5 ms·
Street Epistemology
- asplake 4y agoI’m very interested in the discipline of respectful enquiry but this passage rang some alarm bells: > Street Epistemology started life as a method to discuss religious belief in the 2013 book A Manual for Creating Atheists. Is it just me, or is there (or was there) an agenda here that’s in conflict with its claims about creating understanding? With apologies for the pun, were they “good faith” conversations?
- guerrilla 4y agoThey've discussed the ethics of this a few times on the live show. Some practitioners think the attitude is wrong, other's don't... but now it's spread so much that background viewpoints are pretty diverse anyway with even Christians doing it, ironically due to their evangelism. On the other hand, I think Anthony Magnabosco[1] doesn't hide it well sometimes in his interviews, which I think some of his interivewees pick up on and it harms the process. In any case, I think this is the most important kind of activism their is and nobody needs to be part of their original community to do it or do it for the same reasons. 1. https://www.youtube.com/c/AnthonyMagnabosco210 https://www.youtube.com/c/AnthonyMagnabosco210
- sasaf5 4y agoEssentially "I am rational therefore I am right". Another passage that rings a bell: > Today the method has a life of its own, driven by a community of people interested in discussing difficult topics, seeking truth and reflecting on the methods we use to arrive at our deep convictions.
- feet 4y ago>Essentially "I am rational therefore I am right". Sounds like basically the entirety of philosophy
- avs733 4y agonot really. It is a specific school of philosophical thought - and the basis of a lot of the critiques of science, positivism.
- ww_wpg 4y ago> > Essentially "I am rational therefore I am right". > Sounds like basically the entirety of philosophy That's the opposite of the experience I've observed. The starting point for a lot of philosophy students is learning the teachings of Plato and Socrates, among which the most famous is likely "I know that I know nothing"
- nescioquid 4y agoThe spirit of searching interrogation is there, along with Socrates' daemon who, Socrates said, prevented him from saying anything untrue (I'm hamming it up here). The philosophical prototype of Socrates also gives license to be a gad-fly, piss people off for a good cause, etc. Instead of offering to pay a modest fine when he was found guilty of corrupting the youth, Socrates was so certain of his rectitude he told the court he should instead be awarded free meals for life like the Olympic champions. Now there's someone with chutzpah.
- collegeburner 4y agoThere are plenty of schools of thought that start with "I am not likely rational" or "I can't know if I'm rational".
- Self-Perfection 4y agoWhat is alarming in this passage? Seems innocuous to me.
- otikik 4y agoIf you see religion as something good, or even neutral, to humanity, then of course there is (I would probably say was) a mismatch between the claims and the objectives. If you see religion as an overall bad influence - more specifically, as "the opposite of understanding", then both are (were) aligned.
- swayvil 4y agoEven if you are biased, striving for truly rigorous arguing can lead to much insight about arguing itself. Dissecting your own philosophy as well as that of your "opponent".
- robobro 4y agoPeter Boghossian was an old instructor of mine at PSU. As a B or C-tier "new atheist" who wasn't quite on tenure track, it was interesting seeing how he tried to get attention. He was pretty solid in his lectures outside of politics and religion -- he was generally well-read and was very entertaining, but seeing him trying to "trigger" people on those topics made a lot of students groan. He had a small group of students who would follow him around everywhere and he would ask the class and his clique to promote and astroturf him on Reddit, Wikipedia, et al. Which is valid... I guess it's better if his students are doing it than him? A few times on campus, he was seen coaching students who were later identified by a local antifascist group as being linked to "the Daily Stormer" -- which I have mixed feelings about; I truly believe everyone deserves to have tools for better thinking, but you're right to suspect Boghossian as possibly having agendas. In a direct response to your last question, he did get in some hot water for bad faith academic publishing that produced questionable benefits: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grievance_studies_affair https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grievance_studies_affair I'll say that people criticizing RMS doesn't make the libre software movement bad, and it doesn't invalidate his accomplishments.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoI had him as well in 2012. He was fun back then, but I think a little bit of fame has gotten to his head. I think he wants to get people to really think about their beliefs, why they have them, and if it's reasonable to have them, but his methods are indistinguishable from bad faith trolls that are "just asking questions" (aka, JAQing off). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zxvyeZa1YSI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zxvyeZa1YSI
- a9h74j 4y agoI took his book as disingenuous. "How to have difficult conversations" ... to change the minds of people who are wrong per definition.
