6 ms·
Top Digital Calipers for Machinists (2021)
- olivermarks 4y agoBiggest problem I have with digital calipers, torque wrenches, micrometers etc is calibration. you only have to whack or drop them once before you no longer trust them and getting them checked isn't cheap
- brk 4y agoFor some of these, like the $80/6" Shars caliper that you can get from Amazon in 24 hours (most of the time), it's not even worth dealing with recalibration. If you no longer trust it, get a new one.
- dylan604 4y agoand who's to say the Amazon delivery person didn't drop kick it to your doorstep? being "new" doesn't automagically mean it is calibrated accurately
- brk 4y agoOf course, but the digital calipers I have bought are usually packaged in a way that would survive most shipping, even if dropped. That is much different than dropping them on a concrete shop floor.
- swighton 4y agoYou can inexpensively (~$10) check if your calipers have been whacked out of calibration as frequently as you want with a gauge block or other calibration standard. If they have, you can also calibrate using the same block.
- akgoel 4y agoMy problem with calipers is that there are three separate measuring modalities (outer, inner, depth) that can each require different zeroes as they get damaged.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoThere is a fourth using the back of the main head similarly to the depth probe. It can be less fiddly and less subject to wear if you don't need to get into a small space.
- msds 4y agoKinda a weird list; in my experience with hanging around lots of shops, it goes Mitutoyo 500-196-30 (non-IP67), Mitutoyo 500-752-20 (IP67), followed by a long tail of everything else.
- etrautmann 4y agoyep, exactly my experience. I've almost never seen non Mitutoyo calipers anywhere that's not a personal/hobby shop
- mc32 4y agoYes by and large, but the Starretts are no chopped liver. They make lots of precision instruments.
- teh_klev 4y agoAdam Booth, abom79 on YouTube appears to swear by his Starrett collection of instruments. I've also never seen him use a digital calibration/measuring tool, everything is precision mechanical. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SdtolQ6acak https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SdtolQ6acak https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gRB9SXSYZ2Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gRB9SXSYZ2Q
- Blackthorn 4y agoI've seem him use the Aventor brand from Shars of digital calipers.
- teh_klev 4y agoAh, ok, fair enough. If I could I'd edit to say "less often". I didn't think, in my five or so years of watching his work, I'd seen a digital caliper set in his hands.
- walterbell 4y agoStarrett models may vary by manufacturing origin, USA vs global/China.
- tvb12 4y agoI'm under the impression that digital calipers are kind of like tape measures: the cheap ones measure as accurately as the expensive ones. I was told that expensive calipers have better circuitry and don't burn through the batteries when they're "off". Is that not the case?
- varjag 4y agoCheapest calipers often have wobbly jaws that makes the stated DRO precision of it meaningless. A quick check is to close them, reset the display and do a few full scale motions. You'll often see the zero is not maintained.
- Blackthorn 4y agoThat's mostly the case. Anecdotal experience here has the cheap ones losing accuracy as the batteries drain, and of course when there's no notification of when your batteries are drained and not being able to actually turn them off, is a problem. I could live with the cheapies if I had to, but buying a Mitutoyo or even that nicer Shars import brand (Aventor) is just such a huge quality of life upgrade. Except for Harbor Freight. I absolutely love Harbor Freight but I will never use another set of calipers from them. The accuracy loss as the batteries started to drain was just ridiculous.
- abakker 4y agothere is a critical place that this is not consistent with the cheapies that the better ones get right: there are 4 ways to measure with a caliper - between the front jaws, outside the back jaws, the plunger on the bottom, and the ledge on the back/top. On cheap calipers these almost never match. On good ones they do. Buying the really bad ones from HF or similar doesn't necessarily produce inaccurate readings, but it means none of those 4 measures can be reliably compared.
- analog31 4y agoI tested a pair of Harbor Freight calipers on a set of gage blocks at work, and they were accurate. They don't always drive exactly to zero, as one other post mentioned. Something I did notice is that the newer Mitutoyo calipers at work have a much faster display update, making them considerably easier to use. They also had more smooth motion, though this is subjective. For home use, bike repair, etc., the cheapies are good enough. Given that my colleagues prefer digital, I've got the cast-away dial calipers and am perfectly happy with them, plus an old Mitutoyo vernier at home that I use, just because.
- bityard 4y agoWhen it comes to basically all measurement tools that a hobbyist would need, the top three companies are Starrett, Brown & Sharpe, and Mitutoyo. If you're just starting out or are limited in funds, buy these used from eBay or estate sales. If you need it to last for one project, go to Harbor Freight and buy two (in case the first one is DOA). Personally, I like dial calipers because they are just as accurate, don't need batteries, and can sometimes tell you things that a digital one can't.
- Blackthorn 4y agoGood luck buying a Mitutoyo from eBay that isn't a fake. I won't buy measuring tools from anything except a factory authorized retailer anymore.
- dreamcompiler 4y agoI'd be skeptical about using the Amazon link in the article for the same reason.
- anon_cow1111 4y agoI usually prefer analog-everything but I always found dial calipers to be extremely drop-sensitive. Like a "shock-proof" set from work developed wiggly-needle syndrome after being dropped about 6-8 inches onto a sheet metal desk and could never really be zeroed perfectly again. By contrast a $30 digital set from Lowes or HD got flung into the concrete by a falling part and was still accurate to a few thousandths at least. (I did notice the "inside" gauges have slight variance between brand new pairs though, so the manufacturing tolerances probably aren't the best)
- porknubbins 4y agoGood call on digital. My cheap analog ones are exremely inconvenient compared to digital ones I’ve seen. Typically I do something like measure a bolt, realize I’m just looking at a bunch of unmarked lines, go back to zero and get in the ballpark then slowly open while counting mm lines until I’m just around the object.
