5 ms·
Open source without the option for an alternate development organisation to drive or steer development direction means vey little. Costs matter, and Web develo
by dredmorbius 4y ago
Open source without the option for an alternate development organisation to drive or steer development direction means vey little.
Costs matter, and Web development costs are high. Google benefits from coordination, funding, and one migh presume, cost advantages, which would be exceedingly difficult for any comparable US or EU effort to match.
Development in lower-cost-of-living regions, perhaps most viably China, might pose an alternative.
- paol 4y agoExactly. Even further, without market share it means very little. You could fork and fund a parallel browser, but if it has no market share then it has no influence on the web. That's where Firefox is right now, unfortunately.
- esclerofilo 4y agoMaybe if Mozilla had just forked Chromium in ~2015, its market share wouldn't have gotten as low as it is right now. I've told some people to switch to Firefox. A lot of them switch back to Chrome after a while, simply because it's faster.
- fauigerzigerk 4y ago>Open source without the option for an alternate development organisation to drive or steer development direction means vey little. Open source is that option. The economics of starting from scratch vs starting from Chromium's latest commit are fundamentally different. I'm not saying that it's easy, only that it is not remotely comparable to the IE situation.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThe problem is that Google controls both the overwhelmingly dominant browser and the standard. MSIE was bypassed not by a code fork of MSIE (itself originally based on the Spyglass browser, which was a fork of the NSCA's Mosaic codebase), but by independent implementations of an HTML-standard parser. Microsoft had some influence over Web development (noteably through ActiveX) but far less than Google has now. My point is that Open Source of itself is not sufficient, and moreover simply is not viable. Glibly asserting that it is ... is utterly unrealistic. Though the alternative of forking a Web-like markup and transport, as Gemini is attempting to do, is one option. For other technologies which have become sufficiently baroque, similar worse-is-better alternate paths have been pursued. Otherwise, this is an antitrust issue, and Google very badly need busting.
- fauigerzigerk 4y ago>My point is that Open Source of itself is not sufficient And I didn't claim that it was. My point was merely that Chromium being open source changes the equation pretty fundamentally compared to the IE situation. Whether it's enough to make a Chromium monopoly consistent with an open web, I really don't know. There are very good reasons to be sceptical.
- skinnymuch 4y agoYour comments appear to be saying that Chromium being open source makes the equation better. Like the comments defending this point about Brave and other wrapper browsers. So you’re not claiming open source is sufficient but you are seemingly defending it is a better situation. While I and some other commenters are signaling we don’t think the situation is better. To me the fundamental part of the equation is outsized power and influence. Being open source or not is part of the equation, but not as close to as fundamental as the core issues with this. This is made much much worse now than 20 years ago with the costs to get your own browser going so much higher. Which leads back to the outsized power being the fundamental issue. Open source can even be argued to be a benefit to Google retaining power. Having enough attention diverted to the possibilities of open source when Google has only monumentally gained from open source with paltry benefits that are usually brought up as defenses against its power. Like AOSP mattering because China doesn’t use Google’s Android and some other irrelevant projects. Any fundamental differences so far are giving Google and any other major central powers more power.
- fauigerzigerk 4y ago>Your comments appear to be saying that Chromium being open source makes the equation better. Like the comments defending this point about Brave and other wrapper browsers. So you’re not claiming open source is sufficient but you are seemingly defending it is a better situation. Yes, that's exactly right. I think Chromium being open source changes the equation for the better compared to the IE situation. Whether it is sufficiently better to make it work, I'm not sure. I do see Google's outsized influence as a significant problem. I'm not denying that at all. The fact that browsers like Brave have made changes that go against Google's interests is cause for some optimism though.
- dblohm7 4y ago> The economics of starting from scratch vs starting from Chromium's latest commit are fundamentally different. I don’t think they are. That fork then immediately finds itself in the same position as other engines, where now the fork is going to need to keep up with whatever Google is adding to Chromium. You might then think, “Then the fork can just pull from upstream.” Okay, so then: a) Your fork probably isn’t differentiated enough to matter; and more importantly b) Google is still effectively calling all the shots!
- fauigerzigerk 4y agoThe fact that both Brave and Vivaldi were able to disable Google's FlOC within a very short period of time is evidence against both (a) and (b) in my view. Even more so the fact that Brave was able to build an alternative ad network on top of Chromium.
- dblohm7 4y agoBrave and Vivaldi fall into the “don’t matter” category. Call me when a Chromium fork displaces Chromium.
- fauigerzigerk 4y agoIf your argument is based purely on market share then it's basically a tautology.
- dblohm7 4y agoHow can market share not be part of the discussion concerning who controls the web? You wrote: > The fact that both Brave and Vivaldi were able to disable Google's FlOC within a very short period of time Okay, they disabled some stuff. That isn’t a fundamental divergence from the upstream project. The original argument was that Google wouldn’t control the web in a Chromium monoculture because anybody can just fork it. I disagree. My argument has two prongs: 1. A Chromium fork can only sever itself from Google’s control if it is not taking patches from upstream (ie, Google). I’m particularly thinking about the most consequential pieces: web APIs, not Google ad tech. That’s going to require an army of developers who now are immediately thrust onto the web API treadmill. 2. If a Chromium fork’s market share is tiny, how is it going to displace Google’s influence on the direction of the web? It isn’t. Everybody will still be coding against Google’s Chromium.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoYou are ignoring the fact that Google can start making changes to make it incompatible on a scale that a small team of open source maintainers couldn't hope to keep up with.
- megaman821 4y agoWhy don't these criticisms apply to Linux? The relationship between Linux Core and the Flavors of Linux seems to work well. Edge, Brave, Opera and more are all using the Chromium engine. If Google went off the deep-end, they would easily have enough resources to maintain a fork.
- ciphol 4y agoIf one Linux distribution had 90% of Linux users, that might be a good comparison.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoFor what it’s worth, there are those of us who don’t think it’s great for GNU/Linux to be overwhelmingly dominant in the FOSS operating system sphere. It’s a wonderful project that we’re fortunate to have, but monocultures are rarely healthy.
- dredmorbius 4y agoI'd be among that number.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThey do. Linux itself is at least not a proprietary and commercial entity, though quite arguably its development has largely been captured by a set of proprietary and commercial entities. There's enough multilaterality in that group that fixed loci of control don't seem overwhelmingly apparent, but I'd definitely watch for those. I've been concerned over numerous elements of Linux development (including viewpoints expressed by senior developers) for a decade or so. I think you'll find some level of concern expressed by others, including some very senior former Linux devs. (I'm not positive A.C. has said as much, though that's a vibe I get.)