3 ms·
Berry's nine standards for technology are worth considering: 1. The new tool should be cheaper than the one it replaces. 2. It should be at least as small in
by dredmorbius 4y ago
Berry's nine standards for technology are worth considering:
1. The new tool should be cheaper than the one it replaces.
2. It should be at least as small in scale as the one it replaces.
3. It should do work that is clearly and demonstrably better than the one it replaces.
4. It should use less energy than the one it replaces.
5. If possible, it should use some form of solar energy, such as that of the body.
6. It should be repairable by a person of ordinary intelligence, provided that he or she has the necessary tools.
7. It should be purchasable and repairable as near to home as possible.
8. It should come from a small, privately owned shop or store that will take it back for maintenance and repair.
9. It should not replace or disrupt anything good that already exists, and this includes family and community relationships.
I'm not sure even his own tool choices (typewriter and wife) meet the criteria. The typewriter replaced the quill pen, and at least initially failed conitions 1, 4, 8, and 9.
There might also be other factors for consideration. I'm not prone to jump on the latest technologies, but do own several computers (and a typewriter). Net effectiveness, suitability to task, expansion of possibilities, and other factors are amongst those I'd consider. Many of Berry's concerns would seem to me to come from the realm of unintended consequences, and might be better considered in that light.
His is a useful meditation, whether or not you adopt its conclusions.
- ajuc 4y agoI can't think of 1 invention in history that fullfil all of these.
- andi999 4y agoif a new soap bar is cheaper and smaller, I think it fullfils all criteria. (if it adds sawdust which increases the functionality)
- DoctorNick 4y agoReferring to his wife as a tool… I have to wonder if that marriage lasted
- ad404b8a372f2b9 4y ago""" I am also surprised by the meanness with which two of these writers refer to my wife. In order to imply that I am a tyrant, they suggest by both direct statement and innuendo that she is subservient, characterless, and stupid - a mere "device" easily forced to provide meaningless "free labor." I understand that it is impossible to make an adequate public defense of one's private life, and so I will only point out that there are a number of kinder possibilities that my critics have disdained to imagine: that my wife may do this work because she wants to and likes to; that she may find some use and some meaning in it; that she may not work for nothing. These gentlemen obviously think themselves femin- ists of the most correct and principled sort, and yet they do not hesitate to stereotype and insult, on the basis of one fact, a woman they do not know. They are audacious and irrespon- sible gossips. """ Things change but they stay the same.
- themadturk 4y agoThose responding saying he treats his wife as a tool are just mean-spirited. She was his editor and, apparently, as much a part of his creative process as his pencil and paper. I can certainly imagine that she was willing and happy in that role. (And yes, the marriage has lasted. She's been described as one of the most important fiction editors no one has heard of, thanks to her work with her husband.) His reaction, though, seems to say that working on a computer rather than on a typewriter would completely eliminate her role in the process. This is, of course, a failure of imagination on his part. If she'd learned to use a word processor she would have been able to do the job she'd always done, probably with more flexibility and efficiency than when she had to type essays multiple times through the revision process.
- hourago 4y agoThe list seems tech that is not "worth considering" but if a new technology fulfills all this criteria it would be immortal not to use it.
- dredmorbius 4y agoImmortal? Or the slightly lower bar of immoral?
- hourago 4y ago> Or the slightly lower bar of immoral? Way better that way.
- GTP 4y agoYes I agree, these points are worth reflecting upon. I agree with some of them but I disagree with others, here is my opinion in short, point by point: 1. Debatable. It is nice it it costs less, but if it has added or improved functionalities then each person should evaluate if for their use case the added/improved functionality is worth the extra cost or not. 2. Debatable, for the same reason as point 1: each person should evaluate this by themself. 3. I agree 4. Not sure for the same reason as points 1 and 2, but since we're in an environmental crisis this point is becoming more and more relevant. 5. I strongly agree due to environmental concerns. But also note that a device doesn't necessarily need to be designed to use solar energy: it could just end up using it because the power grid switched to a more sustainable energy mix 6. I agree, at least for consumer devices. 7. Also this could be good, although it is not granted that a private person going with his own car to a nearby shop pollutes less than a big shipping company that tries to optimize shipments as much as possible. It could be the opposite. 8. Not necessarily, also a big franchise of shops works, as long as they actually take care of repairing the devices instead of inventing excuses to not do so (look at what Louis Rossman has to say about Apple Sores for an example, but of course it is not just Apple) 9. I agree but with a catch: we need to better define what this "anything good" is. Because a new technology that replaces an old one is disrupting that old technology. Maybe the old technology was already good, but if the new one is better in some form then it's woth considering disrupting the old one. Indeed we should keep in mind potential side effects of a new technology that could harm society. Edit: formatting
- Izkata 4y ago> 5. If possible, it should use some form of solar energy, such as that of the body. Still working on making my skin glow, got any tips?