments but it is unanswered. I can't find any official data (as usual with eink) but I have heard that an eink pixel's lifetime is around 10 million pixel transitions. Not sure where that number comes from or how accurate it is and how it varies from one display to the next. But if true, you'd get only a couple days with this kind of usage. Anyone know any more on this?
- azeirah 4y agoI would assume at the very least the people at Modos would run into that problem really soon if the pixels start dying after 10 million refreshes.
- meon46 4y agoI know a lot a people seem to prefer e-paper to LCDs. However, I have not yet found papers that could show a significant benefit with regards to eye strain of e-paper over other types of displays. If you are outside and have reflections, shure - but inside?
- bayindirh 4y agoI also didn't find any papers regarding to differences, but I have my eyes and experience. I feel uncomfortable reading from a high quality OLED (iPhone X) or IPS panel (Apple MacBook Pro displays and an HP EliteDisplay) after reading for an hour or so, but when I open my Kobo Glo HD, I can read for hours without eye strain or feeling uncomfortable, even with front light. It just feels natural and doesn't make my eyes dry, forehead stiff or feeling exhausted. This is a study I'm conducting myself for 5+ years. So, it's enough of a data for me.
- meon46 4y agoThat's interesting I switched from a kindle to an iPad mini a few years ago and except for reading outside in the sun, I didn't notice any downsides concerning the display.
- bayindirh 4y agoI started with a 212 DPI display (PocketBook 626), then moved to Kobo, which is 300 DPI, and the effect was much more dramatic. If you're not using displays all day long, you might not be straining your eyes much, and may not be feeling it, too. Try using some artificial teardrops (without any additives, preservatives or active ingredients). If you feel relieved after using them, you're simply unaware of being uncomfortable, then.
- formerly_proven 4y agoI think it's very common for people to use "wrong" settings on their monitors (besides often bad ergonomics in general). If you have pretty much any amount of natural ambient light in your office, and you don't adjust the monitor's brightness over the course of the day, it's probably wrong for long durations. Many folks seem to leave monitors at default settings, which are generally way too bright for most environments. A simple test would be holding a piece of paper up to the screen - white on the screen shouldn't be brighter than the paper.
- semi-extrinsic 4y agoThey mention the issue of dithering changing "everywhere" when e.g. a mouse cursor is moving, which is obviously distracting. I wonder if you couldn't make an error diffusion dithering technique where the amount of error to diffuse is mollified by the signed distance from the moving pixels? * Seed signed distance function with -1 in all pixels that changed, +1 in static pixels * Use a fast marching method to re-initialize a narrow-band signed distance function * Compute gradient of signed distance to get a vector field * Multiply error to be diffused by a sigmoid function of signed distance * Diffuse error in the direction of the vector field Also, I've found in my own toying around that introducing a bit of randomness in the error diffusion matrix of traditional dithering methods gives much more pleasing results.
- frabert 4y agoThis might interest you: https://forums.tigsource.com/index.php?topic=40832.msg1363742#msg1363742 https://forums.tigsource.com/index.php?topic=40832.msg136374... It's about how to perform realtime dithering of a 3D scene such that the amount of annoyance you describe is minimized
- semi-extrinsic 4y agoThanks for the link, that was a nice writeup indeed! It's a different technique though, using a dither pattern gives a very different look from error diffusion (which IMO looks more natural). But in the example you posted, the pattern is a nice stylistic effect. I might actually have to try and code up what I outlined above to see if it works.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoBlue noise in error diffusion dithering was a thing some decades ago. Perhaps there are better algorithms?: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dither#Digital_photography_and_image_processing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dither#Digital_photography_and... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colors_of_noise#Blue_noise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colors_of_noise#Blue_noise
- AlbertoGP 4y ago> “This is possible and used on eReaders, so texts, images, and UI elements could use different update modes, but not with the current available Eink monitor + software stack. Our controller supports per-pixel update mode settings, but this would need support from the software side.” That “per-pixel update mode settings” sounds very useful for things like interactive books, where the static text could be anti-aliased with grayscale, and moving pictures (physics animation, mathematical graphs, etc.) would be 1-bit monochrome and react smoothly to adjustments. They show something in this direction in their second video, embedded further down in the linked page, where letters being typed are first rendered immediately in 1-bit mode, then after a delay smoothed out.
