3 ms·
Reading that is a sad reminder of why people make such poor decisions. He’s still arguing about things in the abstract without a basis in the underlying mechan
by Retric 4y ago
Reading that is a sad reminder of why people make such poor decisions. He’s still arguing about things in the abstract without a basis in the underlying mechanics of these systems. And the sad thing is he’s effective at convincing people.
- breytex 4y agoCan you elaborate on where the author is wrong?
- Retric 4y ago“Trillionsof dollars were spent on wind and solar projects over the last 20 years, yet the world’s dependence on fossil fuels declined only 3 percentage points, from 87% to 84%.” Core issue is he’s at best justifying his points with sloppy thinking, we didn’t just transition to solar for fun we got actual energy from those investments. The world also spent around 100 trillion on just oil over 20 years excluding natural gas and coal yet tomorrow we are going to still need to spend more. So, on that basis it looks like a great investment and huge progress. Except look at where exactly that 87% number is from, it includes fuel oil to heat homes while excluding passive solar gain. So it’s a number that does represent something just not “dependence on fossil fuels.” After all the primary use of energy by humanity is either plants converting sunlight to chemical energy or even more holistically the energy needed to keep the earth from freezing. In the end he picked those numbers because saying saying humanity’s dependence on fossil fuels dropped from something like 0.00087% to 0.00084% just doesn’t have the same impact.
- fundad 4y agoSounds like anybody who goes to work for the fossil fuel industry. "Trillions spent on solar and wind" but apparently what we spent annually on Fossil Fuels is not significant enough to mention and Nuclear power can't cost too much because government money pays to build the plants.
- Retric 4y agoExactly, he’s not comparing costs vs gain just tossing around various numbers.