4 ms·
I tried this out for a bit and it was definitely interesting. For flowcharts that are closer to a pure tree it's blazing fast and simple to work with, more than
by zamadatix 4y ago
I tried this out for a bit and it was definitely interesting. For flowcharts that are closer to a pure tree it's blazing fast and simple to work with, more than anything else I can remember trying. Though for more complicated flowcharts that break out and remerge it can be very confusing to both edit or read. If the the tree-style or pure linear is more your use case I highly recommend trying it out despite its demo state, even if just to export the topology into a tool that will draw it fancier if this isn't "wowing" you on the looks side of things.
The "make a salad" example is an exception to the above but I think it gets away with it because the branched paths are of equal length and overall it's not too large. Once you get even slightly off this, like the Mars example where a branch is 1 box longer than the other, it can easily fall apart. Such branching and reconnecting topologies tend to result in things in the editor moving around on you a lot while you're trying to create the paths which can be disorienting as well. Other options such as code2flow which have already been mentioned here can get away with as much on the fly restructuring as they want because they separate graph construction and graph representation in the UI whereas this combines them. Maybe an option here would be a toggle to disable overall graph auto-layout but keeping the keyboard shortcuts and auto default placements? Or maybe it's just best to focus on where it's unique.
An "easy win" feature add for knotend might be a set of shortcuts to change the symbol and maybe some automatic ones like terminals or decisions that get set based on their connectivity in the drawing (unless otherwise manually set). As it is now everything is a rectangle which typically means "process" in flowcharts.
- escot 4y agoIn terms of the lines crossing, you’re right I have to work on the algo. It’s just not been something I prioritized because its not often a problem until you get into larger graphs. I’d like to avoid manual layout because I haven’t found a way to support that without sacrificing speed. But I dont disagree it would be nice if theres a clever way to do it.