4 ms·
I seriously do not understand why people come/stay here given the way they are treated by our government. You must be masochists. Things have actually gotten wo
by ck2 15y ago
I seriously do not understand why people come/stay here given the way they are treated by our government. You must be masochists. Things have actually gotten worse under Obama, not better (and I am liberal).
What is it like in Israel for startups? In theory his kind of internet startup could work from almost anywhere in the world. Since he is in Vancouver now, might as well bring in the tax dollars for Canada.
ps. what is with linking through Digg for this - and they are still framing sites?
- angkec 15y agoI come from China. And US is still way better than China to start a small tech startup. Don't know much about Israel though.
- ck2 15y agoSure, I get that, but if you could go to Vancouver (which apparently is a startup-mecca too) you'd have far less fear about being deported (and ill will from nearly 50% of the population). Why put yourself through that - running a business is enough stress. The USA is like going to a store, filling up your cart, but just before you are about to checkout and make them money, they drag you out the door instead.
- BadassFractal 15y agoI seriously doubt the Vancouver scene is even remotely as big as the one in the Bay Area. The only thing that comes close to SV on this continent is NY, and even that is a decade behind.
- ck2 15y agoBut do you need the "biggest and best" scene, or do you just need a decent environment where what you are trying to do is not uncommon and the resources you need have already been established?
- BadassFractal 15y agoI believe one of PG's latest essays seems to suggest that being in the middle of it all has been vital for many successful businesses out there.
- BadassFractal 15y agoI believe one of PG's latest essays seems to suggest that being in the middle of it all has been vital for many successful businesses out there.
- Zimahl 15y agoI've been at a startup that was about as far outside of the bay area as possible - North Idaho. We had a great product in a nice space and were fairly successful at selling it and making modest profit. But the start was rough. Unless it's a one-person gig (and there aren't many of those out there) you need two things - bodies and money. The further you are away from metro areas the harder it is to find both - the people with the skills either left or are already working somewhere and the investors aren't multi-millionaires, they are angels with $10-20k each, sometimes $100k+. It's possible though. That startup eventually sold but long after a more inferior competitor sold for a lot more which had more to do with their location (Cali, I think in the valley) than how well they functioned. And the company I was with sold for less than we thought it would and long after the window in which acquisition would have been ideal. There's just no visibility outside of major (tech hub) metro areas. You don't get any buzz even if you are in magazines and the like, and you don't have the contacts that can really help you out. It's a major negative. Pure (somewhat educated) conjecture: if that startup would've been in Seattle or Portland it would've sold much earlier and for much more than it did, maybe in year 6 instead of year 10. If in the Bay area I think it would've sold by year 3 instead of year 10.
- mgkimsal 15y agoSounds like if the goals are acquisition and quick payouts, the place to be is SV. However, you indicated that the company in Idaho was better run or had a better product. Isn't that better for the end users in the long run? Wouldn't that indicate there's a better chance of a company staying around for the long haul and providing better service and what not? Wouldn't be surprising at all if your competitor that was acquired was absorbed or shut down within a year. For the founders - sure, that's success - they had an exit. But how is this necessarily good for the long term economics of those businesses? The original video story on this talked about all the jobs that 'high tech entrepreneurs' create. But how long do those jobs last? Sure, there's no such thing as a 30 year job for most people any more, but isn't this type of behaviour contributing or accelerating this trend?
- angkec 15y agoCan you point me to more information about Vancouver for immigrants? I'm still on a student visa in the US but eventually I'll face problems like this Israeli.
- potatolicious 15y agoI grew up in Vancouver, now live in SF. Comparing the startup scene in Vancouver to the one in the Bay Area is like, well, comparing a basket of oranges to an entire orchard. Or a bunny hill to a black diamond run. The level of acceptance for hackers, much less hacker-entrepreneurs, is worlds apart. There are numerous places in Canada that would proclaim the title of "Silicon Valley North", I've lived in almost all of them. None come remotely close.
- cmer 15y agoBeing from China, you have one major advantage over most of us: you're in the booming market of China. If I knew anything about your country, language and culture, I'd probably give it a shot. You should use your situation to your advantage in my opinion. The asian culture is so foreign to us North Americans that it makes it nearly impossible for us to do business over there, yet, there's a huge opportunity.
- angkec 15y agoEveryone thinks this way, but then it's so hard for an average Chinese to succeed in his own country in the form of startups. Seems like there's more barriers facing a Chinese startup than an US equivalent. Plus there's this distant fear that the country will fail sometime in the future and all the sweat into the startup will evaporate. This is probably why so many Chinese are fleeing the country.
- cmer 15y agoWe have the same problems and barriers in the US. Nobody ever said starting a startup was easy.
- angkec 15y agoI know. But having being born in China and stayed in the US for the last 3 years, I feel there are many more barriers for a Chinese startup than a US one. That's why I've started my own in the US, even knowing that there will probably be some messy business when my student visa expires.
- yuvadam 15y agoIsrael is very friendly towards startups. Launching from here is definitely an option, albeit not an optimal one. I can very much understand that Israel's physical and cultural distance from SF can pose a problem. Do not underestimate the importance of being physically close to customers and partners - not to mention VCs.
