3 ms·
> Most people do not bother to root their Android phones, and it's perfectly possible to pirate iOS apps on non-jailbroken phones, so that point is also moot. T
by acdha 4y ago
> Most people do not bother to root their Android phones, and it's perfectly possible to pirate iOS apps on non-jailbroken phones, so that point is also moot. The people who are technically savvy enough to pirate apps are already doing so whether sideloading is made possible or not.
Your second sentence contradicts the first: the difference is not whether it’s theoretically possible but whether it’s easy and thus widespread. That’s the important distinction and it deserves more careful thought when you’re talking about devices large percentages of the population trust heavily.
> By simply changing non-Messages texts to green, they created an entire dichotomy between messages from iOS devices, and non-iOS.
Similarly, this deserves more careful thought: is the difference the color or the fact that one which isn’t controlled by the phone companies is faster, more capable, more secure and cost less for years?
Again, I’m not saying that Apple is perfect but it’s not as simple as people like to portray it, either. Multiple of the topics here are market failures where governments were deterred from stepping in. What Apple has done is not purely benevolent but it’s also satisfying a lot of users - they didn’t go from niche to one of the most important tech companies because they weren’t doing what people liked (and, no, it’s not “just” marketing or design).
- Apocryphon 4y ago> the difference is not whether it’s theoretically possible but whether it’s easy and thus widespread. That’s the important distinction and it deserves more careful thought when you’re talking about devices large percentages of the population trust heavily. Apple can allow sideloading without making it easy. This whole discussion is about whether or not Apple can craft a user experience that carefully balances between permitting users to use a powerful and potentially insecure ability, and carefully warning them against it, warning off those who are not savvy. I believe they can. > Similarly, this deserves more careful thought: is the difference the color or the fact that one which isn’t controlled by the phone companies is faster, more capable, more secure and cost less for years? I believe it's self-evident. The appearance of the different UI itself, which clashes against Apple's otherwise uniform design scheme, presents its own inherent psychological friction. Certainly, non-Messages apps come with certain poorer performances in Messages. The way group chats get broken up. The inability to respond to Messages. None of that has anything to do with phones being faster, more capable, or more secure. The difference in of itself is created by the users drawing the distinction in their own minds. Similarly, I believe if Apple was to curate the sideloading experience, the majority of iPhone users can simply be guided away from that. And it will remain safely the province of developers and power users. Apple is simply too good at crafting user experiences to not be able to do that.