4 ms·
Reasoning from real estate to describe the Internet is a fraught analogy. When "we landed there," the Internet didn't exist; it wasn't built yet. It's not finit
by shadowgovt 4y ago
Reasoning from real estate to describe the Internet is a fraught analogy. When "we landed there," the Internet didn't exist; it wasn't built yet. It's not finite carve-able territory like a continent; it's machines, the interconnections between them, and the data accessible on them. And all of those things were always owned by someone (even if the data wasn't under copyright, someone was paying for the electrons to represent and transmit it).
Everything about access to the network has grown as a peer-and-guest arrangement between private owners or government entities (starting from the original systems where most people connected via academia or the government and being fired from your government position or exited from your university cut your access to your email account and other online resources). In this modern era, very few are peers and most are guests, and yes, the ownership situation reflects that. Adjusting that ownership situation by fiat or force is a fraught enterprise. Let's imagine someone tries to nationalize Internet infrastructure that is currently privately-owned and establish a democratic structure for managing it. What government do we trust to do that? Part of the allure of the Internet was how hard it was for governments to control it; do we willingly hand them that power?
All of that having been said, I agree with you that tension is there between the origins of the Internet and the modern desire for self-actualization and personal data rights in the use of the Internet. I'm somewhat excited about projects like Mastodon that seem to be trying to decrease the complexity of becoming a peer. I can imagine someone starting a democratically-run service provider, perhaps off the credit union model, to provide more direct ownership to their userbase. Of course, it would have to compete in the corporate world alongside other companies, and there is, perhaps, a reason that the corporate world so closely resembles medieval fiefdoms almost uniformly. You noted "It took humanity thousands of years to figure out that democratic systems work better than feudal systems;" I'd offer the counterpoint that the feudal system describes most corporate structures pretty correctly. But maybe that's just accident of history and there's no particular reason that board-owned or single-owned companies dominate the landscape relative to co-ops.
It'd be a fun experiment to watch someone try to provide a better alternative as a service provider (in the connection, social networking, data hosting, or cloud infra spaces).