- antihero 15y agoAlso there's the fact that your tax dollars will very likely be paying to demolish Palestinian homes and blow up Palestinian schools and burn people a live with White Phosphorous. If you start a start in Israel, you will be losing money because (quite like) there's an international boycott on Israeli goods. http://www.bdsmovement.net/ http://www.bdsmovement.net/
- cema 15y agoIncorrect, irrelevant, and close-minded.
- BadassFractal 15y agoIt's similar to what they say about LA: there's a million waiters who are all there hoping for their chance to be the next Brad Pitt or Natalie Portman. You want to be where the action is, it maximizes your chances of success. Sure, you could attempt to run your startup from Milan, Barcelona or Marseille, but the amount of talent and opportunities for support are infinitesimal compared to what SF will have to offer. If you're 100% determined to obtain success at any cost, it's worth packing your bags and leaving Peripherystan to come to the big city.
- mgkimsal 15y ago"it maximizes your chances of success" I'd question whether being in "the valley" really does increase your chance of success, and also question what's meant by 'success'. If you raise a few million in a first or second round, hire people, then close up shop 2 years later, was that a 'success'? That's probably easier to do out in CA, but if you define success as a longer-term sustainable organization, does being out there really make that much of a difference? Successful companies are built all over the place.
- idiopathic 15y agoAgreed, this was my same thinking when I was in the USA until 2008. Sure, my employer and my wife's both offered to get us a green card, but why wait? I had applied to YC earlier that year with an idea for a start-up that was based on my living in DC and was turned down. I went back to the UK, applied with a different idea that was more appropriate to the UK / Europe. That got funded by Seedcamp, and off we went. I have no doubt that the USA / SV is a great place to start a company, but why waste your life trying to satisfy government bureaucrats that you should be allowed in when there are plenty of other places that want you? If you are European, you can move to any of the hubs like London or Berlin. They might not be as brilliant as SV, but they have their own advantages, and the key for an entrepreneur is to get down and make use of these advantages. Folks in the Persian Gulf (I am from Bahrain) can move to any of the hubs there like Dubai or Bahrain, and there are plenty of gaps in the market that an entrepreneur can fill by starting a company. And of course the BRIC countries have huge growth for their own nationals to ride. So why go through the headaches of government immigration? (PS I am really sorry for entrepreneur that this story describes. I just hope fewer people have to go through that fate.)
- econ101 15y agoAlso, entrepreneurs shouldn't forget that if they do get into the US and make it big with their startup, they might be subject to the 30% exit tax (on their net worth) if they ever want to end their relationship with the IRS. They are dangerous people to do business with!
- brc 15y agoEven when visiting, the entire entry process with all the yelling to stay in line and complete your paperwork and fingerprinting and photographing is bad enough, then all the security theatre on the way back out again. You come away with the distinct feeling of being tolerated but not welcome, and that saying the wrong thing to the wrong person at the wrong time could see you detained for a period of time. I always want to say 'OK, I get it, you don't want me here, sorry for trying to do business with your citizens'. But of course I just shut up and smile for the camera.
- anonimo 15y ago> I seriously do not understand why people come/stay here given the way they are treated by our government. You must be masochists. The immigration thing definitely sucks, but other things probably make up for it. You're probably underestimating the good parts of living in the US, especially from the point of view of someone who comes from a poorer country or, in some cases, for an entrepreneur who lives in a developed country but doesn't have access to places like Silicon Valley and NY. Also note that, with the possible exception of Canada and Australia, most other developed countries are at least as restrictive as the US regarding immigration from developing countries. I'm from Brazil, which is considered one of the leading countries among the "emergent" countries. Yes, things have been improving in the last 20 years. But it still sucks. For instance, consider that the GDP per capita in Brazil is still far lower than places like Portugal and Greece, which are not exactly booming. In fact, there's a significant number of Brazilian immigrants in Portugal even though they're not exactly welcoming us with open arms. In another area: half of slums in Rio are now dominated by drug gangs, and the other half by paramilitary militias. One of those militias recently killed a judge. A state congressman had to flee the country due to death threats from militias. I'll take your bureaucratic nightmares anytime. ;-)
- shn 15y agoRule of law trumps everything. Once you start giving special treatment for individuals you do not know where you will end up. I am not saying that this is not happening at all, but law needs to be uphold. Assuming his stay is against the visa law he should definitely leave, and he did the right thing to leave. I am not saying that the laws are perfect either. It took me 9 years to get my permanent residency, so I am someone who has been through the process. I also found article a bit biased, in the sense that it does not give proper detail about his visa status and in what terms he was allowed to the country and why he was asked to leave. Article is emotional. I think the biggest merit of starting a company in US is the aura of credibility it gives. The other is the huge market size. Ask this question yourself, would you be willing to give your credit card number to a (for no particular reason) Hungarian or an Israeli company or to a company from US? How much sense of security do you feel? Of course, ventura capital and startup culture in US is leaps and bounds ahead of the rest of the world.
- kyledeb 15y agoAn unjust law is no law at all.
- danssig 15y ago>I seriously do not understand why people come/stay here given the way they are treated by our government. The US is really good at advertising.