7 ms·
Where is the scam in this? [0], [1], [2] Also, does that mean that you going to finally stop using Signal for not only having mobile wallet [3] for payments, b
by rvz 4y ago
Where is the scam in this? [0], [1], [2]
Also, does that mean that you going to finally stop using Signal for not only having mobile wallet [3] for payments, but also facilitating in using cryptocurrencies for donations? [4]
[0] https://skiff.org https://skiff.org
[1] https://ens.domains https://ens.domains
[2] https://handshake.org https://handshake.org
[3] https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360057625692-In-app-Payments#payments_which_ones https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360057625692-In...
[4] https://signal.org/donate/ https://signal.org/donate/
- NullPrefix 4y agoDon't care about Signal wallets, stopped using Signal long ago when Moxxie came out against federation.
- alexanderh 4y agoSo lets say that none of these web3 coins are scams. They still aren't actually solving anything that hasn't already been solved with web2. So at best they are unnecessary. And while the examples you have listed may not be scams, unfortunately the general web3 landscape is rife with them.
- rglullis 4y agoThe keyword for web3 is disintermediation. This might not be important for you, but it is far from being "unnecessary".
- jasonshaev 4y ago(Not the OP) Re: Skiff, it looks like a very cool product but I'm skeptical they can make enough money. The primary path to monetization for a product like this would be enterprise SaaS licensing but I simply don't see how you can sell to enterprises without centralizing the product. Auditability, compliance, SSO, etc. would all seem to be difficult if not impossible with the product as specced.
- johnmarcus 4y agoSkiff.org charges $8 USD/month for it's premium service, and it's just an implementation of PGP encryption. I have no idea what this as to do with crypto. ens.domains is a privately owned and managed DNS provider. It's litterally the exact opposite of what web3 claims to be. Having a "constitution" is just re-wording "Terms of Service". I love how it sells hard covers versions of it's Terms of Service for fiat at Blurb.com. And no, Blurb does not accept cryptocurrency payments even, lol. Signal.org existed well before they added crypto, and quite frankly, yes I did just about completely stop using it - and so did many others. The introduction of cryptocurrency in that app litterally chased away users rather than improve adoption. Gawd, could go on forever here.
- amilich 4y agoSkiff allows login with MetaMask and Brave wallet, lets you store files with E2EE on IPFS, and lets you send/receive emails to your wallet address. And of course you can pay for your subscription with crypto. There's no coin, because there's absolutely no need for one.
- uoaei 4y agoAgain, how is this a web3 service and not just a version of SSO that allows for a couple not-so-commonly-used centralized authentication services? Taking payments in crypto doesn't really seem to me to be anything "web3"-related apart from their finance department participating in the speculation game on the backend.
- rglullis 4y agoWay to miss the point. ENS being "privately owned" or "having a constitution" only really matters if you care about participating in the governance - which I will admit is silly - or if you want to have have some influence in further developments. But as an user, none of this matters. You can claim an id and no government or "owner" will take it from you. No registrar will give names to squatters to put in marketplaces. Actual ownership is public and transparent. Prices are reasonable. You can now have completely censorship-resistant sites by tying a ENS address with an IPFS page. ENS is already super useful if you care about owning your identities without worrying about intermediaries.
- bofadeez 4y agoOnly a very small percentage of the population has a demand for encrypted email or decentralized anything. Most people trust institutions blindly and it gives them anxiety to even think about not trusting them. Most people don't even agree that there's a problem at all with centralized institutional trust-based systems. They don't understand or trust algorithms, they trust brands on TV. Web 2.0 gave us legitimate added productivity and functionality of being able to do stuff online for the first time. Web 3.0 does nothing but give us a trustless system that nobody asked for. Zero new functionality in any of those apps. If you trust banks and FAANG companies, as most people do, Web 3.0 has exactly zero value.
- rglullis 4y agoAnd if you don't trust FAANG?
- JohnHaugeland 4y agothen it still has no value
- rglullis 4y agoLet me flip the question: if you think that "this" web3 has no value, what kind of web do you think could be built by and for those who don't trust FAANG? I am not even asking you to do anything. I am just asking you to think of an alternative.
- peoplefromibiza 4y ago> what kind of web do you think could be built by and for those who don't trust FAANG? The web? FAANG is not the web, it's just some companies putting apps on the web
- rglullis 4y agoNo. This web is controlled by these "some companies". They monopolize social media, e-commerce, games, telecommunication platforms. Billions of people go by assuming that Facebook is the internet. Go ahead and try to live on the internet without being forced to interact with any of FAANG services. It's impossible even for me, who tries to keep as strict of a "digital hygiene" as possible and use open source and open standards as much as possible. If you think that we can not improve on the web that we have today, either your standards are way too low or you already got so used to be manipulated by Big Tech that you can't even imagine how much better and freer life could be without it.
- JohnHaugeland 4y agoseems like you're saying "hey, here's an email company that takes crypto payments, here's two domain name companies for crypto, here's two posts about one company that takes donations in crypto, that means a multiple hundred billion dollar system that produces several nations of pollution and serves no tractable purpose other than being an unlicensed securities casino somehow isn't a scam" to which i reply: "shaka, when the moon lambo fell"