2 ms·
> So once I sell it, if it's still on my hard-drive am I allowed to listen to it in your world? I don't recall the precise case law that applies to CDs. There'
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
> So once I sell it, if it's still on my hard-drive am I allowed to listen to it in your world?
I don't recall the precise case law that applies to CDs. There's certainly a version of things (probably the one desired by record companies) in which one or both of these is true (a) you can't rip it (b) you can't listen to the rips after you've sold it.
Remember, methods of enforcing such a legal regime are distinct from the regime itself.
> Licences can be irrevocable, so this isn't a necessary property of a licence.
With networked digital technology, it is not always a matter of the legal terms of the license. If the playback mechanism requires contacting a remote server, whether you have a license of not does not matter if said server is no longer in existence.
And sure, licenses can be irrevocable, but those connected with digital media, in general, have not been.
- Closi 4y agoI just mean that a lot of the chats in this thread seem to be saying “if we didn’t have licences, the alternative would be x” Where x describes a licence, just with different licensing terms.