3 ms·
My rebuttal to the poorly considered Chinese Room thought experiment: I'm going to use this Wikipedia text as the backdrop: > Searle then supposes that he is
by kazinator 4y ago
My rebuttal to the poorly considered Chinese Room thought experiment:
I'm going to use this Wikipedia text as the backdrop:
> Searle then supposes that he is in a closed room and has a book with an English version of the computer program, along with sufficient papers, pencils, erasers, and filing cabinets. Searle could receive Chinese characters through a slot in the door, process them according to the program's instructions, and produce Chinese characters as output, without understanding any of the content of the Chinese writing. If the computer had passed the Turing test this way, it follows, says Searle, that he would do so as well, simply by running the program manually.
> Searle asserts that there is no essential difference between the roles of the computer and himself in the experiment. Each simply follows a program, step-by-step, producing behavior that is then interpreted by the user as demonstrating intelligent conversation. However, Searle himself would not be able to understand the conversation. ("I don't speak a word of Chinese," he points out.)
The reason he would not be able to follow the conversation is that he's being the CPU, and not the computer program. The computer program (according to the Strong AI hypothesis) understands the conversation, evidence for it being that it can converse with Chinese speakers and convince them that they are conversing with a human being.
The content of the papers stuffed into the filing cabinets to keep track of the program state contains (somehow) the representation and behavior of understanding, not John Searle, the pencil-and-paper-pushing executor of the program (who doesn't even hold the content of those papers in his own mind, let alone failing to understand any of it.)
Searle misunderstands computers and software; his argument amounts to the assertion that it is the CPU which must necessarily be the seat of the computer's intellect, and since we know that CPU to be a very simple machine with no understanding of the data flowing through it, there is no intellect, QED.
Fact is that, in the thought experiment, the Chinese Room as a whole appears to be intelligent; it can converse with a Chinese speaker and pass the Turing test. That's what is intelligent: the room, and not the clerk sitting inside it who pushes the pencil.
It's like insisting that individual neurons must be intelligent (conscious, sentient, ...).
By Searles' argument, a computer doesn't actually know how to browse the web because an Intel chip doesn't understand what is TCP/IP or HTML.
I can't believe this twaddle was ever taken seriously, but that's philosophy for you.
If you want a good reason why kids should learn to code, there it is: so they have a fighting chance at not being duped by stuff like this.