2 ms·
One country unilaterally decides that it is fine to pollute the sky for everyone else in the name of profit. One company decides to produce more and more witho
by palata 4y ago
One country unilaterally decides that it is fine to pollute the sky for everyone else in the name of profit.
One company decides to produce more and more without giving a damn about their ecological impact, in the name of profit.
Hardly sounds like a revolution to me.
- oxplot 4y ago> One country unilaterally decides that it is fine to pollute the sky for everyone else in the name of profit. One country allows the entire world to use its global navigation system "for free", build businesses on that technology, save people's lives and benefit from it. One company brings usable Internet connection, the electricity of the 21st century, to anywhere in the world, with a fixed price, often lower than the existing inferior or non-existing ones. > One company decides to produce more and more without giving a damn about their ecological impact, in the name of profit. One company will have accelerated our escape from extinction. > in the name of profit If Space was such a profitable industry, it'd be as crowded as ad and social network markets. It's the exact opposite. To claim it's all for profit, is to admit you shouldn't be trusted with anything money related, as you'd probably lose it all in a blink.
- palata 4y agoOh right, the US built GPS, one of the few GNSS systems out there! Yeah my bad, then private US companies should be allowed to pollute space, it's not the problem of the rest of the world! > One company will have accelerated our escape from extinction You mean by sending a few chosen people in space? Or do you believe that connecting smart devices to satellites will somehow solve the climate crisis? xD > it'd be as crowded as ad and social network What's your definition of crowded? I don't feel like there are thousands of successful social networks or ad companies out there... But I get your point: SpaceX is a nonprofit with the purpose of solving the climate crisis by launching as many rockets as they can to fill the sky with satellites. No profit planned, no investors, nothing. My mistake.
- oxplot 4y ago> Oh right, the US built GPS, one of the few GNSS systems out there! When US opened up GPS for civilian use, there was NO other GNSS. Other GNSSes exist BECAUSE of GPS. > You mean by sending a few chosen people in space? This is how every new thing starts. Do you think people one day had no cars and then suddenly a billion people were driving cars the next day? No! It started with a few who had the money and believed in the future to invest in cars, and further few who could afford to buy cars and were OK with the initial dangerous, horribly unreliable vehicles that the most ill horse of the time would be superior to. If you read up on the history of literally any tech, that's how they start, and literally that's how they are received (e.g. waste of money, more important things to do, few chosen ones, etc.). > I don't feel like there are thousands of successful social networks Your feelings bears nothing on reality. Go do a app search for dating/social apps and you'll see hundreds, with dozens being pretty successful. > But I get your point: SpaceX is a nonprofit with the purpose of solving the climate crisis No non-profit will ever solve anything at this magnitude, by definition. This is what it boils down to: - You need to have a plan to make profit - in order to attract investors to give you money, - so you can pay talented people to join your cause. Yes some of your employees are there because they believe in the cause and they're fine with lower pay. But that's a minority. Majority of your workforce will want challenge and good pay or you'll lose them to the competition making social network apps for iPhone. I'm baffled that most people can't follow this simple logic. > My mistake. Never too late to learn.
- palata 4y ago> No non-profit will ever solve anything at this magnitude, by definition. So when I say they make that for profit, you disagree, and when I say (sarcastically) that they don't want to make profit, you say the opposite again? Choose your camp. Mine is that SpaceX exists because it is profitable. Then one thing that would be worth considering is that technology is the problem today. You seem to consider that cars made the world a better place, that's your opinion. But it would be hard to argue that the current climate crisis is not caused by technology. You're just blindly hoping that more of it will magically solve the problem which is: technology is destroying life on Earth. Because we can do something cool (nobody denies that SpaceX is cool) doesn't mean we should do it.