4 ms·
Can they not spend $1.5 million per unit to build luxury housing and then allow the old luxury housing to become affordable? This kind of economics has worked
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
Can they not spend $1.5 million per unit to build luxury housing and then allow the old luxury housing to become affordable? This kind of economics has worked in the past for housing when we built a lot more units, and it's kind of the natural lifecycle of a building.
- bombcar 4y agoThe dirty secret is that "affordable housing" is usually a certain number of "dwelling units" in a new development (think apartment building) and so they dump as much as possible of the entire cost of the building into the cost for the "affordable units". If I am building a building with 50 high-end condos, I won't bother making cheaper ones for my affordable units, I'll just designate some as affordable and maybe skimp on the trimmings, but even then probably not much because of the hassle.
- zdragnar 4y agoIt's not a dirty secret, it is by design. Having mixed income properties is thought to significantly deter the sort of blight caused by "ghetto projects".
- opportune 4y agoI’m not against mixed income developments as a way to combat ghettoization, but in a lot of cases in CA the costs are born by the developer (and thus indirectly the people purchasing the new units) which keeps the regulatory burden/costs of new developments high. So while it does create some below-market housing for those lucky enough to finagle their way in, it keeps the actual market rate construction expensive. In my opinion it would be better for local governments to buy off the units from developers if they so chose, so the full cost is born by the program. Of course, that wouldn’t really solve the problem unless new construction were less restricted, since not enough is being built anyway for the % of “affordable” units to be able to make much more of a dent. What bothers me is that a lot of people don’t actually know how “affordable housing” is implemented, and if they did I bet most wouldn’t support it. Not only because of the complexity and costs it adds to new market rate construction, but also that you still need an income of like $70-$150k to qualify for owned BMR housing in SF and I don’t really care to subsidize people at those income levels.
- foolfoolz 4y agothis isn’t a secret it’s section 8 and not the problem. new construction doesn’t need to be cost effective affordable housing. new construction can and should be luxury. affordable housing can be older buildings. it’s not a secret because the market is already priced this way
- seoaeu 4y agoFirst off inclusionary units are not a “secret”. But more to the point, that not the kind of affordable housing that the article is talking about: The article is about 100% affordable developments which are almost always by non-profits receiving government funding.
- seoaeu 4y agoThe problem is that when people are suffering now, they don’t want to be told to wait a decade or two for current luxury housing stock to filter down and become affordable. Just imagine closing a local food bank and replacing it with a vague promise that the local grocery store prices will improve. How well is that going to go over? Long term, we do need more market rate (“luxury”) housing stock. But they cannot be instead of trying to help people who need it now Some places do social housing where they rent a fraction of the units to upper income individuals to subsidize the rest. However in the US funding sources generally have rules that say the units can only be rented to households making less than X% of the area median income. Which isn’t necessarily a bad thing: even in a properly functioning housing market there are going to be some people who cannot afford mark rate housing, and the assumption is that everyone else will rent market rate units