- Ancapistani 4y agoI’d argue that most cheap calipers are fine - if you need the precision of a Mitutoyo, you should be using a micrometer anyhow.
- blagie 4y agoI'd agree. With calipers and multimeters, I find having multiple so there's always one on-hand beats precision. There is room for precision equipment on both fronts, but the number of times I need that level of accuracy is maybe 1% of uses. Having several is often handy. I often want to monitor several voltages at once, or have calipers locked to multiple lengths. That's more general too. Power drills and drivers too -- there are times for a really good hammer drill or what-not, but having one versus not having one is a much bigger difference, and on most projects, the convenience of having several is huge. If I have four, I can do a whole row of screws without swapping bits: - 1/8 pilot hole for the bottom piece; - 1/4 hole for the top piece; - 1/2 hole for the countersink; and - driver for the screw Four cheap drivers beats one good driver.
- Ancapistani 4y ago> Power drills and drivers too Yep. I have a bunch of Milwaukee M18 Fuel tools, because I apparently gotta catch ‘em all. I find that I very rarely use the hammer drill. All of my drill bits are hex shank, so I just chuck them into my hex driver. It’s way faster and “good enough” for almost all use cases.
- mikewarot 4y agoMost digital calipers use a capacitive stripe to measure distances, which consist of 0.1" grounded stripes on 0.2" centers. Using the same principle as a Vernier caliper, this gets interpolated into resolution down to quite small distances, even in the cheapest harbor freight model. Metric/Imperial scales are done in software. You can use a vinyl cutter to make a pattern in the same dimensions, and stick it on a conductive back, and make an arbitrary sized caliper, subject to the accuracy of the pattern once applied. You could also just machine it with a 0.1" end mill.
- phkahler 4y agoWhen I got a 3d printer the very next thing was a digital caliper. Just a cheap $10 to $20 is fine since FDM print resolution is much less accurate. They are a required tool. My next tool will be a profile gauge.
- _carbyau_ 4y agoAs a fellow FDM printing amateur, tools most used are: - digital caliper. The ultimate reference measurement device. - feeler gauge. To check bed levelling but also prints. I hadn't considered a profile gauge but will now look into it. Thanks!
- sokoloff 4y agoA caliper is not considered an ultimate reference measurement device. (In the scale of 3D printing, it’s perfectly adequate for that non-precision job, but they’re rarely spec’d for anything better than 0.001”.)
- serf 4y agodon't buy Mitu's on Amazon (the website links amazon referrals) they're famously counterfeited.
- causality0 4y agoI saved a lot of headaches by just getting a set of digital calipers with a solar panel so I never have to worry about the battery. I really wish someone made a set of micro-vernier calipers that are small enough to fit on a keychain.
- mikewarot 4y ago>I really wish someone made a set of micro-vernier calipers that are small enough to fit on a keychain. I'd really like to know what you mean by that. Obviously the Vernier scale can't shrink, so you're going to be limited to an inch or two of range, and all the sharp edges common to calipers aren't pocket friendly. Something fold-up, or that has a few pieces to snap together?
- causality0 4y agoTwo inches of range would be perfect for sizing bits, fasteners, bolts, screws, etc. I tried carrying a messograf pen for a while but they're wildly overbuilt and heavy. Amazon, eBay etc sell a caliper keychain but the tolerances are too loose for it to be useful and it has no vernier scale.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- grae_QED 4y agoYou know what has the same, and even sometimes better, precision, requires no batteries, lasts a life time, and is usually a lot cheaper? Classic analog vernier slide calipers. You really don't need anything that fancy the get some exceptionally precise measurements.
- Doxin 4y agoDigital calipers do have the advantage of being much harder to misread, as well as the fact that you can do some neat math tricks with em. E.g need the center distance between two same-sized holes? measure the hole diameter of one, zero the calipers, and then measure the outside-outside distance of the holes. The caliper will read the center distance.
- snypher 4y agoThey also have an ABS button sometimes for that trick without changing the zero point!
- Doxin 4y agoClearly you own more expensive digital calipers than I do ;) Once you get to 0.01mm, which even fairly cheap calipers get down to, you're at the limit of how precisely calipers can measure anyways, so why bother going with the really fancy expensive ones?
- hjkl0 4y agoThis is a listicle based on nothing. The author did not use or compare any of the products. It’s easy to see this because no author is credited. All the information in the article is from the product descriptions. There is zero value here.
- Blackthorn 4y agoUnfortunately, while the Practical Machinist forums are excellent, their website itself is worthless.
- walterbell 4y agoSome of the metalworker comments at the bottom of the page are useful, as were most HN comments. Links to better articles would be appreciated.
- xtiansimon 4y agoI bought a cheap <$10 Vernier caliper for 3D printing, and it’s such a trip to use. I’m not an industrial design student working all hours, blurry-eyed; I don’t see the need for WYSIWYG digital readout. But I guess if I was professional industrial designer I’d want to impress my colleagues with the caliber of my caliper. Haha. All joking aside. For 3D printing and the amount I use it, I don’t see reason to spend more.