3 ms·
This is a good opportunity for people to learn some basic media literacy and how to deconstruct propaganda. For the record, I'm o fthe opinion that the evidenc
by jmyeet 4y ago
This is a good opportunity for people to learn some basic media literacy and how to deconstruct propaganda.
For the record, I'm o fthe opinion that the evidence for climate change is clear, compelling and undeniable. So don't take this or my previous comment to any kind of denial. Climate change is real. It's just not the primary cause of the problem.
So, what we see with an effort to blame this on climate chang eis an effort at misdirection. Climate change as a political issue tends to follow left vs right divisions. If you're left-leaning, you tend to believe in climate change. If you're right leaning, you tend to be a denier.
Agricultural industries are, by their nature, rural. Rural voters tend to be conservative. So why is a business that leans conservative blaming climate change for the Colorado River problems? Because it blames the issue that many will deny the existence of and for those that don't deny, many will believe there's nothign that can be done.
And on the left, some so want the very real issue of climate change to be taken seriously, they'll latch onto any media coverage that shows the ill-effects of climate change, even when climate change isn't the primary cause. I personally believe this undermines the cause because when people realize it's an unrelated issue it undermines that issue.
So agribusiness blaming this on climate change is smart propaganda because people on both sides will latch onto the narrative (for different reasons).
But this is propaganda.
- robonerd 4y agoCentral Valley farmers love to deny climate change and blame the government for all their problems. What they don't want to admit is their "perfect" farmland was bone dry a few centuries ago, and is now reverting back to that state.
- downut 4y agoYes, I agree completely. I once structured a month's unpaid leave in the early '90s around a camping tour partially as an "eye's on the ground" of Mark Reisners "Cadillac Desert"[1]. It was, erm, eye opening to see the built environment for water across Eastern CA (including Owen's Valley), Utah, Colorado, and of course AZ. I have been across Imperial Valley a whole bunch of times on all of the externally connecting roads. Agribusiness is not stupid. Climate change is the perfect wedge issue. (I am also not a climate change denier!) [1] Recent experts seem to dislike that book but at least it provides a nice map for things to see.
- soco 4y agoOk so will anything be done about either topic? Unsustainable agriculture and climate change?