- swayvil 4y agoI skimmed. Little meat but lots of references to meat elsewhere. Can somebody give me a nutshell of their method beyond "practice good epistemological hygiene"?
- guerrilla 4y agoThey basically just do what's on Anthony's channel[1], i.e. asking how you know something, what would change your mind, etc.. Very few are actually learning epistemology as far as I can tell from having been in their Discord for a while. 1. https://www.youtube.com/c/AnthonyMagnabosco210 https://www.youtube.com/c/AnthonyMagnabosco210
- foobar1962 4y agoI heard this conversation which used the method, and was a game-changer for me: Somebody says they like a particular sports team because the coach is their favourite. They are asked, would you still like the team if it had a different coach? They answer yes, they would. So the reason cannot be the coach. Is there another reason you like the team? Well, my family followed the team since I was a kid. The technique is NOT to argue the truthfulness of a belief, but to focus on the reason for the belief.
- tgv 4y agoIt's only a toy example, and it already has a problem: people aren't very good at explaining their motivation. There doesn't have to be any logic to it, so you basically are in no position to question any preference by appealing to logic. People are also tempted to simply reply when asked, even if they don't know the answer. And your conclusion isn't fully justified either. Suppose the true, underlying reason for liking that team is coach == "my fav coach" || center_player == "my fav player" || won_last_match and the team did in fact win the last match. Then the answer "because the coach is my favorite" is a fair answer, but changing the coach doesn't change the outcome. This technique may very well set you on a path to misunderstanding when applied rigourously.
- guerrilla 4y ago
- wussboy 4y agoI grow bored with trying to convince other people to agree with me and am much more interested in how I can change my own mind to agree with others. True bravery is saying “I will change my mind about something important today.”
- curiousllama 4y agoI got pretty good at this - it's not all it's cracked up to be. If you're really open minded & empirical, every time you talk to a specialist or hobbyist, you'd change your mind - simply because they have more data available. You're not at the mercy of the best idea, just the best argument; you're simply outsourcing your opinions. It's less "thoughtful" and more "spineless"
- wussboy 4y agoYour comment strikes at the core of the matter. Changing your mind is perceived as being spineless, or lacking in some essential moral component. It's unfortunate. Think of the millions who have died needlessly in large and small ways because humans were unable to admit the folly of their ways, even if they could clearly see it. I stand by my original comment. True bravery is being willing to change your mind about important things.
- curiousllama 4y ago> I stand by my original comment Not unexpected. After all, I did try to change your mind by saying "you should not change your mind."
- ukj 4y agoIt's useful in so far as it makes people question themselves. It's useless in so far as it doesn't teach any of the nitty grittys of epistemic rigour e.g all the tricks scientists learn to avoit the various traps of their own biases while acquiring new knowledge.
- motohagiography 4y agoIt takes a certain level of rapport or even friendship I think to do this well. To me a difference of opinion is super interesting because I like to see if it reduces to a premise that is a new way of looking at the world for me. Just last night I had an exchange where I asserted China was going to invade Taiwan near or around the US midterms, and a friend across the table said while it does seem like the best opportunity for them and the incentives are there, US air and space superiority mean it could manage full wars with both China and Russia without the need for a land war in either country. My view was predicated on the view that the US congress was too unstable and divided to muster the political will for a draft, and that a draft would be necessary to get sufficient troops to be a deterrent to a Chinese invasion, and his view was the draft isn't necessary because the real deterrent is US air power and ultimately tactical nuclear weapons. We are politically polar opposites as friends, and both views were indeed proxies for prior opinions of the US administration, but what was interesting to me was the basic difference in opinions was not actually oppositional about the facts, but rather that the thing I thought was important (mustering a draft) was not important in his understanding (air superiority). The debate wasn't over truth or falsehood, or even that partisan, but rather the respective weights we assigned to facts we accepted at face value from one another. I've become very interested in whether his air superiority premise is accurate, as it's critical to the quality of the prediction of this outcome. Codifying not so much how to argue, but how to learn from people in the context of a disagreement seems like a very useful tool.