6 ms·
To stop this madness, we have to attack and bring down the people who cause this retardation - the content industries. The content industries don't cause this.
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
To stop this madness, we have to attack and bring down the people who cause this retardation - the content industries.
The content industries don't cause this. They go to politicians and say "pretty please take away people's freedom to protect our profits". That's the only thing they have the power to do.
Politicians are not helpless babies who have no choice but to give big content what it wants. They are intelligent adults who choose to side with big content.
The people you need to bring down are Biden/Obama, Orrin Hatch, etc.
- jterce 15y agoAgreed. It's the same as the "occupy" movement saying that corporations shouldn't influence government. It's true, but it's the politicians who are the problem. Everyone, the content providers included, should be representing their best interests to politicians. The burden is on the politicians to remain uncorrupted and to represent the best interests of their constituents to the fullest degree possible under law.
- _delirium 15y agoIf, after several hundred years of trying, we haven't yet found the mythical race of "uncorruptible politician", it might be time for a plan B, like systemic changes to reduce the effects of corruption on the very-human politicians we do have (and are likely to continue having). That's essentially the campaign-finance-reform argument, that the problem isn't going to be solved by hoping that the next crop of politicians, unlike just about every crop throughout human history, will be selfless saints who don't respond to incentives; rather, the solution is to change the incentives.
- pnathan 15y agoThis is the solution; a system level design that assumes a level of corruption and general stupidity, then feeds incentives to help the broad spectrum of society.
- Gormo 15y agoWhat makes it any more reasonable to suggest that it's possible to change the incentives than to suggest we can find uncorruptible politicians? I don't think that this systemic view aligns with the campaign-finance-reform argument argument at all; the people who want money out of politics regard money itself as the root cause of the problem, but neglects to address the real underlying incentives that money - merely an abstraction of value - actually represents. If you take money out of the picture, those incentives will still exist, and still convey political advantage. Who dominates politics then, if not the wealthiest? The most well-connected? The most ruthless? The real, underlying systemic problem is the centralized concentration of de jure power in a small set of political institutions. This will always be susceptible to concentrated influence, whether via money or otherwise.
- jbooth 15y agoWell, here in the real world, there was a Citizen's United decision in 2009, and there was record-setting advertising spending from industry groups in 2010. In a midterm election. Noone's claiming they have a perfect system, I'd be satisfied if we stopped sliding backwards.
- Gormo 15y agoWhat do you mean by 'sliding backwards'? What was wrong with the Citizen's United decision? What's wrong with high advertising spending? Are you implying that voters are really so easily influenced by the mere volume as advertising that advertising alone is the overriding determinant of electoral success? If that's your point, isn't it actually an indictment of democracy itself?
- _delirium 15y agoIt's a good question; perhaps we can't. I think it's worth thinking about and considering if we really can't do anything to reduce likelihood or magnitude of corruption, though. The founding fathers spent a decent amount of time thinking about it in their own historical context, rather than leaving it purely to a trust that voters will punish politicians who behave badly. For example, the U.S. Constitution has written into it a prohibition on federal officeholders accepting titles of nobility, no matter how much voters like or dislike the politician in question; they just decided not to leave that question for the voters, but thought it would lead to less corruptible politics if politicians were completely banned from accepting noble titles. That at least doesn't seem to have had any particularly bad effects, though there is debate over whether it had good effects or was just symbolic anti-monarchism. It does seem vaguely analogous to some of the no-gifts clauses that have been proposed and/or implemented more recently, though the analogy isn't perfect.
- yuhong 15y agoI remember posting this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3161455 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3161455
- CWuestefeld 15y agoit might be time for a plan B, like systemic changes to reduce the effects of corruption ... That's essentially the campaign-finance-reform argument No, your response doesn't address your goal at all. CFR doesn't do a darned thing to "reduce the effects of corruption". It seeks to decrease the possible vectors of corruption (both in quantity and magnitude), but it does absolutely nothing to address the effects of corruption. What yummyfajitas and others have been arguing is precisely for a solution to the problem you cite, the effects of corruption. That is to make it so that it matters much less how a bureaucrat gets corrupted, by stripping him of power to the greatest extent possible, so that the potential for damage he can cause is minimized.
- anigbrowl 15y agoThat so-called solution also ties the hands of honest reformers. Obstruction of regulatory function is just as subject to corruption as an excess thereof. The notion that the payor is morally pure is absurd; public choice theory shows that large entities like corporations and unions have every incentive to rig the process by exploiting the rational ignorance of the median voter.
- afterburner 15y agoOne solution is term limits on Congress. Unfortunately, Congress votes on the bills and amendments, so it's not happening.
- anigbrowl 15y agoWe have term limits in California and there is absolutely no sign that it has led to better legislation.
