4 ms·
I guess you wanted "Oral" (meaning, you eat the vaccine, often as a drop of liquid on a sugar lump) not "Olfactory" (meaning you smell it) OPV is more effectiv
by tialaramex 4y ago
I guess you wanted "Oral" (meaning, you eat the vaccine, often as a drop of liquid on a sugar lump) not "Olfactory" (meaning you smell it)
OPV is more effective at preventing Polio, the disease caused by the virus. Now, if you live in a country without endemic Polio (e.g. the United Kingdom) then that's not a big deal. You were probably never going to catch Polio anyway, and the risk (to others, not yourself) from vaccine-derived Poliovirus is a big problem, so it makes sense to prioritise that by using IPV (the vaccine based on a "killed" virus) and it is policy in countries with elimination to do so.
But, if you live in a country with endemic Polio including vaccine-derived Polio, then you perhaps want OPV because of the improved effectiveness.
Now, the other reason OPV is used in lots of poor countries with endemic Polio is that it's cheaper. It's cheaper to manufacture, and it's cheaper to administer - any idiot can give children a sugar lump with a drop of liquid and tell them to eat it and I believe it's even cheaper to store/ distribute.
We expect to figure out how to make the dead vaccine more effective than it is now, though perhaps never as effective as OPV - but it likely will not be cheaper, nor easier to use.
- qwertox 4y agoOPV was standard in the US until 2000, because Polio got close to being eradicated and OPV used to cause new infections where none existed anymore. So they switched to IPV, which, even if it is not as effective as OPV, still offered some degree of protection, but did not cause new infections. Sounds like an interesting tradeoff / balance act. https://doh.wa.gov/you-and-your-family/immunization/diseases-and-vaccines-can-prevent-them/polio-0/when-should-you-get-polio-vaccination https://doh.wa.gov/you-and-your-family/immunization/diseases...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- More-nitors 4y agohow about giving dead viral vaccine, and then giving live one after 1 month or so?
- gus_massa 4y agoYour idea is very similar for the recommended schedule by the WHO for "in-between" countries that have a good vaccine coverage but still some risk. More details in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polio_vaccine#Schedule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polio_vaccine#Schedule
- hilbert42 4y agoI had the IPV (Salk) vaccine shot in the 1960s at school during the time of polio epidemics (in those days one never heard of people objecting to vaccines and everyone was terrified of polio so opposition to getting the vaccine was essentially zero). About a decade and half later when preparing to travel to countries where disease was more of a possibility than those I'd been to on previous trips, I mentioned to the Dr that I'd had the IPV years earlier. Hardly before I'd had time to utter another word she reached into her refrigerator took out a tiny bottle and said "here's the Sabin [OPV], stick out your tongue". A couple of drops later she said "all done." It was all over before I'd had a chance to raise the possibility of the OPV giving one polio (which I'd vaguely heard about) and to that she said "there's a very miniscule chance - hundreds of thousands to one and even then it rarely progresses to its worst form - however in your case it's effectively zero as your earlier Salk shot would certainly protect you from what is an already weakened virus". If one hasn't had either the IPV or OPV vaccine and there's even the slightest chance of polio being about then have the shot ASAP. If OPV is your only choice then it's far the least risky of your options. Even if you're a vaccine denier and think COVID wasn't as bad as has been made out then think again about polio - this disease is in another league altogether. (One day when I was in primary school a year or two before the IPV became available, a kid disappeared from my class, some months later after holidays we'd heard he'd died of polio. Another kid ended up being only able to walk on crutches and with calipers on his legs. At that time it was not unusual to see people hobbling about on crutchrd and calipers or to hear of survivors having to live permanently inside an iron lung as polio had paralyzed their respiratory muscles. Make no mistake, polio is a truly horrible disease.)
- gus_massa 4y ago>> there's a very miniscule chance - hundreds of thousands to one and even then it rarely progresses to its worst form As far as I know, the OPV is safe for the person that receives it. The problem is that the virus may be transmitted to another person that may transmit it to another person ... and after a few hops mutate and give the vaccine-derived version of polio.
- hilbert42 4y ago