4 ms·
Neutral bots probe political bias on social media
- bediger4000 4y agoThe abstract says: We find no strong or consistent evidence of political bias in the news feed. But then it goes on to apparently contradict itself: The interactions of conservative accounts are skewed toward the right, whereas liberal accounts are exposed to moderate content shifting their experience toward the political center. How is "shifting their experience toward the political center" not a mild form of conservative bias? If one tribe gets a lot of reinforcement, but the other tribe gets "shifted", that's bias. This is yet another study that refutes the "Liberal Bias" article of faith. If you hold this faith, you should really re-examine it's truth.
- StanislavPetrov 4y agoThe idea of political "neutrality" is completely subjective, which is clearly lost on these researchers, especially after reading their paper. The idea that it is possible to distill political positions to a left vs right spectrum is incredibly absurd and reductionist (despite how widespread it is) - which the authors themselves admit in the paper! For example, in their methods section, they list the Washington Post as their benchmark for "center-left". There is perhaps no large publication in the United States that beats the drums of war louder than the Washington Post for every war, invasion, attack or bombing suggested by the Pentagon - but they are used by these researchers as an objective metric for being "center-left"?
- 0des 4y agoHow are the bots 'neutral'? Why do I have the feeling this is a slang term for "We have sanitized the training data to conform with 2022 values"?
- woojoo666 4y agoThe bots were given one initial account to follow (a political account that either leaned left, center, or right). After that, actions were random and performed at random intervals
- woojoo666 4y agoFor people wondering how this can be neutral, I found their method quite interesting. From what I gathered, they deploy some bot accounts that follow one initial political account, and then all interactions afterwards (liking posts, following other people) are random. From this, their main finding was that > We find no strong or consistent evidence of political bias in the news feed But while this study focuses on algorithmic bias, I thought one of the main accusations about platform bias was that twitter banned/suspended more conservative accounts than liberal ones. Also something I found interesting: > Conservative accounts also find themselves in denser communities and are exposed to more low-credibility content With the definitions of "low credibility" based on previous research papers: > A low-credibility source is one that exhibits extreme bias, propaganda, conspiratorial content, or fabricated news. We use a list of low-credibility sources compiled from several recent research papers. Specifically, we consider a source as low-credibility if it fulfills any one of the following criteria: (1) labeled as low-credibility by Shao et al.33; (2) labeled as “Black,” “Red,” or “Satire” by Grinberg et al.49; (3) labeled as “fake news” or “hyperpartisan” by Pennycook et al.62; or (4) labeled as “extreme Left,” “extreme Right,” or “fake news” by Bovet et al.63. This provides us with a list of 570 sources.