10 ms·
Anonymous Cancels Operation Cartel as Los Zetas Track Hacktivists
- w1ntermute 15y agoSounds like Los Zetas tracing the Anonymi is just coincidentally concurrent to their decision not to release the information. The real reason why they're not releasing it is because the civilians they were intending to expose aren't actually members of Los Zetas, and would just get killed by the cartel if they were to be exposed.
- brown9-2 15y agoWouldn't anyone who actually knew much of anything about the cartel situation already know this before the original announcement?
- lizzard 15y agoAnd they probably won't bother to trace actual Anonymous folks exposing this information but may end up targeting random people who are into computers, or even heavy social media users.
- tsotha 15y agoI think you're underestimating the reach of these cartels. I doubt they have the resources to find hackers, but they do have people feeding them information from inside the Mexican and US governments. Also, the Anonymous people have made themselves a pain in the ass to governments who have the resources to find them. Even if the cartels don't have ears in the right place it's not hard for me to imagine a list of probable Anonymous members somehow making it into their hands.
- mdda 15y ago> I doubt they have the resources to find hackers Hey kid : People tell me you're the smartest computer guy in your year. My friends know where your mother lives. Please help me find some of these "hackers".
- tsotha 15y agoSure, but can they put a tap into all the fiber running through the US? That's what I mean by resources.
- ulisesroche 15y agoYou don't need to tap all the fiber running through the US to track down someone. That would take too long. Much easier to put "Wanted" posters up with "$$$" on the bottom and wait for the head to come back.
- humbledrone 15y ago> I doubt they have the resources to find hackers. The Los Zetas cartel, being the second largest cartel in Mexico, probably has revenues of well over a billion dollars per year. (It's estimated that the overall earnings of all Mexican drug smugglers is $13-40 billion.) I'm pretty sure that's enough money to hire a hacker or two.
- TheEzEzz 15y agoYou need more than money if you're buying something illegally. You also need a certain amount of sophistication to know you're getting what you want.
- humbledrone 15y agoIn this case, I'm pretty sure that money is enough. It's not like the cartel needs to know anything about hacking or how to choose good hackers. All they have to do is tie the monetary reward to the result they want (track down the Anonymous member who said this), and somebody will figure it out, through hacking or other means. As an aside, I don't know of any billion-dollar industry that doesn't have a fairly high level of sophistication. I don't see why the cartels should be any different.
- xtracto 15y agoThe sad thing is that they do not need to hire hackers. They have been kidnapping Engineering students (electronic or software) and forcing them to work for them with the "plata o plomo" approach. Moreover, it is known that cartels have connections in every government agency, such as the CISEN (Mexico's national security agency), Policía Federal Ministerial (Mexico's FBI). That's one of the reasons why a lot of "protected witnesses" or people who report crimes are murdered, because there is always someone inside these agencies.
- MichaelApproved 15y agoI applaud their desire to try and fight the cartel but its extremely dangerous and don't fault them for pulling back.
- nandemo 15y agoIndeed. I don't live in Mexico, but from what I've read the Zetas are like a rogue cartel among the Mexican drug cartels. They kidnap "civilians", kill policemen, compromise the security of the local population, etc, things that the other cartels apparently frown upon. See, for instance, the Mata Zetas (Zeta Killers). It's unlikely that Anonymous can play this game. http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/world_now/2011/09/mexico-government-denies-paramilitary-matazetas-zetas-drug-war-1.html http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/world_now/2011/09/mexico-gov... (take care if you stumble into videos, they're disgusting even if not explicit)
- dylangs1030 15y agoNot only is it extremely dangerous, but it is a campaign which would be incredibly difficult to do anonymously, and even more difficult to do with the resources available to a largely disorganized movement (read: no governing authority to direct the group's actions other than mob mentality).
- jberryman 15y agoJust look at the photo at the top of the article of policemen with automatic rifle wearing masks to protect their identities. That is some terrifying stuff.
