5 ms·
"It’s easier, after all, to take a risk, quit your day job, and start a new business if you don’t have to worry about getting health-care coverage." Actually,
by BerislavLopac 15y ago
"It’s easier, after all, to take a risk, quit your day job, and start a new business if you don’t have to worry about getting health-care coverage."
Actually, I think it's the other way around. First of all, countries with national health care have introduced it precisely because is citizens are less risk-tolerant on average. Also, with a bunch of social parachutes such as health care, solidarity pensions and the like, the willingness to risk actually decreases, as there is less incentive to "make it big".
- dylangs1030 15y agoAs with most other gambles, greater risk entails greater reward. Reduced risk (read: more comfortable safety net) means more competitors, a more diluted market for startups, and a lower payoff to fewer successes. Convesely, Google rose from America in precisely the quasi-starving artist mentality that makes a startup riskier with a less comfortable safety net. I agree.
- bobbles 15y agoSorry, but I think this is delusional. The fact that I can break my leg and pay for nothing more in the hospital than a pair of crutches to take home in no way is related to what I want to do professionally. On the other hand, the fact that it could cost some ridiculous amount in the states would definitely drive me to wanting to stay put in a reliable salary position in corporate world.
- dylangs1030 15y agoTo play devil's advocate, there are different ways of looking at this. While in theory you're right, I'm not sure startup founders are thinking of their health insurance when they decide to quit their jobs. They are probably more concerned with immediate requirements, like raw shelter, food and utilities. But again, there's several ways to look at it.
- mixmax 15y agoI'm from Denmark, maybe the country with the best social safety net in the world. The state pays your medical bills, your school and education (you even get a state allowance to live on while you study), if you lose your job the state will give you money, and so on. You can actually live a whole life with nothing but statemoney. The startup culture here is terrible, exactly because of this. People become cosy and risk averse because they don't really need to fight, and because there's no need to. So i think the parent hits the nail pretty much on the head.
- chairface 15y agoThat's an interesting correlation that you've transformed into causation.
- BerislavLopac 15y agoActually, a "reliable salary position in corporate world" is actually not -- you could get fired, or even if you don't you might get denied the coverage by your insurance company. In the US, as I understand it, the most reliable way to enjoy a similar level of social protection provided by most European countries is to get quite wealthy, amirite?
- Daniel_Newby 15y ago> First of all, countries with national health care have introduced it precisely because is citizens are less risk-tolerant on average. Really? Those countries tend to be much more homogenous than the U.S. Sweden does not have a horde of Mexicans who dearly wish to become free riders.
- majika 15y agoForgoing your blatant racism, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_foreign-born_population_in_2005 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_foreign-bo... Sort by "immigrants as a percentage of national population." In fact, Sweden and the US have almost identical immigrant percentages. Switzerland, Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and Austria all have higher immigrant percentages than the US, and all these countries have public health care systems.
- Daniel_Newby 15y agoLook, the demand for a free service is infinite. For an expensive service like medical care, giving it away is very expensive indeed. > Forgoing your blatant racism, ... "Racism" is not a general purpose swear word, any more than is fascism. And even if my motives were naked bigotry, Mexican is a political affiliation, not a race. The appropriate accusation would be to call me an American nationalist. > Switzerland, Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and Austria all have higher immigrant percentages than the US ... Their immigrants are heavily skewed towards the First World, and screened for acceptability. None of them share a border with a famously corrupt third-world country. (I suppose Canada may quibble. ;-) If you actually want to learn about the Latino medical theft problem, do some reading: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/21/health/policy/21grady.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/21/health/policy/21grady.html... http://www.cairco.org/econ/econ.html http://www.cairco.org/econ/econ.html http://www.newswithviews.com/DeWeese/tom94.htm http://www.newswithviews.com/DeWeese/tom94.htm
- chairface 15y ago> Look, the demand for a free service is infinite There are few things in life that are as demonstrably false as that sentence.
- Robin_Message 15y agoIt's interesting that you think that, since it is quite clear that it is the other way round. The article has data both implying that the US is bad at startups (23rd in the developed world), and suggesting that a lack of medical coverage (as evidenced by a spike at 65 when Medicare kicks in) is a key factor. A sensible argument against the article might be to suggest reasons why this is the case, or doesn't matter (US startups do better despite fewer being started, 65 is the retirement age so natural to start a business then). But instead you make up some rationalisation about national character and a desire to "make it big". The only place I see national character fitting in is that despite the extremely adverse circumstances to forming a startup in the US, its still quite good at them because "making it big" is part of the national psyche in a way it isn't in say, France, who don't even have a work for entrepreneur ;) The US genuinely embrace entrepreneurs and small businesses as a good thing, a valid lifestyle choice and even an aspirational one, and the surrounding business culture reflects that: for example, in the UK it can be very frustrating as a hobbyist in things like electronics since businesses don't want to know, whereas I get the impression that companies in the US are more open to dealing with individuals who may or may not represent small businesses.