3 ms·
Any X-only diet doesn't seem healthy to me. There is no magical ingredient and we are omnivorous. Sure you can reduce weight with many types of different diets
by prmoustache 4y ago
Any X-only diet doesn't seem healthy to me. There is no magical ingredient and we are omnivorous. Sure you can reduce weight with many types of different diets but it doesn't mean it is good for your health.
It is better to develop good healthy habits than you can maintain for years and also while socializing and living in family.
- jmnicolas 4y agoTelling an obese person to develop good healthy habits is like telling an alcoholic to drink with moderation. The theory is sound but it get crushed once it gets IRL.
- ravenstine 4y agoWe are not omnivores. Humans are obligate hypercarnivores that are capable of scavenging other energy sources for survival. Plenty of animals, both herbivores and carnivores, are capable of eating foods that they were not developed to eat, but that does not mean it's optimal or good for them. Humans only became "omnivores" in the last 30,000 years as a result of agriculture. For several million years prior to that, hominins ate diets almost entirely of meat from ruminants and occasionally some roots and tubers. If we were designed to eat everything in a "balanced" proportion, as is often suggested, we would have a cecum to properly ferment plant material, and our digestive systems would be more basic than acidic.
- cheese_goddess 4y agoWe have a cecum. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cecum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cecum And we can digest plants just fine without having to ferment them. All those fantastical ideas about how the human body works, they keep cropping up in this kind of thread again and again. Where do they come from, I wonder? I am really curious. Who comes up with those things? The other day some guy was saying we can't digest plants. Like, at all. A vegetarian once told me that our teeth and stomach can't deal with meat. Have those people never eaten the things they say we can't eat? There's clearly a kind of madness in all those diets that starts to become dangerous when it becomes a fad. But I'm still curious: how do they start?
- ravenstine 4y agoYes, we have a cecum by name, as do other hypercarnivores including cats, but its design in no way suggests that humans developed to primarily eat plants or even digest them in an efficient way. Even the article you cited states explicitly that the function of the human cecum is different than that of herbavores, and it's dubious whether it should even be referred to as a cecum. If you look at the digestive tract of herbavores, such as cows, deer, horses, and rabbits, their cecum is a distinctly large and is typically considered a separate digestive organ. Besides absorbing salts, the human "cecum" is a glorified dead end to the large intestine. A human could easily live without one if it were removed. It would have nearly no impact on our ability to swallow cellulose and excrete it undigested. Removing the cecum from an herbavore like a horse would be an entirely different story because they need it to process cellulose. > And we can digest plants just fine without having to ferment them. This is not correct. Humans are entirely ill-adapted to digesting plant material. You will find no credible source that suggests that our digestive tracts are good at digesting cellulose, which makes up the bulk of plant material because it composes their cell walls. Just because we can swallow plants and poop them out without necessarily getting sick or dying doesn't mean it's at all optimal. At best, we can ferment a small amount of cellulose given that it has been sufficiently broken down through cooking. Even if we were better at fermenting it, we are extremely poor at grinding it and are bad at harboring microbiota that produce cellulase enzyme. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8661373/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8661373/ Can we derive energy from plants? Of course. If those plants are abundant in sugars and proteins, then we can access those. That is possible in present day because agriculture and selective breeding made edible and energy dense plants available and ubiquitous. Such plants did not exist the way they do today, were usually scarce, only available seasonally, and were energy-expensive to obtain and prepare. > There's clearly a kind of madness in all those diets that starts to become dangerous when it becomes a fad. Depends on if those diets are actually dangerous. What's more dangerous than believing that humans are developed to primarily eat meat is to ignore all available scientific evidence and promote fanciful ideas around plants being good or even better for humans. I await the day that a child dies from being fed plenty of meat. Meanwhile... https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/vegan-couple-murder-baby-starve-ryan-patrick-o-leary-sheila-florida-a9255046.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/vegan-coup... https://www.vice.com/en/article/wjqbem/judge-convicts-parents-after-baby-dies-from-vegan-diet https://www.vice.com/en/article/wjqbem/judge-convicts-parent... It's as if the human body is optimized to process animal material and is not so good at processing plants.