- londons_explore 4y agoSo... The downside of eink is: To set a pixel to anything other than white or black requires a distracting and time consuming pattern of white and black flashes. But... There exists multiple different patterns of flashes that end up with the same grey scale shade. So the logical solution seems to therefore be for neighbouring pixels to use different flash patterns such that when viewed from a distance the flashes are hidden - ie. At any point in time while the flash pattern is occurring, the average color of an area is the the target colour, even if each individual pixel isn't that shade. Obviously in eink, pixels disrupt neighbouring pixels, and the target colour of a pixel may change during the flashing pattern. You therefore will be requiring a very complex model/optimizer to figure out how to transition every pixel from its current state towards its destination color while maintaining dithered-flicker. Seems like a good target for a tiny per-pixel ML model - put as input a state vector representing the current visible and hidden state of the pixel and a few neighbours, together with the target color, and have the ML model output the next signal to output to the screen and the new hidden state. This could be trained with a screen in the lab with a camera pointed at it outputting random patterns for a few days. You could also have as input to the ML model the temperature and per-screen and per-pixel calibration vectors to deal with process variation, and maybe an encoding for the age of the screen if wear starts to occur. Training should be pretty quick, because on a 1 million pixel screen, every frame is a million training data points. The execution of the ML model would run great on a modest GPU in real-time as a shader - it's the perfect fit for that. It seems this solution covers all the usecases people are wanting... Fast updates for things like mice, fast motion for films, quick updates for typing, high quality for static images, anti aliasing for static text, no blurring for moving things, etc.
- londons_explore 4y agoAlas, I would love to implement this, but the world of eink is filled with patents and lawsuits, and I think that if I implemented this and it worked well I could never sell it. Even if I gave it away for free, I'd probably have lawyers banging on my door wanting to take away my home.
- pooper 4y ago
- fho 4y agoI am still hoping for a large, reasonable priced eInk display that I can frame and hang up on a wall. Does not even have to be color, I would be fine with just changing through different black&white dithered images over time. But large eInk displays are prohibitively expensive for what is basically a gimmick :-/
- nextos 4y agoMe too, but perhaps cheap AMOLEDs will come sooner and they can kind of be an okeyish replacement? If one runs an AMOLED on black background, e.g. a terminal, a text editor or an inverted PDF, only the pixels displaying characters will be lit. Maybe this is good enough? I experimented with an AMOLED tablet displaying inverted PDFs and it felt similar to a Kindle. However, this was my completely subjective perception. It could be that in the long run, it is tiring for the eyes as well. IMHO, the worst part about displays is staring at a bright LED backlight all day long. Screens such as Dell UltraSharp, which are able to dim the backlight a lot and do not flicker feel much better.
- bayindirh 4y agoOLED displays cannot replace E-ink displays. Even reading on dark backgrounds with OLED tires my eyes the same way using an IPS panel. Nothing can replace the dynamics of an e-ink display as of today.
- frosted-flakes 4y agoSharp's Memory LCD comes pretty close. It's a high contrast LCD with a reflective back layer that mimics paper and has very low power consumption. But I believe it's only available on small sizes, and it's a one-bit display (no greyscale). This screen is used in Panic's Playdate game console as well as the Pebble smartwatch. https://sharpdevices.com/memory-lcd/#1615975689583-4d044034-56d122b6-23f8 https://sharpdevices.com/memory-lcd/#1615975689583-4d044034-... https://www.adafruit.com/product/4694 https://www.adafruit.com/product/4694
- 4y ago
- gennarro 4y agoCompanies have tried for years [0] to make progress here and none of these problems (ghosting, refresh time, price) have proved solvable given the quantity of units demanded. I wonder if anything has changed or if this is just an exploratory survey that precedes any of those advances 0: https://cloudconfusing.com/2020/02/07/e-ink-monitors-ready-for-prime-time/ https://cloudconfusing.com/2020/02/07/e-ink-monitors-ready-f...
- HidyBush 4y agoIt's incredible how as a society we have accepted that people must spend hours upon hours glued to screens that were never made to be reading devices. It would be like if we invented sofas before chairs and so every office worker needs to awkwardly work on a sofa instead if sitting on a nice Herman Miller
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 4y agoAre you referring to the use of LCD / OLED emissive screens here? And how does E-Ink fit into this idea?
- bityard 4y agoWere trees made to be reading devices?
- jlturner 4y agoI still use my Pixel Qi display from 10 years ago, love the thing. I’m glad people are still working to make reflective display computing a thing.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoDo you know if anyone is still selling those transflective displays other than second hand market?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ThrowawayR2 4y agoNot transflective but a commercially available fully reflective (non-backlit) LCD display did get discussed on HN not too long ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31203809 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31203809
- chewxy 4y agoPixelqi went out of business :(
- phkahler 4y agoI'm wondering how CAD would look on this. Solvespace already has a high contrast default color scheme. Some people flip it to black on white though.
