4 ms·
Otto had realized that United Copper had 105% short interest – i.e., 450,000 shares were trading, yet only 425,000 had been issued, the rest borrowed. But Hein
by anigbrowl 4y ago
Otto had realized that United Copper had 105% short interest – i.e., 450,000 shares were trading, yet only 425,000 had been issued, the rest borrowed.
But Heinze miscalculated. Every one of the twenty brokers could find the stock from buyers other than Heinze. No one defaulted.
Irritatingly, there is no explanation of the miscalculation, or how the 25,000 share difference was made up.
All I am left with is the knowledge that one group of speculators went bust rather than a different group of speculators, and the conclusion that the crypto market will be regulated because it exhibits some vague similarities to this incident in 1907; no discussion at all of the 2008 financial crisis, which seems highly relevant.
- HeavenFox 4y agoIt's actually really simple. The parties short seller sold to can lend their shares out again. Say I own the only share in Acme Corp. A borrows it and sells it to B. B then lent it to C who then sold it to D. Now you have both A and C with short position, despite only one outstanding share.
- anigbrowl 4y agoSure, but they can't both cover it, as D can only sell it back to one of them to return to you. It only works if everyone essentially does the trade in reverse, which requires (illegal) coordination.
- phyalow 4y agoThe key insight is the order of reversal doesn't matter, and that any securities trade/position is eventually reversed (its the only action available). Hence having synthetic positions outstanding via rehypothecation doesnt actually matter as they are fungible with normal float.
- anigbrowl 4y agois eventually reversed (its the only action available) But this assumes normal market operation, which a short squeeze is not. Suppose in the example above A buys the share from D and sells back to the original issuer, who then refuses to lend it out again. C can't pay back B and presumably goes bankrupt. It only makes sense if people are required to lend securities to anyone who wants to borrow them.
- euroderf 4y agoMaybe the company quickly issued more shares, and this info got forgotten in the confusion ?
- anigbrowl 4y agoVery possibly, but there's no way to know without further research. It's a failure of the author to just skip over what actually went wrong.