12 ms·
For natural theologians, proving God was beside the point
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bob6745 4y ago
- ulfw 4y agoThis kind of thing really doesn't belong on Hackernews.
- JasonFruit 4y agoWell, of course we focus on natural theologians' arguments for the existence of God, because God's existence is logically prior to any other arguments you could have about Him. It doesn't matter what God as revealed in nature can teach us about predestination if God doesn't exist to predestine anyone.
- riku_iki 4y ago> exist He may existed, or will appear under certain circumstances. Or he may have quantum nature: doesn't exist, but manifests himself.
- whatshisface 4y agoThat's not how nonexistence works...
- Xeoncross 4y agoI'm not sure about all religions, but a Christian's belief that nature proves God's existence is taught in the bible: "Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shewed it unto them. For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse" - Romans 1:19 & 1:20
- CodeBeater 4y agoKind of off-topic but, why does the angloworld keep using a translation of the bible that's written in an almost "archaic" English (yes I know, I'm exaggerating, but I can't think of a better description from the top of my head). Coming from someone that was born and raised in a Portuguese speaking country, their version of the bible seems much more "accessible", But I acknowledge the fact that it might come at the cost of the accuracy of the translation.
- yellowapple 4y agoFor me, it's the concern that newer translations are very likely derived from older translations; even when they attempt to translate the original Hebrew/Greek, they'll tend to be colored by other translations, be they other English translations or the Latin and German translations preceding the first English translations. That being said, I usually go with Young's Literal Translation due to its explicit focus on, well, being a literal translation of the original Textus Receptus and Masoretic Text; whereas even KJV does its share of editorializing, YLT actively avoids it. Unfortunately, the consequence of such a literal translation is that it makes even KJV look modern and comprehensible by comparison ;)
- _gabe_ 4y agoI think some people may do it out of a misguided perception that an older translation is more accurate. I used to read the NKJV out of this misperception, but I tend to stick with ESV these days. It's much more readable (imo), and if the resources I've researched over the years are accurate, it's a better translation than the King James or New King James versions.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Kind of off-topic but, why does the angloworld keep using a translation of the bible that's written in an almost "archaic" English Not almost, it was deliberately archaic when written. But also...the “angloworld” as a whole doesn't.
- barrysteve 4y agoKJV is conservative methodists and baptists and high church anglicans. There's also plenty of ESV and NIV kicking anout. Native english speakers often agree the KJV is beautiful in writing and speech.
- drewcoo 4y ago> such as the ‘New Atheists’ – to assert that the disproofs of God None of the atheists I know try to disprove all gods because they're generally collections of unfalsifiable claims. Specific gods as claimed to exist by specific groups, yes, but generally no. > [to assert that] the secular science that they claim to be doing are value-neutral, apolitical and objective How strange that science can't be neutral because someone's introduced a god. It couldn't be that person's god making the science non-neutral and political now, could it? I dare say (tongue in cheek) that the proof of that is obvious through mere observation.
- keane 4y ago> None of the atheists I know… Anecdotal and unfamiliar with the literature. >How strange that science can’t be neutral because someone… That’s not what the article implies in the slightest. Nor is it why science is unable to be objective.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- shakna 4y ago> None of the atheists I know try to disprove all gods because they're generally collections of unfalsifiable claims. Specific gods as claimed to exist by specific groups, yes, but generally no. "New Atheism" as a term, _requires_ it. It isn't simply atheism, but rather a form that advocates for an intolerance of all religion. Whilst it doesn't require that you advocate for particular disproof against individual gods, as it may make use of all-encompassing arguments, it does requires that the concept of gods being disproved.
- galaxyLogic 4y agoTwo things to ask anybody who claims to have some information, or even just some personal beliefs, about something they call "God" : 1. What are the statements about what you call "God" that you believe in? 2. Why do you believe just that set of statements and not some other set of statements? I believe that the answer to 2., if they are honest, would most often be: They believe the set of statements they believe because they WANT to believe just those statements. And why do they want to believe just such a set of statements? Because believing what they believe makes them feel good. They want to believe those statements, and here's the minor miracle: Just because they want to believe those statements, they also all of a sudden do believe them. At least they claim they do.
