6 ms·
NextDoor: home of the dumbest people on the Internet. They must be proud of that. There are occasionally things I want to see on there: a new Costco going in w
by AlbertCory 4y ago
NextDoor: home of the dumbest people on the Internet. They must be proud of that.
There are occasionally things I want to see on there: a new Costco going in where the OSH Hardware used to be, or whatnot. So I got the daily email digest. One email per day -- tolerable.
Then it stopped coming. I wrote to Support, and their guy swore it was still being sent! I said "no, it's not. I looked in Spam and Trash." He swore again that it was going out, and I should "check with my email provider."
I asked "How do you know they're going out? Did you look in the Sent folder?" He got all sniffy and said "We are unable to disclose anything about our internal operations." Ooh, big secret!
So I wrote to the Nextdoor handle on Twitter. They told me there was an experiment going on. I asked if they could take me out of it. They did and all was good again.
Except other people on Nextdoor were also unhappy about being in the experiment, and asked me how I got out of it. I told them; they tried it; Nextdoor now refused to do it for them.
Think about it -- almost every site on the Web is trying to get you to sign up for a daily email. Nextdoor already has one, and they're trying to take it away.
- dylan604 4y ago> Think about it -- almost every site on the Web is trying to get you to sign up for a daily email. Nextdoor already has one, and they're trying to take it away. Well, this is kind of a "duh!" moment though, yeah? Of course they don't want your only interaction with them to be a single email once a day. That's so Web1.0. They want you on their appyApp so that they can hit you with all of their engagement algos and gather all of those metrics from you and what not. No once-a-day-v̵i̵t̵a̵m̵i̵n̵-email will ever give them the numbers they are looking, and if you're not giving them those $$$ then why give you the content?
- AlbertCory 4y agoWhy? Well, the alternative is: I never go to their stupid website. Whereas now, I go there when some entry in the daily email is interesting. And very occasionally, contribute something that entices other people to go there. Nextdoor: "Hey, how about you come here several times a day and stay, like we were a real website or something?" Me: "Nope, nope, nope. Buh bye."
- kelnos 4y agoRight, and I bet the experiment was to figure out how many people would notice the missing email, and either complain, or start visiting the site more often. Of course we'll never know if most people are more like you, or would actually go to the site daily, if it weren't for the email.
- AlbertCory 4y agoI don't have the app on my phone, so either (1) they didn't notice that, or (2) they wondered if losing the digest would make me install it (guess not). I think the app is what's supposed to make their site "sticky."
- zionic 4y ago
- ultrarunner 4y agoSpecifically for the design. I haven't been on it in a year, so my memory is foggy, but the reason I left was the fact that it seems tailor made to amplify the most paranoid, antisocial perspectives at the expense of good faith and trust. The following progression of thought comes to mind: many police departments have a mandatory arrest policy for calls in response to alleged domestic violence. Despite the fact that many neighborhoods are, frankly, boring, plenty of nextdoor users are looking for a chance to interact with the app and contribute to "the greater good." It's easy enough to call the police "just in case," but often there are disastrous results[0] that at minimum include the arrest of one of the partners, regardless of guilt. This kind of mindless see-something-say-something excuse marches us daily toward a speech-chilling antisocial breakdown where all that's left to do is clutch our pearls and cower at the thought of interaction. Nextdoor directly provides a channel for the amplification and praise of this modality of thought. While (I hope) most people reject or ignore it, its continued existence is a net negative for neighborhoods and society. [0] https://www.fox10phoenix.com/news/police-release-video-taken-during-deadly-officer-involved-shooting-in-ahwatukee-foothills https://www.fox10phoenix.com/news/police-release-video-taken... -- note that Ahwatukee is a wealthy suburb of Phoenix
- Spooky23 4y agoYeah they changed the default behavior a year or two ago so that if there’s a post in a nearby neighborhood that someone in your neighborhood engages with, it shows up in your feed. The result is that shitposts spread and drive engagement.
- zionic 4y agoI can’t comment specifically with certainty on the internals of their algorithm. What I can say though is I have lost most of the faith I had in moderation systems, their role should be to validate that XYZ is actually your neighbor. Maybe rate limit all posts by geo. Beyond that? Fuck off.
