4 ms·
High but realistic LVT at say 2% wouldn’t force people to sell, it would however tank the value of ultra expensive land. Fewer people could afford 2% of land v
by Retric 4y ago
High but realistic LVT at say 2% wouldn’t force people to sell, it would however tank the value of ultra expensive land.
Fewer people could afford 2% of land value + mortgage costs + insurance + … at current prices which means there are fewer buyers at those prices. That price drop scales with the LVT so at 10% you would pay more than at 2%, just nowhere close to 5x as much.
- ericmay 4y ago> it would however tank the value of ultra expensive land. Well it would depend on why the land is expensive. What it would do (at least in theory which I do agree with) is force the expensive land to be developed for a useful economic purpose instead of just sitting there. For single-family homes and such a LVT is likely to be neutral or slightly positive b/c a lot of those homes weren't built on particularly valuable or useful land (which is why it was cheap in the first place). I really like the idea of focusing taxes on more of a "what am I actually paying for in my community" which LVT and variations of that tend to support, but it'll never happen in the US.
- Retric 4y agoLVT’s don’t cover the cost of education, roads, police, etc that scale with population. What they tax is proximity to places people want to live or resources to be extracted etc. This tends to minimize the distance people travel to work, but it’s hardly go to force a billionaire to sell land they want to keep.
- ericmay 4y agoIt depends on the implementation, but generally it actually would cover these things.
- Retric 4y agoIf the land tax is identical between an apartment complex with 1,000 people and one across the street in a different school district with 10,000 people then it can’t.
- ericmay 4y agoIn such a case I think it wouldn’t be possible to have those two buildings be taxed exactly the same per-person because by virtue of 10,000 people living in an equivalent lot you’re demonstrating that the land value is quite high and so the 1,000 person lot would have to be adjusted significantly. You’d have to actually cram that many people onto a lot too, which means you are looking at a location like Manhattan level density in which case it’s very unlikely that a 1,000 person property isn’t paying significant land value taxes. I’m sure we can come up with contrived examples of things, but be open-minded to how things could work.
- Retric 4y agoFirst absolute density isn’t relevant in my example as a single property could hold 10,000 garden style apartments or 1,000 single family homes etc. Anyway, it’s not that property taxes are 1:1 with population, however it does broadly correlate with density. A farmer next to a subdivision is a more extreme version of the same thing that only represents which farmer happened to sell their land. Meanwhile a farm is less value per acre than a housing development. Just as high rises represent more value per acre than garden style apartments and garden style apartments beat single family homes. Land value taxes on the other hand ignore all such differences by design. The farmer pays the same amount per acre as the subdivision next door. LVT can capture increases in value as regions develops, but those increase don’t line up with political borders.
- ericmay 4y agoYou are mistakenly believing that LVT means that two lots of the same size are taxed the same rate.
- Retric 4y agoTwo equivalent lots next to each other should taxed the same or very close to it. Beachfront vs non beachfront isn’t equivalent, but two random fields in Northern Virginia next to each other with similar features should be. Anyway, LVT definitely doesn’t care about what you built on the property so this distinction just doesn’t matter.