2 ms·
The weakest link in applied math is often the step of turning a physical problem into a mathematical problem. This is even difficult to do when what you're try
by scott_s 15y ago
The weakest link in applied math is often the step of turning a physical problem into a mathematical problem.
This is even difficult to do when what you're trying to model is not the physical world, but a computer system. (A computer system can count as the "physical world" depending on your view, but I don't think that's what the author meant.) That's what we're doing right now, and me (a systems guy) and a bunch of several applied math / theoretical CS people are having a hell of a time with it. Well, fun in its own way, but, yes, getting a model that makes assumptions that gel with reality is the first order concern, always.
- jpitz 15y agoHonestly, computer systems should be approached and treated as though they have the complexity of the physical world. They're composed of a bunch of different parts, some moving, some distant, all accumulating all sorts of interesting bottlenecks and errors at the edges. The starting assumption that a given computer system is simple and ought to yield easily to analysis and modeling is a red flag in many situations.
- scott_s 15y agoI agree, actually, which is why I made that aside.
- mjb 15y ago> This is even difficult to do when what you're trying to model is not the physical world, but a computer system. Indeed. A couple of days ago, somebody posted a fascinating image of memory latency (http://www.bitmover.com/mem_lat.jpg http://www.bitmover.com/mem_lat.jpg) in a comment here. Getting to a model of a computer system which captured all the subtleties in this graph isn't easy - and this is only one aspect of real computer behavior. Abstractions and approximations are extremely important in science, computer science included, but I am often disappointed by how little thought is given to the implications of these approximations. In comparison, getting excited about floating point error is much easier. This is not a criticism of Sussman or his talk in any way, but just an observation on many computer engineering and computation papers.