- anamax 15y ago> Just look at the photo at the top of the article of policemen with automatic rifle wearing masks to protect their identities. FWIW, US swat police seem to do the same thing.
- Super_Jambo 15y agoIf you really want to get into it UK riot police seem to do the same thing.
- fallous 15y agoSpeaking truth to powe....what? Oh yes, well then nevermind!
- The_Sponge 15y agoThere's so many ways to analyze this and so many possible ulterior motives. It's also unfortunate that their anonymity is under threat, even if they don't release the info they are still in danger.
- redthrowaway 15y agoThis whole op was fishy from the get-go. For one, the person speaking in the original video had a mainland Spanish accent but used Mexican vocabulary. Two, no anons within Mexico spoke out in support of the op. Three, nobody was able to verify the claim that an anon was kidnapped in the first place. Four, nobody could figure out where this op was discussed or planned. It came out of the blue without any previous involvement from the main organizing channels. The whole thing is just bizarre.
- zlapper 15y agoJust to point out, many videos released by Annon in spanish are made using a well known text-to-speech voice from Loquendo, "Jorge", who has a Castilian Spanish accent.
- cpeterso 15y agoHow do we know this op was announced by the "real" Anonymous? How long until the CIA is posing as Anonymous to incite rebellion in other countries (and/or make Anonymous look bad)?
- redthrowaway 15y agoI think that's severely overestimating the power of Anonymous. The CIA has tried, tested, and true methods for inciting rebellions and coups; no need to invoke Anon. As for making Anonymous look bad... maybe. I find it hard to believe they view anon as a legitimate threat, but NATO did call out anon specifically in one of its reports on growing threats, so who knows.
- mdda 15y agoOr look at it the other way around, maybe the CIA is using really bad dudes to take out Anonymous (or at least muffle them). An ISP may successfully defend themselves against a subpoena, but I have less confidence in them holding out vs a hammer.
- hugh3 15y agoSince when is there a "real" Anonymous? Heck, I went to an anti-scientology protest one time, surely that gives me as much of a right as anybody to claim to be Anonymous.
- djmdjm 15y agoThe lulz stop when people start getting killed.
- stfu 15y agoSadly Anons are less and less about lulz these days. Too much white-knight'ing going on there.
- forensic 15y agoIt's difficult to wage an information war with gangsters. The ones who get to the top by killing and torturing are not likely to be threatened by having a few emails released. All the shit runs downhill to the relatively innocent civilians being extorted by the gangsters. If knowledge of who the crime bosses are was enough to take them down, they would not exist in the first place. Organized crime does not require secrecy to operate when the police are corrupted.
- dylangs1030 15y agoYes, and actually the police need not be corrupt. Organized crime leaders can be in the public eye and unless there is evidence against them, they cannot be penalized by the legal system.
- rdl 15y agoThe only way to fight criminals at a scale where they threaten the state is through intelligence and military techniques, not law enforcement. Find them, build up decent evidence, kill them; don't try to prosecute. The risk is turning into a star chamber or right wing paramilitary, but I would trust the professionalism and morality of an organization like the us military to resist that. Plan Colombia worked out ok, compared to Peru vs shining path, for instance.
- gyardley 15y agoDecent evidence often isn't. Remember those 'weapons of mass destruction' in Iraq? 4,482 dead American soldiers and counting. I'm not saying these gangs aren't full of horrible people, and I'm not saying all branches of the US government and military aren't perfectly good intentioned and well-meaning people, but mistakes do get made - which is why we need some judicial oversight here. We've already got one war on an abstract concept where the president can order the extrajudicial execution of a US citizen based on secret evidence. That's more than enough for me.
- sliverstorm 15y agoWell, on the other hand what are the costs of doing nothing in Mexico? What price do the Mexican people pay? This situation is a little different than the twin towers.
