4 ms·
just use PNG. JPEG sucks.
by hulitu 4y ago
just use PNG. JPEG sucks.
- LocalH 4y agoPNG sucks for some uses too. There is no universally perfect image format for all possible use cases.
- jug 4y agoWebP & JPEG XL compress losslessly better than PNG and lossy much better than JPEG. Perhaps not perfect either, but we finally do have formats that can do both — and better than either before.
- igoradamenko 4y agoWell, if we're talking about web, then I it's better to use WebP rather than PNG. It's widely supported by vendors if you do not need to deal with IE: https://caniuse.com/?search=webp https://caniuse.com/?search=webp.
- jeroenhd 4y agoDo note that if you need to target macOS 10 + Safari, WebP is not available. WebP is available for macOS 11, even with overlapping versions of Safari, but Apple relies on the OS image library to render some images and they haven't backported WebP supported when they updated Safari.
- martin_a 4y agoThat is only true for a subset of images, mostly the rather "simple" ones. Try saving photographs as PNG and see your filesize explode.
- Markoff 4y agoor JPEG XL
- igoradamenko 4y agoWell, yeah, unless you want to use it in a browser: https://caniuse.com/jpegxl https://caniuse.com/jpegxl
- bob1029 4y agoJPEG absolutely destroys PNG in areas of performance and size when it comes to typical use cases. Lossy compression is not a bad thing. We need to get over this.
- keyle 4y agoPlease these kind of comments are entirely counter productive and don't add anything to the conversation. No matter the topic, presume some people are truly interested in the topic and feel free to stay off it. There is a space for JPEG and for PNG. Here is a good base reference https://www.a2hosting.com/blog/pngs-vs-jpegs/ https://www.a2hosting.com/blog/pngs-vs-jpegs/
- gruturo 4y agoFor a screenshot? Yeah JPEG sucks. For a diagram with large blocks of uniform color and sharp edges? Yeah JPEG sucks. But for pictures, JPEG is in its comfort zone and it's amazing it is still doing comparatively well after the IT equivalent of 150 years. Only now worthy alternatives are starting to emerge (looking at you JPEG XL), not for lack of trying (looking at you WEBP). It's incredible it managed to stay relevant for so long, and while surely patents, sunken cost fallacies, hardware implementations and inertia played a part, none of this would have mattered if it hadn't been pretty good to start with.
- zinekeller 4y ago> none of this would have mattered if it hadn't been pretty good to start with. Considering that MPEG (and competitors) have evolved due to its deficiencies (the current baseline today is H.264 and not the original version H.261 or even its immediate successor MPEG-1), I'm surprised that JPEG is just showing its deficiencies today and not in 2000. Actually, it's a complement that although multiple file formats were invented to handle lossy pictures but even WebP can't beat JPEG all the time (especially that WebP can only save up to 16k pixels per side while JPEG can handle up to 64k pixels).