3 ms·
> expand NATO membership How could the cause of a conflict be the solution to preventing that conflict? Doing almost anything except attempting to expand NATO
by pessimizer 4y ago
> expand NATO membership
How could the cause of a conflict be the solution to preventing that conflict? Doing almost anything except attempting to expand NATO membership would have prevented the conflict in Ukraine.
- wbl 4y agoNo it would not have. Ukrainian protest in 2014 was driven by wanting EU membership and trade ties. Russia responded with an invasion.
- ceeplusplus 4y agoRussia responded with an invasion because an EU state on their border would be like Mexico being an ally of China on the border of the US. Not saying Russian actions in the war haven't been despicable but if this happened to the US they would invade too. I think the most likely outcome of this war is Ukraine gets split into 2 buffer states, one as a client to Russia and the other as a client to the EU/US. US can't afford to spend the hundreds of billions it would take for Ukraine to win (1000's of tanks, artillery pieces, IFVs, etc) and Putin can't back down now or he'll lose face and be toppled from leadership.
- spamizbad 4y agoI'm not sure if you've been paying attention to the current political situation in Mexico but AMLO has no problem strengthening ties to various countries that "threaten" US interests. And he's free to do so! Mexico is a sovereign country and is allowed to build diplomatic bridges to any nation it chooses. It would be completely inappropriate for the US try an annex Baja California or something in retaliation. Just imagine if the international community took a firmer line on the US during GWOT - half a million lives could've been saved. Edit: Was the US justified in fomenting death squads Latin America because those countries embraced socialism against the wishes of the United States? No? Then why is Russia entitled to a full-scale invasion over Ukraine's western aspirations?
- jonnybgood 4y agoThere are already EU and NATO member states that border Russia and haven't been an issue for Russia. Russia/Putin in all likelihood really invaded because they believe Ukraine is ran by Nazis.
- ceeplusplus 4y agoYou don't really think Putin believes that? Pretty sure that's just Russian propaganda for their domestic audience to justify the invasion. The real reason is preventing a EU ally on their border and gaining access to the gas fields in the Black Sea.
- Animats 4y ago"You don't really think Putin believes that?" He seems to. Putin's clear goal is "Make the Russian Empire Great Again". He's been grumbling since the fall of the USSR that, for the first time in centuries, Russia is a second-rate, "or even a third-rate" power. He wants to turn that around. His role model is Peter the Great. His model of world power is the 19th century, when the British Empire, the Imperial German Empire, the Austria-Hungarian Empire, the Russian Empire, and France had multiple medium-sized wars over land. This is a guy who was personally hammered by the fall of the USSR. The USSR had huge national security organizations and most of them were laid off. Putin himself was driving a cab for a while around 1990. There's a mindset amongst the former national security tough guys that they are supposed to be in charge. Now they are again. The strong rule; the weak cower. Such is the way of the world. Post-USSR capitalism was a disaster for Russia. People starved. The population dropped. That produced demand for a "strong leader", a long-standing theme in Russia. Weak Russian leaders have been disasters. (Kerensky, Gorbachev, etc.) Now, Russia again has a strong leader who bows to no one. Putin is popular. He can't afford to lose a war, though. Russian leaders who lose wars do not live long. He wouldn't survive to retire to a golf course in a warm climate. This is hugely oversimplified, and someone who knows more Russian history could do much better.
- pm90 4y agoWhat you said is all true, but the Nazi thing is almost certainly propaganda. Putin wants to restore the USSR and his justification for annexing Ukraine has been to question the existence of a separate Ukrainian Culture and State. You only have to go over the stuff he’s talked about since the last invasion; most of it is the reunification nostalgia, very little about defeating “Nazis”.
- JanSolo 4y agoI think you're being facetious here. NATO expansion was Russias stated cause of the Ukrainian Conflict. However, Putin's statements since then have made it clear that the real objective is more of an ideological one. He wants to expand and build into a sort of neo-russian empire. Ukraine was considered the easiest target because of the ongoing Donbass conflict. However it could easily have been Georgia, Khazakstan, Azerbaijan or others.
- soperj 4y agoWhat caused Russia to invade Georgia in 2008 then?
- dmpk2k 4y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/world/2008/apr/01/nato.georgia https://www.theguardian.com/world/2008/apr/01/nato.georgia Five months later the Georgia war happened.
- corrral 4y agoThere's... a bit more background than that. Russian activity to fracture the country and outright threats of resolving the situation with military force, date back years before Georgia sought NATO membership, and indeed, before the '03 pro-western shift in their government. Which, gee, I wonder why they might have decided they want allies opposed to Russia.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoIf Ukraine had been in NATO, Russia wouldn't have invaded. They did because Ukraine was in the verge of joining, knowing that once it was done, they would not be able to attack anymore. Plus, NATO being historically a shield, not a sword, Russia stance was basically the equivalent of stating "to look for safety or we kick your ass".
- LAC-Tech 4y agoNATOs operations have frequently involved air campaigns against states that pose no direct threat to any of its members. Quite a bizarre shield. You can tell me the operations were justified. I'm yet to be convinced that the Russian regime should not feel threatened by them.
- ncmncm 4y agoTroops need combat experience somewhere for there to be any hope of their effectiveness. That was enough justification, from a military standpoint. Unfortunate geopolitical consequences of the conflicts are unfortunate.
- dmitrygr 4y ago> was in the verge of joining Where did you get this incorrect information? Joining NATO non-negotiably requires checking a few boxes, one of which is having all your borders settled and under no dispute. Ukraine did not fit this requirement and thus could not have been on the verge of any such thing. They had stated their desire to join, then canceled (under Yanukovych), then re-stated it, but they were never even close to being admitted.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- verve_rat 4y agoBullshit.