2 ms·
Part of the problem here is that good incentive design is incredibly, incredibly difficult. We've learned this lesson over and over again. If you apply an ince
by simonw 4y ago
Part of the problem here is that good incentive design is incredibly, incredibly difficult.
We've learned this lesson over and over again. If you apply an incentives layer to anything, people will attempt to game it. Watch what happens at any company that starts rewarding developers for number-of-issues-closed or lines-of-codes-written.
The only responsible way to work with incentives is to constantly monitor and re-balance them. I use Duolingo a lot and I find it really interesting watching how they tweak the various gamification models over time as people's behaviour alters. They need to balance their models such that people who game them will also learn the language most effectively.
The token model - represented by things like DAOs - generally requires this incentive design to be perfect up front. It assumes that people can design a perfect incentive system from day one - which obviously they cannot.
This goes right back to the beginning of smart contracts: Vitalik was famously inspired to create Ethereum after his World of Warcraft character got nerfed. But nerfing is essential to how game design works! If you don't constantly rebalance things your game ends up being broken.
- seibelj 4y agoI am a member of many token projects that have successfully altered their rules via governance vote. These include contract upgrades and fundamental changes to structure. It is possible to fix and augment post-launch, and in 2022 is quite common.
- simonw 4y agoYeah that's a good point - I'm wrong here to suggest that the rules are set in stone for every (or even most?) project.