- afterburner 15y agoThe goal is not better legislation; I agree term limits wouldn't do anything for that. The goal is to combat accumulation of power, which results in greater and greater corruption.
- nroach 15y agoWell, I think it's a bit more than: "pretty please take away people's freedom to protect our profits". That's the only thing they have the power to do." More along the lines of: "Pretty please take away people's freedom and here's a huge bucket of cash set up as an anonymous corporate shell donor. If you don't support us we'll give this huge bucket of cash to your opponent. kthxbye." But I agree that a lack of term limits or accountability means that its the career politicians who are ultimately responsible.
- yummyfajitas 15y ago"Pretty please take away people's freedom and here's a huge bucket of cash set up as an anonymous corporate shell donor. If you don't support us we'll give this huge bucket of cash to your opponent. kthxbye." Ok, more precisely: "pretty please take away people's freedom or else we might tell everybody that you're a poopy head."
- jbooth 15y agoIt's not "tell everyone you're a poopy-head", it's "run saturation-level advertising claiming that you voted to take away medicare, raise taxes and make it illegal for people to visit certain websites", unless you agree to our bill making it illegal to visit certain websites. Advertising works. I've canvassed the last 4 or so national election years and every single time I hear a lot of people echo the latest attack ad as truth, or say "I just don't know who to believe".
- InclinedPlane 15y agoIn reality it's more like this: Step 1: Use bucket of cash to gain access to and develop a rapport with a politician, increase the rapport and dependency with campaign contributions Step 2: Convince said politician of your perspective, namely that the works of art your company has struggled to create are threatened by people who want to "steal" them without paying. Step 3: Convince said politician that it's necessary to go to special measures to protect content from being "stolen" because it's such a big and growing "problem". In many cases these steps can be quite natural and good seeming. The biggest problems are that the MPAA/RIAA have a lot more access to politicians than and a much more well honed "pitch" than any organization seeking to defend individuals.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- amurmann 15y agoIt's more of a systemic problem with how democracy (if you want to call it that) works in this country. The costs of running a successful, political campaign are unbelievably high and contributions from corporations and lobby organizations play a major role in it. For all practical purposes, you only get the choice between two huge parties. Not only is a large segment of the population pretty much bound to one party, since they would never ever vote for the other party, but for those people who actually might swing their vote, there are even more issues at hand. Even if you wanted to use corruption as your single decision criterium, the choice would be hard. Both parties managed to stay pretty en par in that and that's all they needed to do. The brain washing that the campaign contributions pay for also work really well. It's astonishing what unimportant tiny events change in the polls before a presidential election. There is a complete decoupling from reality, once the race nears the finish. If we want a better working system, we need a better democratic process. Sadly the US was a pioneer in that and is still stuck with a system, that was brilliant for its time, but needs updating. We need a system that allows more than two parties to participate and we need better campaign funding regulation. That's the only way we can permanently stop BS like this
- poppysan 15y agoHow does Obama/Biden side with "big content"? Everyone has their preference to repub or dems, but this seems unfounded to me...
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIf this seems unfounded to you, it's because you are unfamiliar with Biden's record. http://news.cnet.com/2010-1071-946732.html?tag=mncol;txt http://news.cnet.com/2010-1071-946732.html?tag=mncol;txt http://www.politechbot.com/docs/congress.p2p.letter.081002.pdf http://www.politechbot.com/docs/congress.p2p.letter.081002.p... http://news.cnet.com/Senators-aim-to-restrict-Net,-satellite-radio-recording/2100-1028_3-6149915.html?tag=mncol;txt http://news.cnet.com/Senators-aim-to-restrict-Net,-satellite... http://news.cnet.com/8301-10784_3-9920665-7.html?tag=mncol;txt http://news.cnet.com/8301-10784_3-9920665-7.html?tag=mncol;t... Please note that I was attempting to avoid partisanship by naming Orrin Hatch (R, Utah) as well.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- candleholder 15y agohttp://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2011/01/riaa-lawyer-solicitor-general http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2011/01/riaa-lawyer-solicit...
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoWhile I appreciate you calling out the lovely senator from my state (and I completely agree), with such a poorly informed public and with issues that exceed the capacity of many to understand even if they did try yo become informed, I don't think there is a solution that doesn't require a massive overhaul. Personally, I've like many aspects of the Starship Troopers model: if you don't care enough to serve your country (military or humanitarian), you may still live there, but you are disenfranchised. I suspect there is the real potential for tyranny of the voters, but, in theory, the service is supposed to limit that.
- cabalamat 15y ago> The content industries don't cause this. They go to politicians and say "pretty please take away people's freedom to protect our profits". It's not the fault of corporations. It's not the fault of politicians. It's the fault of corporations and politicians working together. When that happens, it is usually not in the public interest.