- eigenheart 4y agoMany, many people who've had near death experiences, e.g. Howard Storm, Dean Braxton, Randy Kay, Bryan Melvin, etc... do not believe simply because they want to believe: their entire operating system (heart, mind, soul) has been updated with the ineffable and there's no going back.
- galaxyLogic 4y agoNo doubt. My question is simply what exactly do they believe in and why? They had some wonderful experience, maybe they heard a voice saying "I am God thou shall not have other gods but me". Ok you had that experience but what can and what do you infer from it? That every word in the Bible is true? How would you draw that conclusion, based on the heavenly experience you had? I think the point that many people refuse to question their "faith" is a clue which tells us that they believe because they want to believe, regardless of any factual basis. I'm not against faith I believe everybody has the right to believe whatever they choose to believe. And if they do then obviously there are good reasons why they do so, my guess is the reason is it makes them feel better.
- Yizahi 4y agoDo you realize that humanity has an enormous pool of people from multiple races and cultures, which have a near death experience on a regular basis? They are called soldiers. The representation of humans groups is near perfect in the army, excepts for women obviously. There is no evidence that near death experience can change human thinking to the "belief" in any statistically significant numbers. The only people who claim to become "believers" after such experience are probably people already on the verge of believing due to their psyche or education or both.
- barrysteve 4y agoThe article was quite difficult to read, the point was often lost in historical recaps and relationships between historical figures. The central premise is wrong, natural theology was dicussed by hume and paley, but neither of their arguments disprove it. Arguments about 'proving' god using end up being arguments about what 'kind' of evidence qualifies as proof, which is not explored here. Paley's infinite regression of watches doesn't sidestep God, it moves God into the watch. Paley's argument about a stone being ultimately purposeless depends on knowledge he doesn't have. The position you can't logically argue to God is JE Schellenberg's non-resistant, non-believer. As soon as you start arguing logical propositions, they have to end somewhere and it's always God if pushed far enough. Douglas Adams' parody argument is fun, but is just wrong as a serious theological argument. The 2005 version of intelligent design the article discusses was rejected from schools because it was an undeveloped young-earth creationist style religious proposition. Stephen meyer spent the rest of the 2000s debating phd scientists (buried in youtube) and found they couldnt challenge his claims and he also developed the idea into a scientific philosophy. That's the face of intelligent design the author should be addressing. It would be better for the internet community to have a wiki-like or myspace-like battleground for theological interpretation so that we can all skip to the most recent developments and see the history of it like a git changelog, without having to endlessly quiz a Dominican monk about the arguments Aquanis conquered.
- msmenardi 4y agoI think it was difficult for you to read because you aren't viewing it from the required context. It made perfect sense to me, I was enraptured and thought it was written beautifully. But I also have the requisite beliefs to address the subject matter - sorta like trying to grok algebra without understanding division or multiplication. >The central premise is wrong, natural theology was dicussed by hume and paley, but neither of their arguments disprove it. This is a misunderstanding, I think, because the author was saying Hume and Paley are examples of natural theology, they weren't trying to disprove it. They were embedded in their own cultural and theological context, just as we are, and if they could view us (as we view them) then they'd understand just as little of our context as we do of theirs. >Arguments about 'proving' god using end up being arguments about what 'kind' of evidence qualifies as proof, which is not explored here. Right, because the piece was written to show the differing definitions of "proof" - how do you prove something immaterial using a material context? You can't, because that'd be attempting to connect two disconnected fields. It's like using math to define a word in the dictionary. The argument between spiritual and atheist people was never "does god exist", but rather "what is god's will (in relation to this phenomenon) / what is the scientific nature of this phenomenon", which is two ways of saying the same thing. This isn't an attempt to say "Ha atheists are dumb and they suck, god rulezz" it's more of a peace offering - "Hey can we agree to focus on the authoritarian patriarchal evangelical zealots who want to condemn our children to a life of ignorance?" >Paley's infinite regression of watches doesn't sidestep God, it moves God into the watch. Paley's argument about a stone being ultimately