2 ms·
> A critique of MIDI is that is is optimized for keyboard instrument input with the result that the sort of music you are funneled to make with MIDI is the sort
by WalterBright 4y ago
> A critique of MIDI is that is is optimized for keyboard instrument input with the result that the sort of music you are funneled to make with MIDI is the sort than can be rendered by keyboard.
Isn't that true of any instrument? They're all limited by the nature of their interface to the musician.
- nescioquid 4y agoExcellent point! In the context of early electronic music (thinking of Varèse), there was a sort of resentment for the fact a composer was limited to working with the sort of sounds that can be "drawn from horse hair and catgut" or by an octave divided in twelve or any instrument other than the composer's imagination. That's how I understood the criticism (which was also voiced in an academic context).