- dirtyid 4y agoEink experience would improve if there's built in style transfer algo to convert to images/video to be more legible. Something like toonify BW line art with shading.
- dredmorbius 4y agoLine art is e-ink's strength, which is why it's featured so often in adverts or boot / sleep screens. Durer's rhinocerous is phenomenal on a high-quality, large e-ink display. Most photography would benefit by being run through a halftone filter. That's default in "Regal" mode, though "Normal" (highest-quality) mode doesn't do this, and the result is a somewhat posterised image (16-shade greyscale on my Onyx BOOX Max Lumi). Dithering would be another option, and might work. Onyx's most recent image update (as of a couple of days ago) has some improvements in image display which apply to its book reader (NeoReader), and seem to be an improvement. Video should be presented at A2 or X mode. Though quite honestly, animation and e-ink are usually a mistake. As jarring and distracting as animation is on an emissive screen, it's pure anger-fuel on E-ink.
- avgcorrection 4y ago> Native e-ink optimized applications Finally a use for the ex mode of Vim or whatever it’s called.
- grae_QED 4y agoInstead of e-ink displays, I wish companies would try to make strides in transflective lcds [0]. If more companies invested the time and resources, I think that the potential cost savings and technological benefits (such as a higher refresh rate and no ghosting) over e-ink would make a killing. Right now, I only know of one commercial product [1] currently being made that is taking advantage of this untapped market. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transflective_liquid-crystal_display https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transflective_liquid-crystal... [1] https://www.sunvisiondisplay.com/product/SVD-32-Color-RLCD-Computer-Monitor https://www.sunvisiondisplay.com/product/SVD-32-Color-RLCD-C...
- AlanYx 4y agoThe Sun Vision display you linked to is purely reflective, not transreflective.
- speechtotext 4y agoIs anyone aware of any development for a product which can be a fast-refresh monitor while USB-C powered, but has a battery-powered PDF tablet mode when disconnected? I use both a Digital Paper tablet and Mira monitor and suspect that many in the eink cabal would happily give market share to a product that serves both purposes.
- throwawaySG 4y agoThis isn't really a tablet, but may come close enough: https://www.sunvisiondisplay.com/product/SVD-32-Color-RLCD-Computer-Monitor https://www.sunvisiondisplay.com/product/SVD-32-Color-RLCD-C...
- dredmorbius 4y agoThe medium is the message^W affordance. During the aughts, I got used to saying "Linux is not Windows" --- if you're looking for a Microsoft experience on a Free Software operating system ... you're liable to be disappointed. If you accept the strengths, and weaknesses, of a platform, you're going to be far happier. The first computers I used didn't have e-ink displays. They had ink displays. Teletype access to an early Unix system, mostly offering BSD games. No, I didn't do Real Work on those systems.... But I was doing real work on glass-tty VT-200 Wyse terminals about a decade later, also on campus-wide Unix servers. (Benefit: walk into any terminal room, log on, and all my work was Just There.) As I've noted for a while, E-Ink has features which differ from emissive (OLED / LCD) displays: - Persistence is free. Once the display is set, it does not change, even with power shut off. - Pixels are cheap. Current displays tend around 220--300 DPI. That's the effective resolution of most laserprinters (given toner drift and paper coarseness). - Refreshes are ... slowish. Not seconds, but 4-10 Hz is a typically upper end, rather than 60--120 FPS of an emissive display. Higher-quality refreshes may be slower. - Colors are nonexistent to few. My monochrome display offers 16 greyscale shades, though with dithering and/or halftoning, that increases. Photographs appear slightly posterised without those. Colour displays exist, though they're limited in size/format, muted in saturation, slower than B&W e-ink, and carry a price premium. - Paginated navigation is strongly preferred to scrolling. A single whole-screen flush is much better than scrolling a pixel at a time. This is where EInkBro really shines over conventional tablet browsers, in that it supports paginated navigation through a web page. - Displays are reflective rather than emissive. The brighter the ambient light, the easier the display is to read, with direct sunlight being the optimum. I suspect colour displays will also reflect a mix of ink-vs-light colour design / mixing. Ultimately, e-ink applications and platforms should play to the medium's strengths. E-Ink does fixed text and graphics exceptionally well. Operating systems, graphical shells, and controls which reflect this should do well. Those that fight these characteristics will deliver disappointing experiences.
- ladyattis 4y agoYep, I think there's no need to make e-ink into a competitor for oled or lcd monitors. Something like a tablet or small purpose built computer like a POS machine with built in scanner and card reader is something I think would fit best for this kind of display rather than forcing LCD/OLED to handle small form factors but somehow compete on power usage.