3 ms·
Canada has "free" universal healthcare, but to call it a "solved problem" seems pretty naive.
by refurb 4y ago
Canada has "free" universal healthcare, but to call it a "solved problem" seems pretty naive.
- bruce511 4y agoIt's a solved problem in the sense that it exists, and works[1] and it is available in a lot more places than Canada. [1] "works" is an interesting point because it isn't clearly defined, and usually means different things to different people. Ever experience of the system is "unique" - there is this mix of human patient with human provider with finite resources with medical knowledge with time. So there are plenty of examples of long waits, bad service, unfavorable outcomes, even death. It's not hard to cherry pick bad experiences here. No health system will make everyone live forever. Death comes to us all sooner or late. But universal healthcare works in many places in raising the overall standard of public health, without bankrupting people in the process. Given that its always spending limited money, and only scales at human rates, its far from perfect. But, at least for some, its better than a "health care level based on your wealth" system.
- refurb 4y agoBut the US isn't "healthcare based on your wealth". You have Medicaid for the poor, heavily subsidized Obamacare for the people who don't get it through their employer (hello $100/month plan!) and Medicare for the retired. I mean my cousin in the US whose kid has cystic fibrosis get better care through Medicaid than our other cousin in Canada who can't even get access to the latest drugs.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y ago> heavily subsidized Obamacare for the people who don't get it through their employer (hello $100/month plan!) That $100/month plan will include high deductibles and copays. A weekend visit to an urgent care for a kidney stone will still cost a couple hundred dollars out of pocket.
- wyre 4y agoI don't think anyone that says this has actually been poor and needed medical care.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoYou just have to stay very poor. If you do anything to move up a little bit in life, the benefits stop and you are on your own. https://www.verywellhealth.com/your-assets-magi-and-medicaid-eligibility-4144975 https://www.verywellhealth.com/your-assets-magi-and-medicaid...
- suture 4y agoThe naivety is in thinking that if it doesn’t work in Canada then it must not be a solved problem. The naivety is in thinking that if you can find anecdotal evidence that in a particular instance Canada’s system worked worse than the U.S. system then it must be the case that Canada’s system is worse. The U.S. per capita spends far more on healthcare than any other OECD country. We don’t get correspondingly better outcomes or coverage. Universal healthcare is a solved problem within the context that every system necessarily involves some sort of rationing since there aren’t enough medical resources in any country to do otherwise. If you don’t want to use the phrase “solved system” then don’t but don’t pretend the U.S. is any way better other than in anecdotal instances. Below is a source for information on per capita spending for OECD nations. You can easily find information on health our outcomes, life expectancy, teen pregnancies, infant mortality, etc. https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/876d99c3-en/index.html?itemId=/content/component/876d99c3-en https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/876d99c3-en/index.html?i...
- refurb 4y agoSir, this is a Wendy’s. I’m not sure how your reply has anything to do with what I said. “Better than the US” is not some hurdle that makes a problem “solved”. Canada is likely better at snow removal but that doesn’t make it a “solved problem”.
- suture 4y agoIt’s a solved problem as far as one can get given the constraints involved. As I said, if you don’t want to use that phrase then don’t. I’m not going to quibble over semantics. Human societies are far more complex than programming and the notion of “solved” means something different in the former than in the latter. Use whatever phrase you want. Just don’t think the U.S. system is in any way better. You are the one who brought up an anecdotal experience in favor of the U.S. system over Canada’s system.
- refurb 4y agoYou keep talking about the US, but as a former resident of Canada I know that’s the country’s favorite measuring stick. “We’re not as bad as the US so stop complaining” is the favorite ring of politicians. Doesn’t do much for the people disabled from pain on a 3 year wait list for a hip transplant or my buddy’s cousin’s kid who doesn’t get access to the standard of care of CF. It’s not solved in the least, every country struggles, so using the word “solved” is, as I said, naive.