4 ms·
> IMO, the Pacific coast states need to reject national health care, create a health-care pact between states that slowly grows larger by adding new states. If
by rayiner 4y ago
> IMO, the Pacific coast states need to reject national health care, create a health-care pact between states that slowly grows larger by adding new states. If another state doesn't want to join, then, so be it.
It blows my mind that they don’t do this. During most of the 20th century, Democrat-run states wanted to tax Republican California to pay for social programs. So doing things at the national level was critical. But now that the states that have all the money are also run by Democrats, that roadblock is gone. California can just tax California to pay for universal healthcare for California. They have no reason to care what Iowa chooses to do.
- tptacek 4y agoHow do you avoid the obvious adverse selection problem? California can't prevent the most expensive people in the country from moving there, and the system we're talking about would be a powerful incentive for those people to do so.
- bhupy 4y agoI think you're overstating just how "obvious" this adverse selection problem is, because we haven't seen this play out historically. It sounds like a purely theoretical problem. Canada established its single payer system provincially, one-by-one, and they didn't have this adverse selection problem. Saskatchewan was the first Province to offer single payer in 1947, followed by Alberta in 1951, etc. By 1961, all Provinces had some form of a single payer healthcare system. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3110239/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3110239/ > Taxpayer-funded medicare in Canada did not appear at a single point in time: it emerged over a quarter century from 1962, when physician services were covered across Saskatchewan, to 1987, when the demise of optional “full billing” in Ontario began. So at any given point in time between 1962 and 1987, there was (in theory) this adverse selection problem among certain provinces; and yet that was never really a major problem in Canada. Even to this day, the Canada Health Transfer which provides block funding to Provinces by the Federal government for the purpose of funding these single payer systems covers ~22% of the cost (https://www.cmaj.ca/content/192/45/E1408 https://www.cmaj.ca/content/192/45/E1408). Additionally, even in present day, the European Union has open borders and free immigration between member states, and certain member states have far more generous welfare systems than others, and you still don't have this adverse selection problem, at least in a manner that meaningfully renders those welfare systems unsustainable. Even domestically, we didn't really see dramatic net migration from states that refused to take the Medicaid expansion to those that did. The reality is that people don't choose where to live strictly on the basis of which state provides taxpayer funded healthcare. In fact, those that are most likely to do that (poor people) are likely already covered by Medicaid or heavily subsidized ACA plans (https://www.kff.org/policy-watch/millions-of-uninsured-americans-are-eligible-for-free-aca-health-insurance/ https://www.kff.org/policy-watch/millions-of-uninsured-ameri...). And even if one were to engage with the purely theoretical problem, there are ways to mitigate the adverse selection, e.g. by requiring a minimum number of years of residency in order to qualify. This is what US States do today to establish residency for the purpose of in-state university tuition. Given the plethora of historical (and current) data points that suggests that this isn't really a problem, States can choose to cross that bridge if/when they get there.
- tptacek 4y agoMaybe! These are all good points (well, the Canada example, at least). I guess it's down to "running a single-payer system for California would be very expensive, and you might need to make it mandatory in order to deal with the more pressing adverse selection problem" --- I don't know how much of a canard adverse selection is within the context of mandatory single payer, but it comes up.
- xyzzyz 4y ago
- lotsofpulp 4y agoEducation costs are peanuts compared to healthcare costs. Not to mention that educating children provides a significant economic return to the state in the form of labor when the children grow up. Whereas dialysis and heart surgeries and hip replacements for 70+ year olds is a complete loss. For examples, a single NICU baby or hemophiliac can easily cost $1M+ per year. Health insurers almost had to stop selling policies in Iowa due to a single hemophiliac who needed $1M/month medications: https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/health/2017/05/31/hemophilia-patient-costing-iowa-insurer-1-million-per-month/356179001/ https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/health/2017/05/... There is a reason why universal healthcare is such a political football. It is the single most expensive thing the country spends its resources on, and it is not even universal yet. Hence all the tribes fighting over access to public resources for it, and solutions implemented to ration resources along those tribal lines, via the use of managed care organizations (health insurance companies) and hugely varying reimbursement rules for different programs like Medicare (old), Medicaid (poor), Tricare (military), commercial plans, etc. All the premium increases people complained about due to ACA are a fraction of the tax increases that would have had to happen for universal healthcare. The other option is pharmaceutical companies, hospitals, and doctors take a huge pay cut.
- xyzzyz 4y ago> All the premium increases people complained about due to ACA are a fraction of the tax increases that would have had to happen for universal healthcare. So why would I ever want universal healthcare? I was being sold on it being cheaper and more efficient, but now you’re saying that it will also cost more. What’s the point, then?
- tptacek 4y agoThere's robust disagreement among reasonable people about whether single-payer health care is a good idea in the US or not. The comment you were responding to wasn't overtly advocating for it. There's less reasonable support for acalculiac xenophobia.
- fragmede 4y agoThat's a good idea! Unfortunately, California is subject to the same business interests that the Federal government is also beholden to, so attempts to do so have a hard time getting traction for the exactly the same reason. https://www.npr.org/2022/01/31/1077155345/california-universal-health-care-bill-dies-without-a-vote https://www.npr.org/2022/01/31/1077155345/california-univers...
- lotsofpulp 4y agoVermont did try it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vermont_health_care_reform https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vermont_health_care_reform It does not work for the reasons tptacek wrote. With freedom of movement, eventually net benefit recipients will move in, and net payers into the system will move out.
- xyzzyz 4y agoAdverse selection is not at all why Vermont rolled back their decision.
- ciphol 4y agoVermont (a tiny state) would suffer much more from that than would California.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIf I was a politician in any other state, I would propose exporting high cost patients to California by buying or subsidizing their housing. It is always the same story with any broad high cost universal benefit offered within a taxing jurisdiction that does not have immigration control. Homelessness (land costs), mental healthcare (legal and labor costs), and healthcare. Even subsidized higher education is not universal, it is restricted to residents. That is why we do not see these offered anywhere, and why it has to be a federal move.
- rayiner 4y agoI don’t see evidence of that. Vermont grew slower than the country as a whole over the last decade, so it’s not like there was an influx of new residents. It sounds like people in Vermont just wouldn’t put their money where their mouth is and pay the taxes required for universal healthcare. Our German au pair paid almost 40% on her entry level office job. If you want universal healthcare like the Europeans well that’s what it costs.