Though I suppose it is possible for a universe that has existed forever to have yielded a God that has also existed forever! Strange things are possible when we

Though I suppose it is possible for a universe that has existed forever to have yielded a God that has also existed forever! Strange things are possible when we allow for infinite timelines! That's why it makes more sense that the universe had a definite beginning and asking about time before that beginning is undefined - time simply doesn't exist before the beginning. Roger Penrose has some interesting ideas on what happened before the Big Bang (the universe "forgets" how to "tell" time and so time doesn't exist between different "epochs" of the universe): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7o0gAglNdZw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7o0gAglNdZw