4 ms·

I don't get what your point about the quote is. What is contradictory about the article and the claim?

kragen 4y ago
If Coradir did "develop a battery bank platform, motor train and all the associated electronics" then why are they reselling a Chinese design? Are the Chinese manufacturers using the Coradir-developed battery bank platform, motor train, and electronics?
- mynameisvlad 4y ago
  Has anyone actually verified it's the same car? They only mildly resemble eachother IMO. That said, Coradir's site seems to be a lot of rebranded gadgets so it wouldn't surprise me, but I haven't seen any actual proof of this, just speculation based on cars looking similar.
  - j_mo 4y ago
    https://ar.motor1.com/news/480616/tito-probo-en-potrero-de-los-funes-nuevas-fotos-y-datos-del-auto-electrico-de-san-luis/ https://ar.motor1.com/news/480616/tito-probo-en-potrero-de-l... > The only official image published by Coradir Automotores shows the Tito with the original Today Sunshine M1 grille Looks like they're importing them but with their own styling changes, and originally posted an unmodified Sunshine M1 on their website.
    - kragen 4y ago
      This is absolutely standard business practice here, as I explained in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31829966 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31829966.
adolfojp 4y ago
The headline claims that the Tito is a 100% Argentine car. The article states that they failed to develop their own car platform so they decided to sell the car that they already had. The car that they already had appears to be a Chinese car that you can buy online. Thus, the claim that the TITO is a 100% Argentine car appears to be a lie.
- mynameisvlad 4y ago
  1-2 are facts, sure. What proof is there that the TITO actually is a Chinese car? Your statements hinge on that assumption.
  - adolfojp 4y ago
    My eyes can tell they're the same. If you look at the cars without bias you'll agree. https://argentinareports.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/60ddd9c9c92fd_950_534.jpeg https://argentinareports.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/60dd... https://argentinareports.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/titocolores-1024x683.jpeg https://argentinareports.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/tito... https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/MINI-Smart-Electric-Car-Made-In_1600061825692.html?spm=a2700.details.0.0.384d53a5IQ419j https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/MINI-Smart-Electric-C... The cars are exactly alike in size, shape, proportion, body, etc., except for some minor cosmetic changes in the front grill.
    - mynameisvlad 4y ago
      What "bias"? I'm not Argentinian, I couldn't care less if they made it or not. There's clear differences even in the photos you provided. Obviously the front grill, but the lights are also a different shape, with the TITO more angular. The door frame is different, it looks like the TITO has a larger piece of chrome on the part you open. I'm sure there's other differences there if I were to look at different angles of the TITO. Maybe Sunshine took TITO's design, maybe they're both based on some reference design made by some other company. They both clearly are supposed to be a squished MINI Cooper. Regardless of what happened, "my eyes" are not proof of it. So, I ask again, what proof do you have that it is the case that TITO took Sunshine's design and/or is just a rebadged car?
      - xyzzy123 4y ago
        Check out https://www.chinacarforums.com/threads/mini-evs-in-china.21897/page-32 https://www.chinacarforums.com/threads/mini-evs-in-china.218... "Design and bodywork: The design was taken from an existing Chinese product. The vehicle parts would be imported from China and the assembly would be done in San Luis. For later, they promise to produce the body parts in kevlar and aluminum material, with the support of a Munro (Buenos Aires) autopartist"

If Coradir did "develop a battery bank platform, motor train and all the associated electronics" then why are they reselling a Chinese design? Are the Chinese manufacturers using the Coradir-developed battery bank platform, motor train, and electronics?

mynameisvlad 4y ago
Has anyone actually verified it's the same car? They only mildly resemble eachother IMO. That said, Coradir's site seems to be a lot of rebranded gadgets so it wouldn't surprise me, but I haven't seen any actual proof of this, just speculation based on cars looking similar.
- j_mo 4y ago
  https://ar.motor1.com/news/480616/tito-probo-en-potrero-de-los-funes-nuevas-fotos-y-datos-del-auto-electrico-de-san-luis/ https://ar.motor1.com/news/480616/tito-probo-en-potrero-de-l... > The only official image published by Coradir Automotores shows the Tito with the original Today Sunshine M1 grille Looks like they're importing them but with their own styling changes, and originally posted an unmodified Sunshine M1 on their website.
  - kragen 4y ago
    This is absolutely standard business practice here, as I explained in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31829966 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31829966.

adolfojp 4y ago

The headline claims that the Tito is a 100% Argentine car. The article states that they failed to develop their own car platform so they decided to sell the car that they already had. The car that they already had appears to be a Chinese car that you can buy online. Thus, the claim that the TITO is a 100% Argentine car appears to be a lie.

mynameisvlad 4y ago
1-2 are facts, sure. What proof is there that the TITO actually is a Chinese car? Your statements hinge on that assumption.
- adolfojp 4y ago
  My eyes can tell they're the same. If you look at the cars without bias you'll agree. https://argentinareports.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/60ddd9c9c92fd_950_534.jpeg https://argentinareports.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/60dd... https://argentinareports.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/titocolores-1024x683.jpeg https://argentinareports.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/tito... https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/MINI-Smart-Electric-Car-Made-In_1600061825692.html?spm=a2700.details.0.0.384d53a5IQ419j https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/MINI-Smart-Electric-C... The cars are exactly alike in size, shape, proportion, body, etc., except for some minor cosmetic changes in the front grill.
  - mynameisvlad 4y ago
    What "bias"? I'm not Argentinian, I couldn't care less if they made it or not. There's clear differences even in the photos you provided. Obviously the front grill, but the lights are also a different shape, with the TITO more angular. The door frame is different, it looks like the TITO has a larger piece of chrome on the part you open. I'm sure there's other differences there if I were to look at different angles of the TITO. Maybe Sunshine took TITO's design, maybe they're both based on some reference design made by some other company. They both clearly are supposed to be a squished MINI Cooper. Regardless of what happened, "my eyes" are not proof of it. So, I ask again, what proof do you have that it is the case that TITO took Sunshine's design and/or is just a rebadged car?
    - xyzzy123 4y ago
      Check out https://www.chinacarforums.com/threads/mini-evs-in-china.21897/page-32 https://www.chinacarforums.com/threads/mini-evs-in-china.218... "Design and bodywork: The design was taken from an existing Chinese product. The vehicle parts would be imported from China and the assembly would be done in San Luis. For later, they promise to produce the body parts in kevlar and aluminum material, with the support of a Munro (Buenos Aires) autopartist"