- rdl 15y agoI wish I could buy a letter of marque and reprisal from the us government to interact with Los Zetas.
- bitemyapp 15y agoActually, modern day privateering against criminal organizations sounds intriguing.
- epicureanideal 15y agoMaybe you can buy one from Mexico?
- AndrewMoffat 15y agoI wonder if Anonymous was tipped off about Los Zetas tracking them, and if that played into their decision. Recently there was a video of Los Zetas members chainsawing the head off of an opposing gang member...which was promoted heavily on channels Anonymous frequents. That could have effected their decision as well.
- shareme 15y agotitle is miss-leading, Mexico arm of anonymous has pulled back..however UK arm is going ahead with the Nov 5th plans
- elliottcarlson 15y agoSource please?
- dylangs1030 15y agoThe trouble with movements like Anonymous is that there is no centralized authority. Further, a group pushing for anarchy is either hypocritical if it's effective (because it will be organized) or ineffective because it's anarchical and disorganized. Anonymous is not a serious threat to large corporations. It may cost them a minor inconveniencr, but without centralized authority, the group has no real internal integrity (the question of whether or not a group claiming to work under the auspices of Anonymous is moot...because anyone can be Anonymous).
- marshray 15y agoIt also makes it rather difficult to deny it if accused.
- mojotoad 15y agoWhat does anonymity have to do with anarchy? I realize that they often go hand in hand, but that's a sad generalization.
- dylangs1030 15y agoI was just following a train of thought and making a comparison, not a real correlative relationship.
- tokenadult 15y agoThis whole affair is a good test of the adage that the pen is mightier than the sword. Is the submachine gun mightier than the modem?
- Joakal 15y agoInteresting that they would cancel when many other de-centralised organisations would be pretty resilient. In fact, losing a member to the enemy would cause an outcry and drive more to join the cause. eg Taliban, Al Qaeda, IRA, guerrillas, and more. Whoever cancelled the operation just confirmed to the adversaries that they're easy to squash and immediately put the cause at risk. Adversaries are now more confident to risk further resources if it means they can destroy the cause. They chose unwisely.
- sliverstorm 15y agoAnonymous is not a paramilitary group. I doubt their members are willing to put their life on the line for the cause. Decentralized paramilitary groups are hard to fight because you can track down & kill members without hurting the group- not because you cannot track down & kill members.
- AJ007 15y agoI would say that being involved in hacking that would result in your becoming a felon, getting extradited, and/or going to jail for over 5 years qualifies as putting your life on the line.
- sliverstorm 15y ago"Men with guns will come and arrest you because you broke esoteric law" seems very surreal and a lot less intimidating than "Men with guns will come and kill you because you pissed them off". Don't forget the part where the Zetas have set a very, very strong precedent, while the FBI haven't. I can say even for myself I would take the FBI over the Zetas any day of the week.
- epicureanideal 15y agoPerhaps they need an Armed Anonymous branch.
- BCounsell 15y agoInstead of the Government tracking down anon. Just let the Zeta's do it for them(CIA style). Anyone vindictive enough could fake being anon. Now we just have to convince the Zeta's that Al Qaeda is going to bring the heat down on them.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- drivebyacct2 15y agoIf only there was an easy way to take away much of many cartels' power that has been endorsed by a dozen current and former leaders of several countries.
- yters 15y agoSurely Anonymous, or a more skilled hacker group could do this. To hit the cartel where it hurts they must hit their money supply. Instead of publishing members, track the money and reveal where it's coming from and where it's going to. With an annual income of $1B there has got to be something sizable to be tracked.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoSorry, that was (I thought thinnly) veiled sarcasm.
- malkia 15y agoMaybe it's time to legalize drugs.
- rbanffy 15y agoI don't think the Zetas will cease hostilities just because of that. Their best chance is to flee to the US and ask for asylum. With the data. Simply releasing the data would make killing them pointless, but being pointless never stopped the Zetas before.