- zionic 4y agoThis is because Nextdoor is “moderated” by your local neighborhood gestapo. Nextdoor, as an institution, actively seeks out people who pathologically engage with their platform and then gives them power over people geographically local to them. This results in moderation-cliques that decide what can and cannot be posted in their local neighborhoods. It somehow manages to be worse than this site when it comes to suppression and censorship, and to be honest I’ve almost totally lost the desire to interact with either. I’ve hit peak moderation fatigue, I’m tired and quite frankly offended anyone thinks they can tell me what I should (or want) to see. All their algorithms are corrupt, all the systems that rely on manual, human moderation are biased and useless. Curation is an iron grip around my throat and I want to cut it. I’m to the point that I’d rather drink from the firehose of “misinformation” than thirst in the desert centralized of approval. Edit: originally posted this in reply to a comment down-chain, but by the time I finished typing “you can’t reply to this anymore”. It’s getting meta at this point
- AlbertCory 4y agoI feel for you. And that's why it's worth getting a daily email from Nextdoor, but no more than that.
- int_19h 4y agoI don't know how Nextdoor "seeks out people" to moderate, but what I can tell you is that my previous community lead was a guy who didn't post at all for like 2 years. My new community lead is me, somehow, even though I didn't post for almost as long. 99% of my posts even now are basically, "hey, can you guys please read the rules before making yet another post about a suspicious black dude who's obviously up to no good cuz he's wearing a hoodie? kthx". (I don't know if that constitutes the "neighborhood gestapo" in your book.)
- mcv 4y ago"Somehow"? How are these community leads assigned?
- 4y ago
- matheusmoreira 4y agoWhat is it with these corporations randomly running experiments on people anyway? It used to be that there was an opt in buried somewhere in the settings. Now they just assume we want to be their unpaid guinea pigs?
- flukus 4y agoIt's a consequence of having our software run on other peoples computers. 20 years ago it wasn't really an option because most software was installed and pushing updates was hard, but now everything can be updated without the user even knowing. IME there's a lot of people on HN that will even defend this sort of A/B testing. This is why I like debian, I never open an app to find out the entire UI is changed while I was asleep.
- nyanpasu64 4y agoIf only it were that easy... - Mandatory software updates can change UIs that run on """your""" machines. - I still remember when I was running Debian Unstable, the day I ran a routine upgrade which replaced GNOME 2 with GNOME 3, I couldn't find my way around, and couldn't even easily revert because Linux distributions ship all their software in synchronized packages with interdependencies, and aren't built around picking and choosing older package versions (especially foundational packages).
- Georgelemental 4y agoYou chose to run software with "unstable" in the name, when there is a free "stable" version you could use instead. You opted in to unexpected, disrupted changes
- nyanpasu64 4y agoChill, I was young and new to Linux at the time, and Stable had outdated versions of packages I wanted.
- Lammy 4y ago> Nextdoor already has one, and they're trying to take it away. Once a day isn’t “engaging” enough when Nextdoor’s biggest competitor is built around real-time notifications of fear-porn-near-you: https://citizen.com/ https://citizen.com/
- te_chris 4y agoJesus. That is some proper scifi dystopian stuff. Any employees on here? How do you live with yourselves?
- zkldi 4y agoIt even uses 'for the greater good' as the tagline. I guess they haven't seen Hot Fuzz[1]? [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rm--inJtnc4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rm--inJtnc4
- Lammy 4y agoMy favorite part is "Your world is safer with Citizen" superimposed over a photo of One World Trade Center.
- TheRealDunkirk 4y agoWhy not address the shareholders and officers with that question?
- NonNefarious 4y agoNextDoor is an incompetent mailing list. They don't even understand how a digest is supposed to work. I mean... FREE software had this down in the '90s.
- tablespoon 4y ago> NextDoor is an incompetent mailing list. They don't even understand how a digest is supposed to work. I mean... FREE software had this down in the '90s. Honestly, I think we'd all be better off if all social media was in digest form: queue up everyone's posts to be published next day at 9AM. That'd put a break on things, instead of having stuff snowball out of control. However, it's probably been determined that it's best for the social media companies themselves for stuff to always snowball out of control, so non-digest it what we'll always get.