purposeless depends on knowledge he doesn't have. I think you misunderstood Paley here - essentially he's saying the difference between seeing a rock by the side of the road and a watch is that with a rock you wouldn't presume any ultimate purpose, because it's just a rock. But a watch is intricate, it's mechanical, it clearly has purpose - therefore we can view other things with unclear purposes - like earlobes or mosquitos or geologic processes - as having some kind of purpose, even if we don't understand it. Therefore we shouldn't (I dunno) extinct dodos or something, because clearly there is some purpose in them simply because they exist at all. I think it's important to note that "purpose" doesn't necessarily imply forethought, as discussed later in the article when they talk about how evolution and such is the most germane and lucid presentation of god's will. >As soon as you start arguing logical propositions, they have to end somewhere and it's always God if pushed far enough. Well, by arguing so, you're pushing them in a specific direction. Are you really surprised they end at the polar edge of their reasoning? >Douglas Adams' parody argument is fun, but is just wrong as a serious theological argument. Then give the author credit and take it as a fun burst of levity, and not as a serious theological argument. >The 2005 version of intelligent design the article discusses was rejected from schools because it was an undeveloped young-earth creationist style religious proposition. Stephen meyer spent the rest of the 2000s debating phd scientists (buried in youtube) and found they couldnt challenge his claims and he also developed the idea into a scientific philosophy. That's the face of intelligent design the author should be addressing. Yup. Almost as if we share a common enemy. >It would be better for the internet community to have a wiki-like or myspace-like battleground for theological interpretation so that we can all skip to the most recent developments and see the history of it like a git changelog, without having to endlessly quiz a Dominican monk about the arguments Aquanis conquered. That sounds good to me, but how do you distill it? I think nearly as much effort would be required in administrating and preparing the presentation of the conversation as would be in actually making them. And making arguments is the fun part.
- nikolay 4y agoFaith by definition is believing without requiring proof! In fact, searching for proof requires your faith is not solid!
- mjh2539 4y agoThe root of the word faith comes from the Latin "fides", which can alternatively be translated as "trust" (think fiduciary). You don't need faith to believe in God. This is a common misunderstanding among both atheists and theists.
- _gabe_ 4y agoThis article seems to be saying that science and religion are trying to answer the same question, how did we get here. But I feel like that's misguided. I've always been under the impression that science is descriptive, it answers how? Whereas religion is deeper than that and aims to answer why? We can explain how natural processes work, but, and I believe this is a question Aristotle asked with the immovable mover, we'll never be able to get to a root cause of why everything exists and what started it all. Either the universe is infinite and time has no beginning, or there is a beginning and potentially an end. If there's a beginning, what was before the beginning? If it's infinite, how did it all start? These are the questions that I thought religion tried to answer. Science can (most likely) never answer why. Science is fundamentally based on repeatable experiments, and that's fine. We can use it to build a model of how the universe works, but as of today, we can't use science to answer the fundamental questions about the reason for the universe.
- andrewmcwatters 4y agoReligion doesn’t answer why we are here. Non-religious people think that’s what religion does.
- azth 4y agoDepends on which religion. Islam does: * https://quran.com/51/56 https://quran.com/51/56 * https://quran.com/67/2 https://quran.com/67/2 And more.
- andrewmcwatters 4y agoThe Book of Isaiah says the same thing. That's not the point of either religion, and practitioners know this.
- azth 4y agoYour accusing Muslims of knowing that the point of religion is something different from what the Quran says? That's quite brazen.
- WoahNoun 4y ago
- ithkuil 4y agoScience may not be able to explain why and how the universe came into existence but it may explain why humans so stubbornly insist to know the reasons for something they can't ever know yet at the same time are so willing to accept irrational explanations for it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- silent_cal 4y agoFor the record, natural theology is very much alive in the Catholic tradition, and it is certainly used to prove that God exists. This article seems to be focused on Evangelicals and New Atheists, which are different traditions.
- jononomo 4y agoThe existence of God is easily proven from an empirical scientific perspective just by observing the genetic code, the inner workings of the cell, and contemplating the origin-of-life problem.